Estados Unidos

When Mozart is reliable, and Berlioz provocative (1)

Claudio Vellutini
When Mozart is reliable, and Berlioz provocative (1)
Chicago, martes, 9 de marzo de 2010.
The Civic Opera. Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, Le nozze di Figaro. Sir Peter Hall, original production. Hernert Kellner, stage director. John Bury, set and costume designer. Duane Schuler, lighting designer. Kyle Ketelsen (Figaro), Danielle DeNiese (Susanna), Mariusz Kwiecien (Il Conte d’Almaviva), Amanda Majeski (La Contessa d’Almaviva), Joyce DiDonato (Cherubino), Andrea Silvestrelli (Bartolo), Lauren Curnow (Marcellina), Keith Jameson (Don Basilio), David Portillo (Don Curzio), Angela Mannino (Barbarina), Philip Kraus (Antonio). The Orchestra and Chorus of the Lyric Opera of Chicago. Donald Nally, chorus master. Sir Andrew Davis, conductor
0,0001617 The Lyric Opera of Chicago closed its 2009-’10 season with two concomitant productions that reflect two radically different ways to conceive opera performances today. The two works are themselves diverse in genre, structure, and musical features, and their performance history on the stage of the Lyric is telling of the artistic choices that characterized the productions. Mozart’s The Marriage of Figaro is one of the most significant and popular comic operas of the whole repertoire, a first-rank blockbuster, and it has been produced at the Lyric since 1957 – only three years after the company was founded. Hector Berlioz’s La Damnation de Faust, on the other hand, avoids generic classifications. The composer called its score “dramatic legend” (légende dramatique), a unique designation that fits the nature of a work built up by the juxtaposition of loosely connected scenes from Goethe’s Faust. Unlike Mozart’s opera, this remarkable score had never been performed at the Lyric before this season. While with Figaro, the company relied upon a well-tested artistic formula (stellar cast, professional conducting, descriptive and reliable setting), with La Damnation de Faust it played the card of visual innovation, an operation at the same time risky and stimulating.

Sir Peter Hall’s classical production of The Marriage of Figaro premiered in Chicago during the 1987-’88 season. Despite having lost some of its freshness since then, it still proves entertaining and enjoyable, thanks in particular to some excellent interpreters on stage, with Danielle DeNiese (Susanna) as unmatched star of the evening. Although I found her stylistical approach a bit too leaning towards earlier musical practices when compared to that of the other singers and of the conductor, I was completely charmed by the expressivity that she managed to infuse in her melting rendition of 'Deh vieni non tardar', Susanna’s fourth act aria. More broadly speaking, though, what won me over was DeNiese’s stunning fusion of act and singing—an achievement that made her role not merely a fictional character, but a human creature of flesh and blood. To mention only an example, it will be very difficult for me to forget the expression of her face as she left the Countess’s closet during the second act finale, a moment in which Susanna’s complete control of the situation created by a chain of qui-pro-quos translates visually in her scathing look at the Count and musically by the subtlety of her phrasing.



© 2010 by Dan Rest. Lyric Opera of Chicago

Surrounding such a female leading role, Kyle Ketelsen portrayed a vigorous, manly Figaro in the glorious tradition of Samuel Ramey, Joyce DiDonato served Cherubino’s adolescent turbulences with her belcanto expertise and exquisite musical taste, and Mariusz Kwiecien provided the Count with both scenic and vocal authority. Anne Schwanewilms, announced as the Countess, had to step back from the production after the first few performances due to health problems. Twenty-two year old Ryan Opera Center student Amanda Majesky replaced her the night I went to see the production. After having shone as Vitellia in last year’s production of La clemenza di Tito at the Chicago Opera Theater, Majeski scored another personal success with a Mozart role. The young soprano displayed unquestionable vocal talent, managing the whole role with apparent sangfroid, technical control, and a radiant high register. Although the role is not as demanding as Vitellia, it requires an interpretative maturity that Majeski, because of her age and the last-minute conditions in which she performed, still lacks. Nonetheless, she accomplished the task admirably, showing at the same time huge potential for her future career. For sure, she proved to be an artist to be followed with great attention.



© 2010 by Dan Rest. Lyric Opera of Chicago

The secondary roles were cast with remarkable care. One could hardly wish a Marcellina (Lauren Curnow), Basilio (Keith Jameson), and Curzio (David Portillo) better sung, played, or with a better Italian pronunciation than those heard in Chicago. The veteran Andrea Silvestrelli successfully sang Bartolo’s revenge aria, Angela Mannino potrayed a tender Barbarina and Philip Kraus completed the cast as Antonio.

Sir Andrew Davis confirmed the impression I had last year when he conducted The Abduction from the Seraglio: he navigates through Mozart’s music with the security of a consummate salt, but still leaves the impression of being out of his natural element. His expertise is never out of question, but, on this occasion, it sometimes flirted with superficiality. This was not the case with Berlioz’s Damnation de Faust.
Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.