Estados Unidos

Patricia Racette’s Trittico

Claudio Vellutini
Patricia Racette’s Trittico
San Francisco, martes, 15 de septiembre de 2009.
War Memorial Opera House. Giacomo Puccini. Il Trittico. James Robinson, director. Allen Moyer, set designer. Bruno Schwengl, costume designer. Christopher Maravich, light designer. Patricia Racette (Giorgetta, Suor Angelica, Lauretta), Paolo Gavanelli (Michele, Gianni Schicchi), Ewa Podleś (Princess), Brandon Jovanovich (Luigi), David Lomeli (A Lover, Rinuccio), Catherine Cook (La Frugola, Monitor, La Ciesca), Andrea Silvestrelli (Il Talpa, Simone), Rebekah Camm (Suor Genovieffa, Nella), Meredith Arwady (Abbess, Zita), Thomas Glenn (Song Vendor, Gherardo), Daveda Karanas (Mistress of the Novices), Matthew O’Neill (Il Tinca), Austin Kness (Marco), Jake Gardner (Betto), Tamara Wapinsky (A Lover, First Alms Sister), Leah Crocetto (Suor Dolcina), Heidi Melton (Nursing Sister), Daniela Mack (First Lay Sister), Renée Taum ( Novice), Levi Hernandez (Amantio de Nicolao), Kenneth Kellogg (Pinellino), Kyle Reidy (Gherardino), Dvora Djoraev (Second Alms Sister). San Francesco Opera Orchestra. San Francisco Girl Chorus. San Francisco Boys Chorus. Ian Robertson, chorus master. Patrick Summers, conductor
0,0002303 Puccini’s operas have always held a special place in the hearts of opera-lovers. Critics, on the other hand, have often voiced protest against his music, claiming that its accessibility is an easy way to please the ears of the many without engaging in the quest for a truly innovative musical language as other early-twentieth-century modernist composers were doing. Il Trittico (The Tryptic, a work made up of three one-act operas) has particularly suffered from this argument. Premiered at the New York Metropolitan in 1918, its reception had to cope with the ideas and aesthetic principles resulting from the devastating experience of World War I. In particular, the sentimentality and the mystic aura of Suor Angelica, the second “panel” of the Tryptic, could hardly fit in with the musical scenario of the post-war years. It comes as no surprise, then, that this was the first of the three operas to be dropped from the score when it was revived. Il tabarro (The Cloak) enjoyed a wider circulation than Suor Angelica, if only because the plot, representing a working-class drama, had more chance to survive in a time when socialism was spreading. In the end, only Gianni Schicchi, the closing opera, gained uninterrupted popularity, and was often revived together with other early-twentieth-century one-act works.

More recently, major theaters all over the world have tried to revive the whole Tryptic from time to time, but this choice is still today something of a special event. We must be grateful to the San Francisco Opera, then, for having chosen Il Trittico as the second title of its new season, thus letting the audience enjoy Puccini’s work in the original version. In stating this, I do not intend to endorse any kind of Werktreue towards operatic “texts”, but simply express my conviction that Il Trittico is an extremely coherent work despite its fragmentariness and variety of genres. It contains really beautiful music, and it represents a path through a contrasting set of circumstances and human emotions which frame the experience of death. In the first two operas, this path is built through a crescendo of pathos that reaches its climax in the last scene of Suor Angelica, and finds its catharsis in the black humor of Gianni Schicchi. In addition to being an opera about death, Il Trittico marvelously dramatizes many possible declinations of love (carnal, spiritual, and youthful) through the three main female characters: Giorgetta, Angelica, and Lauretta.

The choice of Patricia Racette as the interpreter of all three roles is another reason to be grateful to the San Francisco Opera. This production constituted Racette’s debut in the opera, but judging from both her dazzling vocal rendition and her compelling interpretation one would say that she has been performing the parts for years. Apart for a little over-emphasis of the Grand Guignol ascendance of Il tabarro in her portrayal of Giorgetta, no weak spots blemished her performance, not even the rather caricatural depiction that director James Robinson had imposed on the character of Lauretta. Racette, instead, resolved the role naturally, with vocal sobriety, and no touches of mannerism at all in the hackneyed aria ‘O mio babbino caro’. Her big moment, though, was Suor Angelica, where she paired all the best resources of her silvery, powerful voice with the subtleties of a nervous and yet burning phrasing. Her final scene of the opera, from the aria ‘Senza mamma, o bimbo’ to the end, was among one of the most powerful moments I have ever experienced at the opera.



Patricia Racette (Sister Angelica) and Ewa Podleś (The Princess) in Suor Angelica
© 2009 by Cory Weaver


Racette shared the success of Suor Angelica with another superb artist, the Polish alto Ewa Podleś. Podleś impersonated an impressive and glacial Princess. The astonishing range of her lower register, the steadiness of her sounds, and the power of her volumes are some of the qualities with which Podleś constructs her thrilling character. She not only sings, but thoroughly acts out her role through her voice. The rest of the cast framed professionally these two outstanding singers. Paolo Gavanelli (Michele, Gianni) reverted to his long-lasting stage experience to compensate for a voice eroded by a long career. Brandon Jovanovich (Luigi) is a young, promising lirico-spinto tenor, whose attractive look will be even more resourceful if he improves his acting skills. Also the Mexican tenor David Lomeli, who was in charge of the roles of Rinuccio in Gianni Schicchi and of a lover in Il tabarro, has interesting vocal qualities but a still too weak stage presence. All the minor roles, and especially the many nuns in Suor Angelica, were well served.

Suor Angelica is the opera that worked best also from a visual point of view. James Robinson set the action not in a convent, but instead in a hospital for children where the nuns are serving as nurses. This choice stresses the maternal feelings of the title role, and it transforms effectively the emotional severity of the convent parlor into the coldness of the empty hospital canteen. At the same time it frees the plot of the opera from overstated visual references to religious symbols: a Madonna statue and a cross at the right corner of the stage and the costumes of the nun/nurses are the only elements that refer to the sacred realm of the plot. I also found the exploitation of neon lights particularly effective as a means of differentiation between the bright collective scenes, and the last darker part of the opera, where Suor Angelica, alone on stage, decides to commit suicide.



Suor Angelica
© 2009 by Cory Weaver


Unfortunately, the other two operas were not as well staged as Suor Angelica. The setting of Gianni Schicchi had many interesting elements, starting with the imaginative marble decorations of the walls of Buoso’s bedroom, whose colors (white and dark green) referred to the exterior of Florence’s cathedral. Nonetheless, in my opinion the idea of rendering the witty, black irony of the plot through a series of belly-laugh gags is anything but pertinent. The setting of Il tabarro, instead, was simply dull both in its setting and in the way the plot was developed through the acting of the singers.



Gianni Schicchi
© 2009 by Cory Weaver

Patrick Summer’s musical direction was also quite inconsistent in the first opera, but it grew considerably starting from Suor Angelica, and reached its peak in the vivid rendition of Gianni Schicchi. Both the San Francisco Opera Orchestra and the San Francisco Girls and Boys Choruses provided a positive contribution to an evening which Patricia Racette’s memorable performance has made very dear to me.
Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.