Reino Unido
A Death in the Family
Staging Il Trittico is a difficult proposition for any opera house. Although united by themes of bereavement and its legacy of emotional, physical and financial entrapment, the operas themselves range widely, offering a kaleidoscope of musical styles which can be tricky to present as a coherent evening’s entertainment. Other challenges are more prosaic: with a preponderance of small roles, casting these three one-act operas satisfactorily can be taxing without using the budget of three larger productions. On CD, Angela Gheorghiu might be perfect as Lauretta, but who can afford the luxury in the theatre?
In its first new production of the Olympic Season, the Royal Opera House tackled these problems head-on through a combination of A-list stars, rising hopefuls and canny double-casting. Building upon his acclaimed 2007 staging of Gianni Schicchi, Richard Jones completed the trilogy with two thoughtful if less obviously spectacular productions which match their less vibrant tone. For Il Tabarro, a gloomy dockyard by the Seine was conjured up through sensitive lighting, a wooden boat and a factory wall at the back, through which minor characters made their presence felt; nothing especially eye-catching, but perfectly satisfactory. Suor Angelica is neatly relocated to a children’s hospital, which added an extra (perhaps slightly predictable) degree of pathos to her final vision of the baby Jesus; rather than a transcendental moment of redemption, it became instead an agonising mad scene in which Angelica identifies a wandering patient with her deceased child.
Like Gianni Schicchi, these productions appear to take place in the 1950s and gave Jones and his team of designers ample opportunity to work their visual magic. The decrepit wallpaper, fluorescent outfits and blaring television of Bouso’s home perfectly evoke the atmosphere of a family who can feel la dolce vita slipping mortifyingly out of their hands, whilst the pastel greens and white uniforms of Suor Angelica provide a backdrop of efficient calm against which the central character’s inner turmoil and depression is tragically unleashed. Il Tabarro is less obviously captivating, but then so is the opera; for all the attractions of the love duet, this was the weakest section of the evening, and it would take a greater degree of visual flair than on offer here to make me hanker for a revival in the near future.
Partly these problems were also down to the cast. As Giorgetta, Eva-Maria Westbroek returned once again to the house in a high-profile role; this is her third new production in a row (with Les Troyens to follow) making her one of the most favoured singers in London at present. An attractively generous and committed performer, she is not one who dazzles with her technical finesse or vocal allure; there is a lack of precision and control in the more extreme passages which is disconcerting in one so successful, and her top notes approach a scream. Here she gave a well-conceived but often coarse-toned performance which was matched by the Luigi of Alexsandr Antonenko - an extremely exciting dramatic voice which as yet seems stuck wholly on forte. In the crucial role of Michele, Lucio Gallo gave a sophisticated but unthreatening depiction whose final act of cruelty seemed under-prepared; one would ideally favour a greater sense of menace in his timbre.
In his second performance of the evening, Gallo gave an enjoyable delivery of Schicchi as a louche charmer, happy to give with one hand and take with the other. As a performer, he doesn’t have the charisma of a Bryn Terfel, but he was happily complemented by a superb ensemble cast. In the smaller parts, Marie McLaughlin and Lisa Anne Robinson gave perfectly timed comic performances and Elena Zilioi nearly stole the show as the disgruntled old widow. Deputing for Ekaterina Suirina, Anna Devin made a sweet debut as Lauretta and Francesco Demuro impressed with his fluent command of style and ringing tones.
Gianni Schicchi had the audience in peals of laughter, but the emotional high-point of the evening was undoubtedly Suor Angelica. This was intended to be a vehicle for Anja Harteros and many must have been disappointed when she pulled out during the rehearsals; yet Ermonela Jaho nearly matched her earlier triumph as Violetta in 2008, with a performance of genuine dramatic intensity. On one level, her singing was a slight let-down: the role is too heavy for her and in the lower-lying passages of her aria and the dramatic outbursts in the central duet, she struggled to project, leading to some awkward moments of vocal pressure. Yet at the same time, her flickery vibrato and physical stress added a further element of fragility to the character, aided by superb acting which from the start suggested a highly vulnerable woman on the verge of collapse. The final scene where she realised she has damned herself to hell - sliding plates and bottles of pills across the stage in a frantic attempt to receive help and grabbing onto her perplexed colleagues- was a terrifying depiction of depression and casual abandonment, a deeply uncomfortable moment of truth only made more painful by Jones’ removal of the traditional consolation. Not what Puccini intended, of course; but for a secular audience, perhaps the only way.
As Zia Principessa, Anna Larsson gave a similarly light-toned but involving performance, more Maggie Smith than Fiorenza Cossotto, but engaging nonetheless. The bedrock of the whole evening was the infallible conducting of Antonio Pappano - wonderfully smoky in Il Tabarro, sumptuous yet delicate in Suor Angelica and alert to the fluctuations of sentiment and broad comedy in Gianni Schicchi. The whole evening was surely Pappano’s dream (given that he recorded it in 1999) and given the difficulties of the task, one can only applaud the team involved. Not quite the perfect hat-trick one had hoped for; but a very good evening anyway.
Comentarios