Reino Unido

Osiris and Barba Azul

Andrew Maisel
Osiris and Barba Azul
Londres, domingo, 11 de mayo de 2008.
The Barbican. Arnold Schoenberg, Die gluckliche Hand. Matthias Pintscher, Osiris (UK premiere). Bela Bartok, Duke Bluebeard's Castle. Michelle DeYoung (Judith), Peter Fried (Duke Bluebeard). BBC Singers. London Symphony Orchestra. Pierre Boulez, conductor
0,0001382 In her programme notes welcoming audiences to the two concerts given by Pierre Boulez as part of the LSO's Great Conductor's series, Kathryn McDowell singles out Bluebeard's Castle as one of "The most powerful operas of the 20th Century" referring to Bluebeard as "sinister" and Judith as "the unfortunate wife" . Nothing very controversial about that -the most common perception being that this is simply a reworking of the old fairytale of the evil Bluebeard and Judith as another innocent and over-inquisitive young bride.

And yet Bartok' s view is to blur this distinction between good and evil into something much more ambiguous and ‘much’ more human. It's certainly possible to perceive Judith as the villain of the piece and Bluebeard as the anti-hero whose suffering and torment is painfully unravelled as each door is opened. Indeed Bartok's most moving and sympathetic music is reserved for Bluebeard. And if anyone wanted to be persuaded that it's Bluebeard pain than brings us to tears at the end rather than Judith's fate, then this performance would have convinced them of that.

Much of this shift of sympathies lay with the moving interpretation of Bluebeard by the Hungarian bass Peter Fried. Despite possessing a voice of limited power (more exposed in the Schoenberg) which struggled at times to make itself heard above the orchestra, he imbued Bluebeard with a sense of dignity and nobility which almost allowed us to forget this is a man who is essentially a wife-collector. Still and with minimal movement of body or hands, Fried beautifully conveyed Bluebeard's growing desperation as the opening of each door revealed more horror . By the end his face was contorted with anguish, his soul laid bare.

Michelle DeYoung's grinning Judith was quite frankly a bit of a let down. Whether her fixed smile was meant to convey her love for Bluebeard or something more sinister we shall never know . Fixed smile or not this was a performance of two faces - a smile and a look of horror . Although vocally secure she never convinced as a woman acting out of love.

Boulez and the LSO delivered - almost. The French conductor's spacious reading laid out a glorious palette of tonal colouring and the near perfect orchestral balance allowed every detail of the score to stand out. There was at times a lack of edge and bite which gives this opera its very sense of unease and the grandeur of the fifth's door's opening was distinctly underwhelming. But Boulez is a master of understanding the architecture of a score and the build up to the furious climax at the end of the 7th door was masterly secured by an LSO on top form.

One other gripe, the absence of any reference to the prologue. Often left out of concert performances , it's a vital pointer to showing that this is a very different take on the fairy tale and it 's a clear reminder to the audience not to take the action on stage too literally. This is, after all, an opera literally of mind games.

Earlier Boulez had given us a fabulously shaped Die glückliche Hand, Schoenberg's 20 minute stage piece in the mould of his earlier Erwartung. It may be less well than known than its illustrious relative but this performance suggests is no less worthy. It's an extravagantly orchestrated piece for large orchestra , a choir of 12 and male soloist, Peter Fried again. Boulez elicited some marvellous playing from the LSO which revelled in the expressionistic and nightmarish atmospheres conjured up by Schoenberg. It's a piece which in the wrong hands could sound a mess but Boulez 's clarity of line and perfect balance turned the piece into an exhilarating experience.

Matthias Pintscher's Osiris was similarly successful. One of Germany most renowned composers, this was the work's UK premiere and Boulez and the LSO did the piece full justice. Inspired by the Egyptian God Osiris is another exotically scored piece for a large ensemble with formidable parts for the trumpet and the contrabassoon, both of which received outstanding performances from the LSO soloists.
Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.