Reino Unido

The chicken or the egg

Enrique Sacau
---
---
London, viernes, 31 de octubre de 2008.
The Royal Opera House, Covent Garden. Gioachino Rossini, Matilde di Shabran. Mario Martone, director. Sergio Tramonti, set designs. Ursula Patzak, costume designs. Pasquale Mari, lighting. Aleksandra Kurzak (Matilde), Juan Diego Flórez (Corradino), Mark Beesley (Raimondo), Vesselina Kasarova (Edoardo), Marco Vinco (Aliprando), Alfonso Antoniozzi (Isodoro), Enkelejda Shkosa (Contessa d’Arco), Carlo Lepore (Ginardo), Robert Anthony Gardiner (Egoldo), Bryan Secombe (Rodrigo). Orchestra & Chorus of the Royal Opera House. Renato Balsadonna, Chorus master. Carlo Rizzi, conductor
0,0001069 For hundreds of years we have been debating what came first, the chicken or the egg. In the interval of The Royal Opera’s new production of Matilde di Shabran somebody on the escalator attempted to use this as a metaphor for the relationship between Juan Diego Flórez and this piece by Rossini. Whilst it was Matilde which provided a platform for Flórez 's leap to fame at Pesaro, the opera itself is now being offered a renewed degree of attention as a vehicle for Florez's unique talents. In the case of Covent Garden, first came Juan Diego and then, to fit his capabilities and skills, Matilde was added to the opera season. Were it not for him, no artistic director would bother to put on this three-and-a-half-hour long opera, the first act of which lasts two hours (as long as Parsifal’s). Matilde's gorgeous music notwithstanding, the opera is hampered by weak dramatic pacing and a predictable plot which tails off badly towards the end. Still, seduced by the excellence of the performers, the audience seemed to have a great time. And, as importantly, Flórez was far from being the only star of the night.

Indeed, whilst the performance could have been conceived simply as a vehicle to showcase the impressive singing prowess of the Peruvian tenor, the Royal Opera worked hard on the casting (as usual) and gave Alexandra Kurzak the opportunity nearly to steal the show. If as Adina and Susanna in previous seasons she displayed a beautiful timbre, solid technique and commendable acting abilities, this time she asserted herself as a world-class artist. This was obvious in her ease at jumping over the vocal hurdles of the score, especially in the final rondo, sung by Kurzak with a combination of impeccable technique and bomb-proof confidence. As world-class singers do, she made us feel as though nothing could go wrong because La Kurzak was in charge.

On a par with Kurzak, as it was expected, Juan Diego Flórez reminded us that he is the best tenor of his kind… ever. It is almost unnecessary to relate his numerous virtues. I will mention only the one that makes him stand out amongst a long line of excellent Rossinians (i.e. Cesare Valletti, Luigi Alva, Rockwell Blake, Raul Gimenez…): however his voice may be small, he always sounds virile and strong, with no need to sing in falsetto or thin out the voice. During this performance of Matilde he also seemed to be having tremendous fun, which was contagious throughout the show.

Of international reputation, and allegedly world-class, Vesselina Kasarova was the disappointment of the evening. Saying the she is not good enough, as it has been insinuated, makes little sense. Indeed, Kasarova has all it takes to keep her reputation intact. Shame she insists on making all the wrong choices. Firstly, she makes no effort to integrate her registers, which produces horrible guttural sounds in the low one, hardly audible high notes and a blurry middle range. Secondly, she chops up her musical phrases, relishing every opportunity to get in the way of canto legato and nuance. Thirdly, and certainly less importantly, you cannot understand a word she says. It seems to me that Kasarova was trying (and failing) to sound like Marilyn Horne. In all, Kasarova’s rendition of Edoardo was painfully substandard and unworthy of a singer of her credentials.

Marco Vinco’s commendable medic and Antoniozzi’s hilarious (if not vocally exciting) Don Isidoro greatly contributed to a brilliant evening from the vocal point of view.

The musical icing on the cake came from the pit, authoritatively and yet flexibly conducted by an inspired Carlo Rizzi.

Mario Martone’s new production was a perfect frame for the musical display. With very simple, non-descript sets and meticulous direction of singers he did a lot with the simple plot and kept us all entertained. Martone’s production is enjoyable and exportable. Probably many opera houses will want it, at least as long as Flórez carries on singing the male role. Then, Matilde will probably end up in some storage facility awaiting a new Rossinian singer to rescue it.
Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.