Discos
Ives improvises
Often when I listen to Charles Ives’ music, the words with which George Szell once described Glenn Gould come to mind: “that nut’s a genius!”. Hearing Ives the performer for the first time on this disc of his complete piano recordings evoked a similar response. After his first recording experience, Ives wrote "A man may play to himself and his music starts to live – then he tries to put it under a machine, and it’s dead!" (Memos, pp.80-81); however, it is not often that one comes across performances that are quite as ‘alive’ as these – Ives’ interpretative approach is highly Romantic and improvisatory, and there are also frequent recorded comments to his wife or the technician along with singing, curses and groans of annoyance at mistakes, and exclamations when he plays a piece to completion (“Oh! That’s the note! My finger slipped on it.”)
We are told in the extensive booklet notes that Ives had three main reasons behind his initial decision to make recordings: firstly, he simply wanted the opportunity to hear with detachment his music, much of which was almost never performed at the time. Secondly, Ives had the idea of “perhaps playing each movement two or three different ways”, and then allowing some “acoustical genius…[to] write it down for me – and probably better than I can” (Memos, p.80). Finally, Ives wished to demonstrate to performers and conductors exactly how his music should be interpreted: “Interpret! Interpret! If they don’t know anything about music well, I’ll tell them!”.
For people who already own recordings of Ives playing Ives, it is worth mentioning that there have been two previous issues. As part of the 1974 Ives centenary album, some of the music on the present disc (two selections were assembled from every four takes, with overlaps deleted) was released on LP by CBS. The sound quality on the present disc is supposed to be an enormous improvement over that on the LP. The first issue of the current version was by CRI, in 1999 – it apparently ran out of stock long before CRI’s ultimate demise in 2002. So, the contents of this disc are essentially unaltered from the 1999 version – the same transfers are used and the same essays are included in the booklet; the only additions being a bibliography and selected discography.
So what is actually present? The majority of the material began as part of, or is derived from, the Emerson Overture [or Concerto] for piano and orchestra. Ives wrote of his Emerson Concerto that he "may always have the pleasure of not finishing it", but much of its music nevertheless ended up in separate completed compositions – the first movement of the Sonata No. 2 for Piano: Concord, Mass., of course, but also the Studies No.1, No.2, and No.9 (the Anti-Abolitionist Riots in the 1830’s and 1840’s), which are adaptations of the 'Centrifugal Cadenzas' of the Emerson Concerto. Furthermore, Study No. 23 contains a fragment of the 'Fourth Cadenza'. Ives also produced Four Transcriptions from 'Emerson'; and it was the reinstatement of the music of Cadenzas 1-3 into the first transcription that prompted his first recordings – “shortly I think I shall make a record, perhaps playing each movement two or three different ways. This will be done more for my own satisfaction and study…”.
The first twenty-five tracks, then, consist of various takes of fragments (usually placed next to each other to ‘complete’ the piece) of the first three of the Four Transcriptions from 'Emerson', along with takes of Studies Nos. 2, 9, 11, and 23. Track four, only 44 seconds long, is titled Improvisation on a passage in Study No. 23, Four Transcriptions from “Emerson”, No.2, and Emerson Overture’s 'Cadenza No. 4' (with false start)! Tracks thirty-two to thirty-seven also consist of Emerson Overture-derived material: three fragments from the Emerson movement of the Concord Sonata, and further takes of material in the first twenty-five tracks.
The final ten tracks of the disc contain recordings from Ives’ final session, at the Mary Howard Studio in 1943. The curiously moving wartime song They are there! gets three takes (the first abandoned), with Ives’ furious piano playing accompanying his own untrained (to say the least) tenor voice – “Smash all dictators!” he yells. March No. 6, 'Here’s to Good Old Yale', comes next, and the disc concludes with the entire 'Allcotts' movement of the Concord Sonata – undoubtedly the highlight of the CD for me. The emotional intensity of Ives’ music can sometimes seem a little obscure, but this is not the case here, and the piano playing loses nearly all of the rough edges heard in other tracks.
The booklet accompanying this disc contains three short essays by members of The Charles Ives Society, and one by the Curator of Historical Sound Recordings at Yale University: a general introduction describes Ives’ recording experiences and explains how the tracks on the CD were arranged; ‘Charles Ives discovered’ describes the discovery of some of the recordings on the CD; ‘Recording and re-recording Ives’, describes the technology behind the various recordings; and ‘The evolution of Ives’ “Emerson” music’ discusses the background of much of the music present.
For those who are not yet familiar with Ives’ piano music, this disc cannot be recommended as a starting point – Marc-André Hamelin’s superlative recording of the Concord Sonata would be far more appropriate. However, for Ives enthusiasts, and especially for any performers of his works, this should surely be essential listening. Many characteristics of Ives’ playing remind one of the Romantic interpretative ideals of his time, and provide an invaluable lesson in performance style. Ives always claimed that, for him, composition was a kind of improvisation, and the semi-improvised performances that we hear here, often different ‘versions’ of the same piece, suggest that he was speaking the truth.
Comentarios