Ópera y Teatro musical
Strauss: As good as it gets!
In the Prologue we see how an opera company and a group of trashy commedia dell’arte actors are told by a patron that they have to put on a show together, the only condition of which is that it should finish by 9pm so the fireworks can start. As you would expect, what follows is an argument on whether comedy or drama should prevail, on whether art is a serious endeavour or else meant to be enjoyed as sheer spectacle. Strauss’s verdict comes in the form of an Opera (after the interval) in which Ariadne complains about her abandonment by Theseus while Zerbinetta, the slutty commedia dell’arte girl, tries to persuade her that life is too short to worry too much about one man only and that she should be looking for someone else.
Musically, both worlds are represented as antithetic: Ariadne’s music is pompous, Wagnerian, made of long lyrical phrases and wrapped in a delicate orchestration. Zerbinetta’s is playful, Rossinian, often made of choppy phrases and coloratura and accompanied by an orchestra which seems to be playing constant staccato. Audiences take Ariadne’s impossibly old-fashioned stance with a pinch of salt and cannot but enjoy laughing at Zerbinetta’s irreverent attitude. The opera, however, ends with a duet between Ariadne and Bacchus in which the libretto and the music are as sublime (or should I say sugary) as one could imagine. Their overblown romantic idiom seems to prevail over comic playfulness.
Thus, Strauss and his librettist Hugo von Hofmannsthal criticise a musical and poetic style, and then move onto writing a long opera in that very style. The audience, mesmerised by the farce, eventually endorses (and indeed enjoys) the tricks presented by this musical work and leaves the theatre convinced of having witnessed a fight between musical styles in which no one wins. Ariadne, however, is given preference in the end. In sum, an opera which is a parody of opera seria ends up stealing the show and becoming an opera seria in itself.
Therefore, it is the sheer self-awareness with which the fight between two styles is presented that makes Strauss’s and Hoffmansthal’s piece so incredibly modern. They understood that the future (and indeed the present) of their art was not to be left to old-fashioned ideas of progress (a late eighteenth-century substitute for God), but to ambiguity and, ultimately, the audience’s choice. In the end, the message seems to be “enjoy opera the way you want and don’t worry so much about dogmatic, prescriptive ideas about what you should be listening to”. After decades in which the idea of progress has contributed to the divorce of audiences and new music, it is refreshing to look back to the beginning of the twentieth century and ask ourselves whether Strauss was really unhistorical or else the avant-garde was. After all, it was this intellectual movement which really did not click with its own historical frame. In contrast, Strauss has not gone out of fashion.
At the centre of this fight between art as sublime or simple spectacle (Apollo and Eros) is the Composer, a character of the Prologue sung by a mezzo-soprano. With this character Strauss and Hoffmansthal poke fun at the quintessentially romantic idea of the artist as a moody, oversensitive and hysterical individual who cannot talk about anything but his work. The Composer does not take well the news that his opera about the torment of abandonment will be performed alongside a comedy. Consequently, he throws a fit. Strauss and Hoffmansthal add a twist to the depiction of the Composer, since he eventually falls in love with the most vulgar of characters, Zerbinetta. In the process of selling himself (i.e. of accepting that his sublime opera be played alongside the comedy), the Composer finds justification for his compromise by sublimating Zerbinetta, who goes from being referred to with some condescension to being worshiped by the artist. It is not only his change of mind that is entertaining, but how the Composer goes about making it seem as though he is not selling himself. Strauss and Hoffmansthal seem to say “thus do all composers” (così fan tutti).

Voigt as Ariadna and Smith as Bacchus.
© 2008 by Clive Barda
© 2008 by Clive Barda
Zerbinetta, impressively sung by Gillian Keith, does not change. As someone says in the Prologue, she is playing herself. Her main task is to be tarty, floating about and annoying Ariadne. This character is, on the other hand, more complex, since she is an opera diva in the Prologue and an operatic character, Ariadne, in the Opera. This duality could not be better served. Indeed, firstly, Deborah Voigt was as “divine” as a diva can get and then showed some restraint when playing Ariadne. In fact, her portrayal of the diva was not less slutty than Zerbinetta’s. The difference -the huge difference- is that she was not playing herself in the Opera and had, therefore, to change. Voigt seemed to be enjoying playing the self-conscious diva because a diva she is. She seemed to be telling Covent Garden, as her character in the Prologue does, “don’t you know who I am?” At that point in the opera some people in the audience giggled. This had to happen, since we all still remember the reasons why Voigt did not sing Ariadne at Covent Garden four years ago.
The soprano’s version of the story is that Covent Garden deemed her as too fat to wear a tiny black dress in the Prologue and therefore fired her. After dangerous yet (I must say) successful gastric surgery, Voigt looked sensual in the infamous black dress. In the fight between Covent Garden and Voigt, as in Ariadne auf Naxos, one does not know who won. On the one hand, she is back and has triumphed. In spite of her often strained top notes, Voigt sang an extremely elegant Ariadne and a fantastically diva-like diva, thus portraying her two characters masterfully. On the other hand, she is back because she has indeed lost weight. Perhaps I should say that the ones who have won are the spectators. Now we can enjoy Voigt’s superb rendition of Ariadne and four years ago we were given the opportunity to listen to a no-less-magnificent soprano, Anne Schwanewilms.
The diva’s very own Prince Charming, Bacchus, was sung by Robert Dean Smith, whom I had not seen at Covent Garden since Lohengrin, five years ago. His technically flawless effusion of hyper-inflated romanticism was duly rewarded by the audience with a well-deserved ovation. He is indeed one of the great helden-tenors of our time, if not “the helden-tenor of our time”.
The icing on the cake was Mark Elder’s conducting (or should I say, Sir Mark Elder, since he has just been knighted by the Queen). As is always the case with this conductor of conductors, he was at the service of the action. Every gesture, every phrase was carefully crafted to make what was going on in the plot believable. What is more, Elder made Strauss’s opera sound curvaceous, lush (as it should be) and self-consciously precious. A real treat!
Comentarios