Discos
A mixed bag
Born in Warsaw in 1908, Felicja Blumental won a scholarship to the Polish National Conservatory where she studied under Karol Szymanowski, among other teachers. In the early 1940s Blumental fled to Brazil, where she became closely associated with Villa-Lobos who dedicated his Fifth Piano Concerto to her. Undoubtedly a pianist of the "old school", it was observed by Hans Wolf that Blumental, who died in Tel Aviv in 1991, brought with her "the breath of a now vanished, cultivated, and perhaps gentler age". This generously filled (77 minute) disc from Brana Records, who are reissuing much of Blumental’s recorded legacy, makes a suitable ‘sampler’ for anybody interested in investigating the pianist, and contains a handful of gems for existing fans.
For the last thirty years of her life, Blumental concentrated on recording works she considered to be neglected by other musicians of the time – a fact certainly reflected on the current CD, which contains miniatures by Kabalewski, Weill and Khachaturian, alongside more familiar repertoire. As might reasonably be expected, the recorded sound is highly variable from piece to piece, ranging from satisfactory stereo to tracks clearly lifted from 78s. What is more disappointing is the variability in the playing, especially in the more frequently heard pieces. In the 'Moonlight' Sonata, for example, the playing is not bad per se, but neither is there much of note about it - it is seldom distinctive, imaginative or interesting. Again with the Schubert F minor Impromptu D935, with so many fine recordings now in the catalogue, there is little to recommend this uninspired performance. The latter piece is further marred by surprising technical sloppiness.
The accompanying booklet is also rather variable in quality. An interesting mini-biography of Blumental is given, along with a panel of several photographs – but there is no information on any of the music, which given the repertoire presented, would certainly have been welcome. Indeed, tracks three and four are of transcriptions from Corelli and Gluck, yet the transcriber is not even named. Furthermore, Brana Records leave us to guess both where and when each of the recordings originated.
With all that said, I am nevertheless pleased to have heard this CD, since much of the playing is charming. The first track gives the disc its title: an arrangement by Melcer of Moniuszko’s The Spinning Girl, an attractive and gracefully played encore piece. Another gem is the Kuhlau Sonatine, with which many piano students will be familiar, played with unaffected simplicity by Blumental. The two Etudes and two Preludes by Szymanowski must have been considered rarities when they were recorded, and along with Villa Lobos’ The Three Maries are convincingly performed. The final tracks on the disc – a fleet-fingered rendition of Khachaturian’s Toccata, a transcription of Kurt Weill’s 'Tango Ballade' from Die Dreigroschenoper, and Kabalewski’s Sonatine Op. 13 are also very good.
Overall this is a mixed bag in terms of playing, sound and presentation, as well as repertoire. Blumental seems to excel in the more obscure pieces – and since many of these compositions are more than worth listening to, I recommend this disc.
Comentarios