Ópera y Teatro musical

That elusive five-star night

Enrique Sacau
That elusive five-star night
0,0001531 At the end of the latest revival of Moshe Leiser’s and Patrice Caurier’s superb production of Il turco in Italia by Rossini, I thought we had attended a nearly perfect operatic performance. The directors told us a story, wrapped in the customarily brilliant sets of Christian Fenouillat and costumes of Agostino Cavalca; the singers generally did an excellent job, with Alessandro Corbelli being the icing on the cake; and the conductor Maurizio Benini could not be faulted. After the show, there were loud bravos for almost everyone and the audience, feeling elated, left the theatre doubtless planning a swift return to the Royal Opera House. Who wouldn’t be keen to see this most Mediterranean, spicy take on Rossini’s own version of Così fan tutte?

As Don Geronio, Alessandro Corbelli oozed buffo pedigree which, in a way, made all the other singers on stage look like less consecrated actors. Sir Thomas Allen’s Prosdocimo was adequate, although the voice is in frank decline. As Don Narciso, Colin Lee sounded occasionally strained, but delivered some good punches. Ildebrando D’Arcangelo looks the part (i.e. he is a fine example of Southern European hunk) but seems less comfortable with the fast delivery of notes than he does when it comes to canto legato. Aleksandra Kurzak was a very good Fiorilla. In a way - and perhaps I’m harsh here - she disappointed me. In her latest appearance at the Royal Opera, as Matilde di Shabran, she wasn’t simply very good, but absolutely brilliant. As Fiorilla her emission was somewhat breathy and didn’t sound as though we were seeing a “bomb-proof” (my words last time) performance.Nonetheless, she acted charmingly, sang beautifully, didn’t awe but definitely conquered.

This is as good as it gets this year at the Royal Opera. Since the beginning of the season, we have seen some very good shows, some good ones and one car crash. Given Covent Garden’s usual standards, or my perception of them (which has gained me dozens of emails from our readers accusing me of having a blatant pro-Royal Opera bias), hitherto this hasn’t been a season to remember. We started off with a concert performance of Donizetti’s Linda di Chamounix which had one flaw – alas, it was the protagonist Eglise Gutierrez as Linda. After that, Nicholas Hytner’s risible Don Carlo, perhaps the worst new production since Werther in 2004, was well sung, but Jonas Kaufmann cancelled the performance I attended and, to be honest, Marina Poplavskaya is not enough of a draw. We had the opportunity, it must be said, to listen to great performances by Ferrucio Furlanetto and Simon Keenlyside as Filippo II and Posa, respectively, but that was also the case in 2008.

We continued with the best imaginable rendition of Isolde by Nina Stemme, wonderfully conducted by Antonio Pappano and controversially (in my opinion, beautifully) directed by Christoph Loy. Shame that the tenor, Ben Heppner, was in such bad form that he had to apologise in the interval – one of the worst professional performances I have seen in recent times which, inevitably, marred the overall result of the closest to perfection we’ve been this season. Roberto Alagna, Ildebrando D’Arcangelo and Elina Garanca sang Francesca Zambello’s Carmen, another nearly-there show. Garanca’s aristocratic Carmen didn’t quite fit with Zambello’s overtly erotic, in-the-face, yes, vulgar, production, which worked wonderfully with earthy Anna Caterina Antonacci – Alagna, no one for subtleties, stole the show.

Tchaikovsky’s The Tsarina’s Slippers, staged by Zambello, was the car crash. Ditlev Rindom reviewed it somewhat positively for Mundoclasico.com, eliciting the following response from one of the readers:

“Engaging critically and in such intelligent and considerate terms, as Rindom does, with this preposterous show, the result of the combination of a bad libretto, uninspired music and the lack of imagination of the director, is commendable, heart-warming and yet a waste of pixels. Don’t bother to go. And Padmore, please, never put it on again.”

Here I find myself more in agreement with the reader than with my colleague. The Tsarina’s Slippers was boring and Zambello’s production didn’t help raise the mood (not to speak of the singing and conducting!). This didn’t happen with Prokofiev’s The Gambler, whose artistic merit didn’t quite match the great show Richard Jones put together. In this case, it wasn’t the performance that got in the way of perfection, but the opera itself. With The Cunning Little Vixen, one of the other non-mainstream shows of the season, Bill Bryden’s production may be ideal for a children’s show, but it doesn’t do for adults. The aesthetics of the production are dated, but that’s not the biggest problem – the issue is that nothing really happens that helps the audience understand why they should be spending their evening seeing an opera about hunters and foxes. There surely must be something in the libretto that makes it tick – a better production could bring it about. Sir Charles Mackerras triumphed, yet again, conducting Janacek.

More central to the repertoire are Rosenkavalier, La Boheme, Così fan tutte and The Rake’s Progress. John Schlesinger’s classic Rosenkavalier was kept alive by the nuanced rendition of the Marshallin given by Soile Isokoski (shorn of cheesy clichés so dear to some of her contemporaries) and Peter Rose’s über-comic Ochs (for some, too comic). The success of John Copley’s still good La Boheme relied upon the single starry performance of Piotr Beczala; just to hear him sing “Che gelida manina” and “O Mimì tu più non torni” was worth the trip to the theatre alone. With no stunning casts, Così and The Rake’s Progress were enjoyable thanks to the masterful productions of Sir Jonathan Miller and Robert Lepage, respectively.

Presented with this summary, the reader might be wondering “what is he complaining about. Every evening, with the exception of The Tsarina’s Slippers, there was something really very good.” Yes, undoubtedly. In fact, I’m not complaining, but pointing out that we are still waiting for that ideal night: top opera, great singing, fantastic conducting and intelligent production. Perhaps the end of last season, with one five-star show after the other, spoiled me. Ahead of us, we have a new production of Aida by David McVicar with heavy-weights Marcelo Álvarez and Micaela Carosi; the revival of Laurent Pelly’s La fille du regiment with a difficult-to-match cast starring Juan Diego Flórez and Natalie Dessay; rising star Ermonela Jaho and multimedia diva Angela Gheorghiu alternating as Violeta in La Traviata; Angela Denoke as Salome in McVicar’s gritty production; a great cast with Soile Isokoski, Erwin Schrott, Eri Nakamura, Mariusz Kwiecien, Christine Schäfer and Sir Colin Davis in (again) McVicar’s Le nozze di Figaro; the always reliable Christine Rice as Carmen; Anna Netrebko in Laurent Pelly’s new production of Manon; and Plácido Domingo’s global gig as Simon Boccanegra in Verdi’s opera. There’s definitely enough stardust before the summer break to guarantee at least one top night. Let’s wait and hope.
Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.