Discos
Muffled emotions
Olivier Messiaen: Visions de l’Amen. John Ogdon and Brenda Lucas, piano. Recording Producer: Michael Bremner. Publisher: Durand Editions S.A./G. Ricordi & Co. (London) Ltd. Licensed from Decca Music Group Limited. One compact disc, total playing time 51 minutes. Recorded at Decca Studio No.3, West Hampstead, London, 29-31 December 1970. Explore Records EXP0013
Composed in 1943, Visions de l’Amen consists of seven movements (symbolic of the act of Creation), and is the first of Messiaen’s works to "make use of a cyclic theme [the “theme of Creation”, as Messiaen called it] as a musical and symbolic point of reference for the work as a whole". From the soft ecstasy of Amen du Désir to the frenetic anguish of Amen de l’Agonie de Jésus, this work requires not only a full range of emotions from its performers, but also a transcendental technique.
The relatively poor sound quality aside, the current performance gets off to a promising start. The ensemble to begin with is outstanding, and a slower tempo than that indicated by the composer is taken, the effect being to produce a real sense of timelessness. It is worth mentioning that there is a particular cluster of rhythmic errors in this first movement, but the effect of these is relatively minor.
The clever second movement, Amen des étoiles, de la planète à l’anneau is briefly, but clearly explained in the booklet notes by Robert Sherlaw Johnson. In the third section of this movement, a rhythm of sixteen values combined with a melodic fragment of five notes results in the rhythm of the melody constantly changing - helping to evoke “the life of the planets”, as Messiaen puts it in his preface. The considerable technical difficulties of the movement are evidently of little concern to the pianists. However, a disappointment comes in the reprise of the opening theme, when the duo significantly slows the tempo - this decision effectively weakens the character and impact of the piece. A greater disappointment is the third movement, Amen de l’Agonie de Jésus, depicting the suffering of Christ in the garden of Gethsemane. The opening rhythm is rushed, and a faster-than-indicated tempo in the usually devastating coda abolishes the feeling of anguish.
Movement Four, Amen du désir, is more successful. Once again, Ogdon and Lucas choose to play slightly slower than Messiaen’s metronome mark, movingly expressing the composer’s ecstatic depiction of divine love. The next movement, Amen des Anges, des Saints, du chant des oiseaux, finds Messiaen using birdsong to convey feelings of joy – he writes in his preface that the true songs of nightingales, blackbirds, chaffinches, and warblers are used. The final two movements, Amen du Jugement and Amen de la Consommation, "symbolise the judgement and final union with God". One of the most impressive moments of the whole recording comes towards the end of the final Amen, when the solid chorale dissolves into an almost Debussian portrait of peeling bells, with Ogdon and Lucas managing to maintain the essential forward movement of the piece.
Despite such fine moments, however, this recording has been surpassed both in terms of recording quality and emotional intensity by the Hill/Frith duo on Unicorn (licensed to Regis), and Osborne/Roscoe on Hyperion.
Comentarios