Reino Unido

Without a climax to speak of

Enrique Sacau
Without a climax to speak of
London, martes, 19 de junio de 2007.
The Royal Opera House, Covent Garden. Leos Janacek, Katya Kabanova. Trevor Nunn, director. Andrew Sinclair, revival director. Maria Björnson, designs. Patricia Collins, lighting. Toby Spence (Vana Kudrjas), Miranda Westcott (Glasa), Oleg Bryjak (Dikoj), Kurt Streit (Boris), Anne Mason (Feklusa), Felicity Palmer (Kabanicha), Chris Merritt (Tichon Kabanov), Janice Watson (Katya Kabanova), Linda Tuvas (Varvara), Jeremy White (Kuligin), Renata Skarelyte (Zena), Neil Gillespie (Chodec). The Orchestra & Chorus of the Royal Opera House. Renato Balsadonna, chorus director. Sir Charles Mackerras, conductor.
9,48E-05 At the end of this performance of Janacek’s Katya Kabanova, a lady sitting nearby said to her companion, “We must thank the composer for having written a short bore; most others write very long ones.” I am tempted to agree, but I cannot possibly go that far. This opera has some enjoyable moments, most of which happen in the pit. It is, however, a slow piece in which very little happens. In fact, from the very first act you know that Katya is going to fall for a man, you know who the man is and you guess that either she is going to be killed by her husband or else she will end up committing suicide. What does the libretto do to entertain the audience in the 100 hundred minutes between the first and the last bar? Not much, really, and that is why I say that all the wonders come from the pit, especially if Sir Charles Mackerras is in charge. Janacek’s orchestration is lavish. The same applies to his audacious use of onomatopoeia, highlighted by Mackerras. None of this, however, did much to spice up the show.



Janice Watson and Felicity Palmer
Photo © 2007 by Bill Cooper


The singers also tried, but to no avail. Janice Watson’s commendable Katya took so long to warm up to the task that it was too late when she finally made it. Her monologue before leaping into the river proves this point. She sang it excellently, but there was no tension whatsoever and her suicide came practically out of the blue. Felicity Palmer, whose last appearance at the House as Clytemnestra in Elektra four years ago was impressive, did not do a great job. Her vibrato was totally out of control and she sounded always harsh, as though she was on the verge of shouting. However despicable the role of Kabanicha might be, a fresher voice was indeed needed. Uninteresting renditions of Boris and Tichon were served by Kurt Streit and Chris Merritt, respectively. The best singers on stage were Linda Tuvas as Varvara and Toby Spence as Vana. The tenor, especially, did an excellent job.



Janice Watson, Felicity Palmer and Linda Tuvas
Photo © 2007 by Bill Cooper


The sets did not help much. Everything was correct, but nothing exciting. Not a single movement helped the drama in the slightest and at the end my feeling was that everything happened on a non-descript grey background. The characters were plain and moved around directionlessly. Unfortunately, I could not attend the performance of Don Giovanni that has been hailed by most critics and the public as one of the best ever. This means that my three last visits to Covent Garden to see Pelléas, Fidelio and Katya have been less than enjoyable. The first was due to a dull production, very-well sung and conducted. The second was wonderfully summarised by Alfredo López-Vivié in his review. I am now looking forward, however, to Così fan tutte, Tosca and Rigoletto. I am hoping things will be as good as they usually are.
Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.