Reino Unido
A good start
The Royal Opera House, Covent Garden. Gaetano Donizetti, Linda di Chamounix. Elizabeth Sikora (Maddalena Loustolot), Ludovic Tézier (Antonio Loustolot), Alessandro Corbelli (Marchese de Boisfleury), Luciano Botelho (Intendente), Eglise Gutiérrez (Linda), Marianna Pizzolato (Pierotto), Balint Szabó (Prete). The Royal Opera Orchestra & Chorus. Renato Balsadonna, chorus director. Mark Elder, conductor
The cast featured some safe bets such as Ludovic Tézier and Alessandro Corbelli, together with debutants Balint Szabó, Marianna Pizzolato and Stephen Costello. Costello - who is returning in October as Rinuccio (Gianni Schicchi) - made a great impression, thanks to his ardent singing which, after overcoming some initial nervousness, became truly world class. No wonder he is already dear to so many American opera bloggers, especially the ‘mother’ of them all at parterre.com. Szabó starred one of the best moments of the evening in his duet with Tézier; and Pizzolato deserves a comeback to Covent Garden so we can enjoy again her dark timbre and beautiful legato singing.
Only Eglise Gutiérrez was a bit less good than her peers. Or was she not? I was not sure what to think when I left the House and am still quite unsure, probably because I dislike the idea of being fastidious about voices. And yet, there’s something about hers that made me feel occasionally uncomfortable. On the one hand, she can sing very high notes and accurately deliver fast coloratura; on the other, every time she went above a G she didn’t make one feel safe. In such moments she slowed down the tempo and thinned out the voice – an effect she tried to make look and sound like an aesthetic choice, but which in fact suggested that she just cannot sing forte or col tempo at such height. Moreover, the faces which she pulled at these moments conveyed the impression that she was actually in physical pain. If this is the case, why is she selling herself as Linda di Chamounix instead of concentrating on lyric roles with which she could show her otherwise beautiful voice? Please, bring her back as Adina, but let others sing ‘O luce di quest’anima’.
I will repeat myself if I say yet again in another positive review of Mark Elder that he was good beyond belief, as always. Let the following question be my assessment of his performance: given that Antonio Pappano has announced that he is leaving in 2012, could someone please make sure Elder gets appointed as artistic director then? Thank you.
Comentarios