Discos
Only for Serkin enthusiasts
It was a well-seasoned programme that Rudolf Serkin performed at London’s Royal Festival Hall on June 4th 1973: the little-known Capriccio BWV993 also opened his Carnegie Hall recitals of 1939 and 1947; the Reger Bach-Variations were played at his Carnegie Hall debut in 1937; and the Op.78 or Op.53 sonatas of Beethoven were also played at each of these earlier recitals. The performances on the current disc, at their best points, by no means sound contrived or lacking in freshness however – and, to greater or lesser extents, elements of Serkin’s "intellectual penetration, structural and spiritual grandeur, lyricism, and virtuosity" are all apparent, as of course is his unquestionable artistic integrity.
It used to be said, especially of his London recitals, that Serkin’s playing did not really take off until the second piece on the programme. I fully agree with Jeremy Siepmann who writes the booklet notes accompanying this disc that this is not the case here. In fact, for me the most convincing performance by some way is that of Bach’s E major Capriccio, with which the concert was opened. As usual with BBC Legends, the notes focus on the musician – yet with Reger’s Variations and the rarely heard Bach Capriccio present, many listeners would probably appreciate some background information on the music as well.
When Bach was orphaned at the age of ten he was placed in the care of his elder brother Johann Christoph, who became responsible for his sibling’s musical education. At the age of fifteen, Johann Sebastian was expected to go and make his own living, which he promptly did at Lüneburg. BWV993 bears the subtitle ‘in honorem Johann Christoph Bachii Ohrdrufiensis’, and was possibly presented to Johann Christoph in thanks for his guardianship. An extended fugue, this piece shows what an intelligent and skilled composer Bach was, even by his middle teens. Serkin’s playing is so sincere and soulful that it is difficult for the listener not to feel moved. Furthermore, whereas Serkin’s technique is pushed to its limits at moments in the bulkier pieces that follow, his control in the Bach is nothing but admirable, with each contrapuntal line highlighted not only by dynamics, but also by tone-colour.
Although composed in 1904, Reger’s Variations and Fugue on a Theme of J.S. Bach are well rooted in the musical past. The theme itself is from the contralto/tenor duet 'Seine Allmacht zu ergründen, wird sich kein Mensche finden' of Cantata 128, Auf Christi Himmelfahrt allein. Rather than varying the entire tune, Reger chooses to focus on particular elements of it in each variation. After the fourteenth variation comes the monumental fugue – or, more accurately, two four-part fugues that are ultimately combined into the finale. I do not entirely agree with Siepmann’s claim that, at seventy, Serkin was in "sovereign command" of the virtuosic challenges found in this work. Although there is great emotional intensity to the playing, and some of the slower sections are cleanly brought off, in many variations and especially in the fugue the playing is strained and at times even clumsy.
The second half of the disc contains two Beethoven Sonatas: Op. 78, in F sharp major, and Op.53, the “Waldstein”. Beethoven is, of course, the composer with whom Serkin has always been most widely associated, and his gritty and percussive Beethoven playing is immediately recognisable. The performances here are by no means Serkin at his worst (one thinks of some of the 1980s releases), but they are still far below the level of his Columbia recordings from the ‘50s and ‘60s. The 'Adagio Cantabile' opening of Op. 78 on the present disc perhaps shows the pianist at his best – soulful and poised, yet flexible. Siepmann admits that hints of Serkin’s occasional rhythmic rigidity are apparent elsewhere in the Beethoven, but this is not the main problem for me. Siepmann mentions Serkin’s characteristic tension, "poised perilously on the cusp between command and chaos" – this time, however, I find the balance lies too far towards the latter. With the exception of the 'Adagio Molto' of the Waldstein, Serkin seems to be struggling right from the banged opening chords through to the clangourous 'Prestissimo'. Although recorded two years later, I find the slightly slower performance on Sony Classical preferable, especially since the recorded sound is much fairer on the pianist here.
Taking account of both the high-points and low-points of this disc, it is probably fair to recommend it to Serkin enthusiasts, but to advise those who are unfamiliar with the pianist to begin elsewhere.
Comentarios