Discos

A Superfluous Messiah?

Matthias Range
Georg Friedrich Handel, Messiah HWV 56 (1750 version). Kersin Avemo, soprano; Patricia Bardon, alto; Lawrence Zazzo, countertenor; Kobie van Rensburg, tenor; Neal Davies, bass. The Choir of Clare College (Cambridge). Freiburger Barockorchester. René Jacobs, conductor. Direction artistique (producer): Martin Sauer; sound engineer: René Möller. Two CDs, 2 h 18’; recorded in January 2006, Paulussaal, Freiburg (Germany). Harmonia Mundi HMC 901928.29
0,0001402 There are probably few pieces of music that have been recorded as often as Handel’s Messiah. And there are some great recordings by some of the best performers and conductors ever. Thus, one might justifiably be surprised by a new recording and wonder: why do we need yet another one? Indeed, we shall bear this question in mind and come back to it later. Very recently, Naxos released its Messiah recording with the Choir of New College, Oxford. This praised itself as being the first ever recording of the 1751 version, in which Handel used trebles not only for the choruses but for the arias as well. And now we have René Jacobs’ recording, which features the 1750 version of Messiah. All the different versions of the oratorio seem to justify the abundance of recordings.

Over the last decade or so, Jacobs made himself a name as a conductor – having achieved some fame as a counter-tenor, he must have heard an inner calling to stand on the other side of the band. In singing as in conducting, Handel is one of Jacobs’ favourite composers – his recording of Giulio Cesare on Harmonia Mundi was well received. However, he is also interested in English choral music in general, and produced recordings of Henry Purcell’s Dido and Aeneas and John Blow’s Venus and Adonis. Thus it was perhaps a logical consequence that he now went on to try his fingers on Messiah.

As in all his earlier recordings, Jacobs’ Messiah displays a refreshingly new approach in all respects: tempi, instrumentation, phrasing, dynamics etc… However, to say it straight away, after several tracks his endless mannerisms turn out to be quite tiring. Jacobs’ personal style inevitably reminds of William Christie and others in the frontline of French Baroque music. Jacobs’ approach with sharp contrasts, distinct sounds, sharp rhythms and phrasings would suit a Lully motet extremely well – shame though he did not record one of these. Instead, he turned towards the apogee of English choral music, to Messiah. Admittedly, there are some nice things in this recording. For instance, Jacobs employs a lute in the continuo, a feature which is authentic and gives a nice change to the sound. At the beginning of Their sound is gone up Jacobs intrudes a short improvised scale on the organ to start off the chorus – that is a nice feature, it sounds natural and convincing. However, at other places, his ‘additions’ seem a bit pointless: for instance the short something in the strings at the end of the chorus Lift up your heads – and more will be seen later.

The soloists are invariably good. Especially noteworthy is the alto Patricia Bardon: she sounds like a very good counter-tenor, and this is meant as a compliment! Indeed, in the aria He shall feed his flock, where she sings together with the counter-tenor Lawrence Zazzo, the deception is perfect: one can hardly tell who is who, so well do the two voices complement and match each other. Kerstin Avemo makes a nice soprano, and her technique in the collaratura of Rejoice greatly could hardly be better (ok, she does slow down a bit, but that is forgivable). However, overall, her voice is a bit too thin for a Messiah solo soprano, which leads to the effect that she sounds a bit helpless as the angel announcing the birth of Christ the Saviour to the astonished shepherds. Higginbottom’s New College treble soloists have a fuller tone…! That said, in the third part of the oratorio she suddenly has a much fuller tone, which she displays in the aria I know that my redeemer liveth – pity though that this aria, which recalls the individual’s confidence in the Redeemer and in eternal life (the beginning of this aria is engraved on Handel’s monument in Westminster Abbey), could do with the more intimate, ‘thin’ singing that she produced in the first part. Her operatic interpretation of the ‘worms destroy[ing] this body’ is a bit too much word painting.

Kobie van Rensburg is a convincing tenor, and he shows some excellent singing in the aria Thou shalt break them with a rod of iron – indeed, he conveys the text much better than many other tenors in earlier recordings. Then there is the bass, Neal Davies. He has not only a good technique, but also a very pleasant, very sonorous voice. For his aria The trumpet shall sound Jacobs surprises with a rather brisk tempo, nevertheless, with Davies’ singing the whole turns into good music and is a pleasure to listen to. The choir of Clare College sings with perfection and wonderful attention to detail – however, one cannot but remark that boys choirs produce a more familiar, and perhaps more appropriate, sound for Handel’s oratorios. It is not understandable why Jacobs makes the Clare College choir sing a repertoire that is so much associated with a different choir sound – he could perhaps rather have done some new, unusual music.

The Hallelujah Chorus is in strange contrast to the interpretation of the rest of the oratorio: here the style is much softer (i.e. less French). Admittedly, one may assume that no conductor would dare to perform this chorus totally against the expectations of the audience – it is simply too famous. However, Jacobs does put his mark on this piece as well: he introduces a number of subtle dynamic contrasts (most prominently on the initial Hallelujah shouts and on the long notes of ‘King of Kings’). Unfortunately, these appear a bit inappropriate for this music: like it or not, the Hallelujah chorus is a piece of utterly majestic and representative music, celebrating the ‘King of Kings’ with trumpets and timpani – really, this is not the place for such an ‘intimate’, individualist approach. And in this piece again, there is a little bit of improvisation: in the last bars the first trumpet ornates its line with some filling notes. Yes, this is a nice idea, improvisations were a common feature in eighteenth century performances; however, this is the only one in the whole chorus, and it is very short and unspectacular. In the end, this episode seems a bit forced and, together with the dynamic ‘playing around’, appears to be completely superfluous. Jacobs’ performance does not justify either of these modifications musically, and hence they appear as if they were introduced simply to make this Hallelujah Chorus different to other recordings.

However, this reveals a general problem of this recording: all the tiny improvisations, changes, dynamic variations etc. give the impression that Jacobs tries to justify why he produced yet another recording of Messiah. As stated initially, it is a very valid question why one should produce another recording of a piece that has been recorded as often as Messiah. It is regrettable for the composition, when the effort to produce something ‘new’ overshadows musical logic and taste.

The design of the whole product cannot be described other than ‘stylish’: the two discs are well packed in a carton box, nicely decorated with Jan Provost’s Allégorie du Christ from 1510, which also adorns the discs themselves. There is no plastic or shiny metal – this is an ‘environmentally friendly Messiah’… The recording sounds good and all the details of the performance come out very well; the reverb of the recording location (the ‘Paulussaal’ in Freiburg, Germany) seems ideal for the number of singers and musicians and their music. The elaborate booklet includes the whole text of the oratorio as well as good notes by Pierre Degott, which are given in French, English, and German; with another informative English contribution by the Handel specialist Ruth Smith. However, the devil is in the detail, as the saying goes: for instance, for the beginning of the annunciation to the shepherds scene, the booklet gives the text as ‘There were shepherds abiding in the field’ – in both the track listing and the full text. On the CD, however, the soprano sings ‘AND there were shepherds’. (Handel used both forms of the text in his performances – depending on the version).

Overall, I would not recommend this recording to someone who is looking for ‘one’ Messiah recording. No, to anyone who is just looking for a good Messiah recording, I would point to the New College recording on Naxos (which also has some weak points, but these are more than balanced out given that it costs half as much as Jacobs’ recording). Nevertheless, Jacob’s recording will be an interesting and valuable addition to an enthusiast’s collection. Anyone who is bored of his ‘traditional’ Messiah, or just intrigued by innovations, may well enjoy this new release.
Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.