Discos

Delectable Brilliance

Michael Lukey
Clifford Curzon, piano. Frederick Delius. Concerto for Piano and Orchestra in C minor [BBC Symphony Orchestra, Sir John Pritchard]. Wolfgang Amadè Mozart. Concerto for Piano and Orchestra No.24 in C minor, K.491. Ludwig van Beethoven. Fantasia for Piano, Chorus and Orchestra in C minor, Op.80 [London Philharmonic Choir and Orchestra, Bernard Haitink]. Executive Producer: John Pattrick. Remastering: Tony Faulkner. One compact disc, total playing time 78 minutes. Recorded at: Royal Albert Hall, London, 3 September 1981 (Delius); Royal Festival Hall, London, 6 November 1979 (Mozart); 28 January 1970 (Beethoven). BBC Legends BBCL 4181-2
0,0001246

Although the three pieces on this disc were recorded on separate occasions, they typify the level of variety that Clifford Curzon often liked to include in a single concert; indeed, it’s hard to think of three more sharply contrasted works for piano and orchestra in the key of C minor! From the ‘oh-so-English’ Concerto by Delius to the intellectual and emotional complexity of K.491 and ‘explosive whimsy’ of Beethoven’s Op.80 Choral Fantasy, Curzon’s wonderful versatility could hardly be better represented on a single CD.

Bryce Morrison’s interesting booklet notes mention that although once having a repertoire of over 50 concertos, "finally Curzon concentrated almost exclusively on the finest masterpieces, on music which in Schnabel’s immortal words is “always better than it can be played”’. Without disrespect, it would be hard to argue that Frederick Delius’ early piano concerto falls into such a category, yet this recording was made at the very end of Curzon’s life; we should perhaps view it as an affectionate ‘trip down Memory lane’. Although not without attractions, the concerto is a composition with several flaws, some of which possibly result from its complicated history.

It is thought that the young Delius may have been inspired to write a piece for piano and orchestra after witnessing the warm reception of the A minor concerto by his friend Grieg, in 1888. Eight years later, the earliest form of Delius’ concerto appeared as a Lisztian three-in-one Fantasy; after considerable revision, a three-movement concerto was produced shortly after 1900, and first performed in 1904. Still not satisfied, two years later Delius had completely abandoned the third movement, placed the D flat ‘slow movement’ back between the development and recapitulation of the ‘first movement’, and added further development and coda sections. On top of this, the entire piano part was rewritten by Busoni’s pupil Theodor Szántó. It is this version, first performed in 1907, that has most frequently been played and recorded since. Whether it’s an intrinsic feature of Delius’ musical language, whether it’s because the solo part was written by another hand, or indeed whether it is simply because of the concerto’s chaotic history, the poetic orchestral part and the percussive piano part do not always seem ideally matched. Furthermore, it is often said that the composer’s characteristic harmony and orchestration are not at their best in this concerto; perhaps a consequence of it being a relatively early work.

Onto the performance. The two other recordings of this version of the concerto that I’ve heard (Jean-Rodolphe Kar, 1970; Benno Moiseiwitsch, 1946; Piers Lane’s recent recording is of the 1904 version) are significantly shorter than the current performance, and Curzon and Pritchard manage to give the piece a larger-scale feel by creating a vast range of emotion and colour. Curzon’s unique playing (and it really was unique) glistens with enthusiasm and fondness, and through the mediocre sound it can just about be discerned that he had remarkable control of his seventy-four year old fingers. He manages to bring both a gravitas and intensity to this work that I can’t imagine many other pianists achieving. Bryce Morrison says it all: ‘clearly in love with its meandering Grieg-inspired rhetoric, he erases all sense of the music’s skids from heroics to introspection. Expansive and delicate as required, his rubato in the central chromatic decoration makes such music “weep and sing and sigh” (Liszt) with all of his poetic commitment’. The audience explodes with applause, of which over thirty seconds are justifiably included at the end of the track.

Next on the CD is Mozart’s C minor concerto, K.491, a 1979 recording with Bernard Haitink and the London Philharmonic Orchestra. Unlike the other two pieces on the CD, Curzon’s interpretation of this concerto is well documented in other releases, although this particular performance is not without individual charms. Morrison is quite right when he states that ‘Curzon had a way with the great C minor Concerto, the work scaled so that there is never any confusion between Mozart’s Apollonian and Beethoven’s Dionysian genius’. He also appears to be correct when he says that the music has been ‘tirelessly sifted for every possible nuance or insight’, and for me this is the only problem with the performance. Balanced and noble though Curzon’s conception is, the listener is left with little sense of natural or spontaneous music-making. The LPO under Haitink perhaps provide a more polished, although certainly no more enthusiastic, collaboration than Sir John Pritchard and the BBC Symphony Orchestra in the Delius.

Another new addition to the catalogue of Curzon recordings, as far as I am aware, is the still relatively infrequently heard Fantasia for Piano, Chorus and Orchestra by Beethoven. Curzon launches the solo piano opening of the piece with a passion and confidence one does not often come across – indeed the stylistic contrast with his Mozart playing ensures that there is zero chance of “confusion between Mozart’s Apollonian and Beethoven’s Dionysian genius”! Intensity and conviction in the solo part are maintained unbroken through the piece’s twenty-minute duration, with occasional trip-ups in the choral sections not detracting from the excitement. Unfortunately, the LPO under Haitink fall some way short of matching Curzon’s keenness. It should be noted that although this 1970 recording is in mono, the sound is actually considerably clearer than in the muffled Delius from eleven years later.

The fact that there are no other recordings of Curzon playing either the Delius Concerto or the Beethoven Fantasy immediately recommends this disc to those who already admire the pianist. For other people, the release provides a fine introduction to Curzon’s fascinating and inimitable art, and contains as convincing a performance of the Delius concerto as one can reasonably hope to hear.

Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.