Entrevistas
‘Composing is always the way of finding yourself’
Johannes Kalitzke © johanneskalitzke.com
Mundoclásico.com meets Johannes Kalitzke in his dressing-room in the new Casa da Música auditorium of Porto (Portugal), a wonderful building by Rem Koolhaas, in which we listened tonight a fantastic concert with pieces by Lachenmann, Pope and Staud (see concert review). Very tired, after four hours of rehearsals and a high demanding performance, in which was included the Portuguese premiere of Lachenmann’s Concertini, the German conductor and composer (Köln, 1959) talks very kindly with us about music, performers, composition and public, with generous explanations and a deep point of view in all the topics.
Paco Yáñez. First of all, thank you very much for this interview with Mundoclasico.com, we know a conductor on tour doesn’t use to have too much free time; and, of course, congratulations for the very impressive concert you’ve conducted tonight.
Going to the program, you put together tonight Helmut Lachenmann, a composer with a huge experience, with two young composers, Enno Poppe, who was born in 1969, and Johannes Maria Staud, who curiously was born in the same month and year than I did, august 1974. Do you want to show any link, any relation between them by putting them together in this concert?
Johannes Kalitzke. I don’t think that we should look for a link between the composers. I have to say that I didn’t expect this question, because in fact I didn’t make the program, I was just invited to conduct a program that was fixed. Anyway, we have two parts in this program; the first consisted on two pieces of Lachenmann, and those have been surrounded by some of younger composers. So, you have two generations; the first generation represented by Lachenmann, who is the typical person of the avantgarde, looking for new instrumental treatments, instrumental sounds, but without any electronics; he is working just looking for the possibilities of the instruments, really at the edge of the possibilities that the instruments can offer. Looking for the limits of the instrumental sounds, he found a new world of new ‘soundscapes’ only using the limit of instrumental possibilities. And the younger composers, like Staud or Poppe, they inherited these techniques and they combine them in a sort of traditional way of composing instrumental music. For example, there are some aspects of spectral sounds in the Lachenmann’s piece, but Enno Poppe just makes spectral sounds in the principle of his composition’s techniques. Staud, on the other hand, is working with harmonic centres, a little bit like Boulez in the later works, perhaps; he combines this technique of harmonic centres with some other sound experiences of the Lachenmann’s compositions techniques. So, you know, the younger composers, in a sort of post-modern way, are looking for links between different aesthetical ways of composing.
Q. Well, I have to say you quite advanced many of my questions in your answer; because I really think Helmut Lachenmann is, in my opinion, one of the key composers in the second half of the XXth Century…
A. Absolutely.
Q. …together with Luigi Nono, György Ligeti, Morton Feldman, Iannis Xenakis and some others. But in some way, I’m looking for an heir of his work, for a person who could be developing this kind of composition techniques between the young generations. We can think of a proximity in some pieces by Jörg Widmann, Rebecca Saunders or Olga Neuwirth, and in the case of Spain I should mention José María Sánchez-Verdú, Manuel Hidalgo [former Lachenmann’s student in Stuttgart] or Ramón Ramos [whose string quartet, Pas Encore (1978-79), is one of the closest works to Lachenmann’s aesthetic you can find in Spanish music]. They have some links with Lachenmann, but I can’t find today any composer who works completely in his way of ‘instrumental concrete music’. Do you really know any ‘heir’ in this way?
A. I think Lachenmann is such a unique person, in the way he have developed a unique musical language; but you can not continue this. Everything you would continue would be eclecticism and a big danger for young composers who are impressed by really great composers; but they are just writing copies and copies and copies of the sound’s techniques. So, intelligent young composers should look for their own way, not copying the language of elder composers, but copying the way of finding their own language. It´s not a question of finding a new way in an established language, it´s a question of finding their own words and to be consequent with them, to be strict and authentic in their own way. You know, composing is always the way of finding yourself and to express this in music; if you don’t find yourself you’ll never write your own music. It’s just a human aspect.
Q. And between those young composers you know pretty well, because you’ve conducted many of their works; do you find any kind of ‘school’, of link? Any leader between those composers? Or are we just in a post-modern time and there’s no really connection between them, as their works are highly individualistic?
A. They should try to be. Because, and it’s large to explain, I think today the biggest task is to write in his own way. We can divide the works of the composers in two parts, between composers who are simulators and others who find their own ways of composing, who find a personal issue to the world of music. So, I think you can not discuss aesthetics, you can not discuss different tastes, because there’re no ideologies and no rules, no objectivity. So, you must judge the composers following their own ideas and compare them with the result. There’re a lot of composers who have a very good technique, but we have too many of them, a little bit like cloning…
Q. Yes, copying…
A. Yes; it’s hearing like some cloning of always the same.
Q. Talking about Concertini; this is a piece you know pretty well, in fact you conducted the Italian premiere in Venezia. Which importance do you think this piece has in Lachenmann’s work? Do you think it has anything new in Lachenmann’s aesthetic, or is it a kind of summa lachenmanniana with many of his previous techniques together?
A. Well, it’s a question of the general development of Lachenmann. In the other pieces he was just writing really on sound, at the limit of noises. He used the noise to produce different fields of harmonic contexts, and today he is mixing those experiences of ‘noise-composing’ with traditional harmonics and spectral sounds, etc. So, sometimes it sounds more ‘operal’, or, if you like it, more ‘philharmonic’, because he opens the door to the tradition, but he opens the door from the other side, you know; he first developed his own language, coming from the experiment with noises, and from this point of view he went back to... no, we can’t talk of ‘coming back’; he found some issues to traditional sounds which are now integrated in this context.
Q. In fact, when I went Madrid this February for listening his three string quartets played by the Arditti Quartet [Madrid, Músicadhoy cycle, 17.02.2006], he told me that Grido [Helmut Lachenmann’s 3rd String Quartet, 2001] was really ‘pop music’ [Lachenmann always had a very fine sense of humour, even on his own works], very easy compared with the two early quartets. He really recognizes that he is giving a step into, not simplicity, but not so much complexity in terms of ‘instrumental concrete music’.
A. Yes. He always tells me that his music should ‘groove’, even in silence, in a time of beaten rests. His music should be ‘swing’ all time, even if you don’t hear a sound, but the general rhythm of the music is here, primary rhythmic.
Q. This piece was written specific for the Ensemble Modern, which gave the premiere last year in Luzern [25.08.2005] Do you really think there’re many ensembles in the world able to play this highly complex music?
A. Absolutely not. Because you need a huge experience of playing music, first of all of playing contemporary music, and apart from this of playing highly demanding techniques which are very special [those of Lachenmann’s ‘instrumental concrete music’]. And, on the other hand, you must have the feeling of what your neighbour is playing, a feeling for the context. You must be used to follow the conductor extremely precisely on the beat, otherwise you can’t play together. It’s never a piece with which you can train a new ensemble; ensembles should learn something different before they play Lachenmann’s music, anyway. The big problem in this piece is to find the correct balance between the sounds background-foreground, and to work with them in synchronity, because the groups behind me never can listen to the group before me, because then they are too late, they have to shut their ears and to follow the beatings, and this is very difficult.
Q. Really.
You have conducted many ensembles worldwide in the last years; in fact, you’re one of the best and leading conductors of contemporary music nowadays. Taking Schönberg’s words, he said, many years ago, that the ‘problem’ was not the music, but the players, in some way. Do you think the ensembles today are ready to play what the composers of this time demand, that is really very complex?
A. Yes.
Q. And do you feel any difference between the ensembles worldwide? Because I think Germany and Austria have nowadays world’s leading ensembles in contemporary music.
A. Yes, we should look for differences, because it would be boring if everybody should play music in the same way; so I think it’s very good if every ensemble develops its own style of playing. In this case [Ensemble Modern] you find an own style; if you go to other ensembles, like Klangforum, you will find another typical sound. In classical music you have the possibility of interpreting and reading the music in your personal way, so it becomes part of your own language; but this is not possible in the contemporary music because its parameters are absolutely determinate, everything is notated precisely and given by the composer, normally; but the sound culture of the ensemble can replace the aspect of interpretation, and you can work out these scores under this aspect. It determines changes on the pieces, but a change of the perspective on the piece, you know.
Q. There’re differences so, from your point of view, between the ensembles. What is out of the question is that auditoriums and concert halls have been improved and go better worldwide, and here we have a very good example. Do you find a good acoustic here in Porto for this kind of pieces like Concertini, that places specifically the groups around the hall.
A. Absolutely; but if it would be full of people the acoustic situation should be better. It makes a big difference whether you play in an empty hall or in a full one; and I hoped it would be a little bit better visited, then the acoustic could have been much more easy to hand on [Audience was just 230 people for 1.300 seats]
Q. We know you’re a composer too; you have written very interesting pieces, many of them really difficult. How can you manage to conduct ensembles, to record, to be on tour, to play, and, at the same time, to compose? Because even Helmut Lachenmann, who is not a conductor, many times says he’s really in stress because for having so many duties worldwide. Which is your way to do all those things?
A. It’s a daily problem. It’s not easy, because normally you start to keep clear some white spots in your schedule, but then suddenly there are invitations which are very attractive and you can’t say no, and then you’re acting against yourself, because you haven’t enough time to write your own pieces... Sometimes it’s really hard and if you speak with other composers-conductors you’ll hear the same.
Concerning your question, I’m starting a 40 minutes composition together with the film-director Edgar Reitz, internationally well known by his Heimat trilogy, for Donaueschingen-Festival next year. It´s a musical project with an integrated film-part.
Q. And finally, the last question, that’s really a very complex thing, that could take hours or years to talk about. XXth Century music, XXIst Century music, contemporary music in general terms, specially vanguard music has gone, part of it, very high in complexity, something I really like and that interests to me very much. But in some places, mainly in the USA and the UK, some composers are asking for “taking public back” again to the auditoriums through different ways, specially known through ‘neo-tonality’. But, on the other hand, we have composers that go really every day higher in complexity. Do you think there’s any way of putting together, or more close, these two ways, or is it really too much complex? It could be that for Lachenmann’s music or Luigi Nono’s one it could take time, like Gustav Mahler said when he talked about his music should wait around 50 years to be generally understood; and he was right.
A. Yes, it’s a question of time. Well, I think the avantgarde strict period was, sure, a time of retirement, a time of going into a closer room and to have time to look for new solutions, thinking on music, composing... It was a time of experiments... Yes, it was like a laboratory, and a laboratory is never public. But this was a short period and now the task of composers and of the public is to find back together. From the public I think we can expect to be curious; if you are not curious you shouldn’t go to any concert, because even in Beethoven you can never take anything new if you’re not any curious. So, generally, I can expect on the public to be open, without prejudgements and with an open mind. On the other hand, the composers and the interpreters should be wise in combining pieces in a program, because there’re a lot of contemporary music which can make the way easy to find it and to understand it. Otherwise there’re a lot of music which is really, as you said, very complicate and a little bit distant, very hard to find a contact to reach it. So, on the other hand, the biggest problem for me to make good programs is the combination of pieces, because the interdependence of the pieces in program can explain the music. So, it’s a problem from two parts, from two sides; public should be open and the dramaturgy of concerts should be intelligent.
Q. Sure. Well, Mr. Kalitzke, that was all. Thank you very much for this very interesting conversation.
A. Thanks to you.
Comentarios