Reino Unido

Chuck out the chintz (II)

Ditlev Rindom
Chuck out the chintz (II)
London, jueves, 16 de julio de 2009.
The Royal Opera House, Covent Garden. Giacomo Puccini, Tosca. Jonathan Kent, director. Paul Brown, designs. Mark Henderson, lighting. Amanda Echalaz (Tosca), Marcello Giordani (Mario Cavaradossi), Bryn Terfel (Scarpia), Martyn Hill (Spoletta), Kostas Smoriginas (Angelotti), Jeremy White (Sacristan), John Morrissey (Gaoler). The Royal Opera House Orchestra and Chorus. Renato Balsadonna, chorus master. Jacques Lacombe, conductor.
0,0001532 Angela Gheorghiu cancelled on 16 July and was replaced by Amanda Echalaz. Mundoclasico.com reviewer Ditlev Rindom, then at the Royal Opera House, reports.

When Anna Netrebko cancelled the majority of her performances of La Traviata at Covent Garden last year (citing bronchitis), those audience members who decided to attend were thrilled to discover an outstanding replacement in the form of Ermonela Jaho. The Albanian soprano possessed not only the necessary flexibility, dramatic power and tonal beauty for the part, but also sang with heart-rending conviction and intelligence, making it clear that she was more than good enough to be employed as a principal in her own right. Upon hearing that Gheorghiu had in turn cancelled her final appearance as Tosca, hopes were therefore high that the Royal Opera would find a similarly talented deputy for the ailing diva (as well as that swine flu had not finally struck the operatic community).

As it turned out, Amanda Echalaz gave a highly commendable, tonally-refined performance which gave much pleasure, without quite banishing the memory of what-might-have-been. Having received rave reviews for her interpretation at Opera Holland Park last summer and now in line to sing the role at the English National Opera, she knows the music backwards and impressed with her vocal warmth, careful phrasing and the apparent ease with which slipped into the theatrics of the production at such short notice. Her creamy, flickery timbre was well-suited to the part (if occasionally sounding pushed in the large auditorium) and there were many beautiful moments, particularly as the evening went on and she relaxed into the occasion. Somewhat inevitably given the circumstances, there were synchronisation problems between her and the conductor and in 'Vissi d’Arte' in particular one sensed that she was not entirely comfortable with the broad tempo adopted by Lacombe, as evinced by snatched breaths in the middle of phrases. Nonetheless, it was a fine performance, and Echalaz certainly deserves to be re-engaged at the House, if perhaps in less high-profile roles for the immediate future.



The flipside to having missed the earlier performances was that I was fortunate enough to see the original tenor, Marcello Giordani, who himself had previously cancelled due to illness (there is clearly something in the air at Covent Garden at the moment). This proved to be something of a mixed blessing. Giordani possesses an impressive instrument with truly blistering top notes and, in addition, has a larger-than-life stage presence to match. Musically, however, much of his singing came straight from the school of can belto, and his throaty entrance aria especially had me wondering whether he had completely recovered from his earlier ailment. Things improved considerably in the final act and his hushed 'E Lucevan le stele', vocally energised even at pianissimo, proved to be genuinely moving, making me wish his singing had been consistently at that same level. With such an exciting voice, it’s a shame that he too often settles for stock operatic gestures.

As Enrique Sacau has already stated, Bryn Terfel repeated his earlier success as Scarpia, leering and sadistic in the best fashion; I noted no problems with his singing in piano. Jacques Lacombe’s conducting was fluid and sensitive, rightly relishing the splendour and darkness of Puccini’s orchestration without drowning out the singers, and the smaller roles were all persuasively taken. Jonathan Kent’s production, though, remains hopelessly cluttered, a mess of candles, scaffolding and oversized bookshelves which had me thinking of the old Ikea slogan: “chuck out the chintz”. His staging neatly captures the murky atmosphere of Puccini’s masterwork, but otherwise he seems to me to have fallen into the classic trap of “theatre as film set”. If the taut drama of Tosca can teach us anything, it’s that nothing succeeds with an audience like a brutal economy of means.
Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.