Discos

Three farewells

Michael Lukey
Jan Ladislav Dussek: 3 Piano Sonatas. Piano Sonata No. 26 in A flat major, op. 64; Piano Sonata No. 24 in F sharp minor, op. 61; Piano Sonata No. 18 in E flat major, op. 44. Markus Becker, piano. Executive producers: Burkhard Schmilgun/Wilfried Schäper. Assistants and editing: Ulrike Franz-Heintzeler. Recording engineer: Gisela Kniemeyer. Recording supervisor: Andreas Heintzeler. One compact disc, total playing time 77 minutes. Recorded at Sendesaal Radio Bremen, October 23-25 2003. CPO 777 020-2
0,0001137

Perhaps even less widely appreciated nowadays than his contemporaries Clementi and Hummel, Jan Ladislav Dussek (1760 Caslav, Bohemia – 1812 Paris) was one of the most famous and respected musicians of his time. Indeed, listening to the three technically, harmonically, and structurally progressive sonatas on the current disc, one is likely to question the preoccupation with Beethoven as the musical revolutionary of the period.

To quote the booklet notes, "Dussek’s dates situate him in the generation of classical composers, but much in his best compositions points far beyond his times, to Chopin, Schumann, or Smetana". In this generously filled (77 minutes) release from CPO, Dussek seems to have found an almost ideal advocate in Markus Becker, whose admirably controlled yet sensitive readings allow the fascinating music to speak for itself.

Although each work here is subtitled (op. 44 being Dussek’s own Adieux sonata), the names hint more at the occasion than the subject of the composition. Starting with op. 44, then, published eleven years before Beethoven’s Les Adieux, the occasion of this ‘farewell’ was Dussek’s fleeing from his creditors in England after the failure of his London-based publishing company; he left behind not just his wife and daughter, but also his close friend and rival Muzio Clementi, the dedicatee of the piece. The unusually detailed and thoughtful booklet notes by Lorenz Luyken rightly observe that Dussek "knew how to respond to the broad public’s craving for sensation and significance while also satisfying people knowledgeable in musical matters. The latter group could find, again in his best works, not so much empty ends-in-themselves as powerful expressive means in his enormous technical demands…".

Op. 44 attests to Dussek’s use of technique at the service of artistry, and it is remarkable that at certain moments in this composition from 1800, which begins with clear references to Baroque models, the music of both Schubert and Chopin seems to be anticipated. Becker’s playing here is also noteworthy – whereas in the other two sonatas he at times seems rather more cautious than might be necessary, greater dynamic contrasts and rhythmic drive, and simple joie de vivre are all on display in op. 44. However, it is worth mentioning that throughout the disc, and especially in this sonata, the editing is not always perfect, with more than one noticeable ambience change.

Op. 61 in F sharp minor is another farewell of sorts, composed after Dussek’s employer Prince Louis Ferdinand of Prussia was killed in battle in 1806: the subtitle reads Élégie harmonique sur la mort de son Altesse Royale le Prince Louis Ferdinand de Prusse. Ferdinand, famously described by Beethoven as “not at all like a prince or king but like a capital pianist” and dedicatee of the composer’s third piano concerto, apparently had a close friendship with Dussek – indeed the latter was present in Ferdinand’s military encampment at the time of the prince’s death, and was deeply affected by the event. Beginning with a quotation from the Consummatum est of Haydn’s then very popular oratorio The Seven Last Words, this sonata is highly unconventional in its form and could aptly be named a sonata quasi una fantasia. After the introductory lento comes an Agitato movement, in which Becker’s playing seems slightly inhibited. Given the considerable repetition in this movement, some listeners may start to tire after seven or eight minutes, and a less restrained performance would not be unwelcome.

In 1807, twenty years after his initial success in Paris (with which he obtained the favour of Marie Antoinette), Dussek returned to the city and entered the service of Napoleon’s Foreign Minister. A new sonata was composed, subtitled Le Retour à Paris, and is described in the notes as being drawn "on the idea of the Farewell sonata, but expanded considerably in matters of length, sonority, pianistic ambition, and liberties over musical convention". Becker’s crystal-clear finger work in this treacherously difficult thirty-three minute sonata is impressive, and, along with subtle colouring and rubato, and a clear understanding of both the sorrowful and humorous elements in Dussek’s music, results in another fine performance.

Overall, the playing on this disc is preferable to that on Jan Novotný’s Dussek recording for Supraphon, and is therefore to be recommended both to those familiar and those unfamiliar with this interesting composer’s music.

Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.