Reino Unido
The best possible Tosca (I)
The Royal Opera House, Covent Garden. Giacomo Puccini, Tosca. Jonathan Kent, director. Paul Brown, designs. Mark Henderson, lighting. Angela Gheorghiu (Tosca), Massimo Giordano (Mario Cavaradossi), Bryn Terfel (Scarpia), Martyn Hill (Spoletta), Kostas Smoriginas (Angelotti), Jeremy White (Sacristan), John Morrissey (Gaoler). The Royal Opera House Orchestra and Chorus. Renato Balsadonna, chorus master. Jacques Lacombe, conductor.
Perhaps I should commence by saying that Gheorghiu is my favourite living soprano, if one who does not always give you 100%. When she does, she is unbeatable for three reasons: she possesses an impeccable technique, which has kept her timbre almost unchanged for twenty years; she has a beautiful lyric voice with a dramatic (almost tearful) tint; and, finally, she is a consummate actress. This last virtue helped her perfectly to portray Tosca’s journey from jealous brat to imperious, commanding woman ready to do anything to save the life of her partner and keep her own on track. As for the voice, the performance I attended was a masterclass. Everything seemed to be working for this soprano with perfectly integrated registers, taste to make you melt with 'Vissi d’arte' and power to be heard alongside Terfel and carry well above the orchestra during act 2’s testing torture scene, often best served by dramatic sopranos. I think maliciously that perhaps Gheorghiu used the 2006 round to test her voice as Tosca and learn the part properly; now that she knows it, I can hardly wait for her return.

Next to Gheorghiu’s, the commendable performances of Massimo Giordano (who, amusingly, replaced Marcello Giordani) and Bryn Terfel could not but fade a little. Giordano needed 'Recondita armonia' to warm up and then seemed increasingly in command of his voice and of the taxing role of Mario, which he finished with a carefully crafted rendition of 'E lucevan le stelle'. Terfel’s Scarpia is no gentleman: he depicts the head of the Roman police as an opportunistic, uncouth and lecherous man, one whose fall you wish from the moment he walks into the church in act 1. As usual with the Welsh baritone, Terfel is more at ease when he sings forte so he can thunder and awe; also as usual, his attempts at piano singing ('Via cavaliere riflettete' and 'Ebbene?') could hardly be heard (and I was sitting on the fourth row). Thanks to his stage presence and acting talent, though, Terfel’s is the Scarpia of our times.
Jacques Lacombe conducted with firm hand, accompanied the singers very considerately and yet didn’t give in to the temptation to muffle the orchestra so the voices took precedence. Hence, he found the right balance between playing Puccini’s orchestral part in all its luscious greatness and letting the singers be heard – not an easy one. The chorus and supporting singers were excellent; pity they had to move about Paul Brown’s unimaginative sets and cope with Kent’s equally unexciting direction which even resorts to the use of flags, a rather amateurish and old-fashioned trick, to fill the space in act 1. Opera, however, is mostly about the music and, particularly, about acting with the voice – and with Gheorghiu in such good form, little else really mattered.
Comentarios