Reino Unido

The global gig of the season

Enrique Sacau
The global gig of the season
London, viernes, 2 de julio de 2010.
The Royal Opera House, Covent Garden. Giuseppe Verdi, Simon Boccanegra. Elijah Moshinsky, Director. Michael Yeargan, Set designs. Peter J. Hall, Costume designs. John Harrison, Lighting design. William Hobbs, Fight director. Jonathan Summers (Paolo Albiani), Lukas Jakobski (Pietro), Plácido Domingo (Simon Boccanegra), Ferruccio Furlanetto (Jacopo Fiesco), Marina Poplavskaya (Amelia Grimaldi), Joseph Calleja (Gabriele Adorno), Louise Armit (Amelia’s maidservant), Lee Hickenbottom (Captain). Orchestra and Chorus of the Royal Opera House, Covent Garden. Renato Balsadonna, Chorus director. Antonio Pappano, Conductor
0,0001055 At 69 Spanish tenor Plácido Domingo has managed to grab the opera world’s attention by making his debut as Simon Boccanegra at some of the most important theatres in the world. His first time singing as a baritone for very many years, Domingo’s Simon has become the most discussed opera gig of the 2009-10 season. The wait for it was somewhat nerve-wracking. In the Spring, Domingo cancelled his Tamerlano at the Royal Opera House as a result of an operation that was then announced as of colonic cancer. Very few thought Domingo would be back on time to sing Simon at La Scala and London, but the global superstar, larger than life, returned to the stages to be acclaimed, once again, as one of the most phenomenal figures of the opera world since the invention of recordings.

In order to sing Simon all over the world, Domingo surrounded himself by top singers and conductors, namely Daniel Barenboim, Antonio Pappano, Ferruccio Furlanetto and Anja Harteros - the latter, unfortunately, didn’t sing in London and was substituted by Marina Poplavskaya. Unlike other opera stars who have aged far less graciously than Domingo, he wanted to share the stage with nothing but the best. And yet, his was the best performance of the evening.

Domingo’s Simon is, naturally, quite light, since the voice is not as dark and deep as that of the baritones who have triumphed in this role. Yet, the contrast between his rather low tenor voice and Furlanetto’s deep rendition of Fiesco worked well. Domingo’s phrasing is intense, as ever, his fiato reliable and obviously he doesn’t struggle with the upper end of the rage needed for Simon. In particular, his death scene was utterly moving and granted him the most thunderous applause of the evening. There was real pain in his voice when he languished in the arms of his daughter Amelia. His acting is, perhaps too predictably, a bit old fashioned. I wouldn’t want this to sound like criticism. It isn’t, given that the effect on the audience (and the effect is all that matters) is that of a consummate actor. What I mean is that, by comparison, the way he moves on stage, often keeping one foot and leg slightly behind to emphasise the feeling of motion, is not often done by singers any more.

Furlanetto’s Fiesco was occasionally strained – time passes even for Ferruccio who has made us enjoy so very many amazing opera nights (most recently, as Filippo II in Verdi’s Don Carlo). I didn’t mind. He compensated for that with great doses of pathos and superior acting. That wasn’t the case with Jonathan Summers, who sang Elijah Moshinsky’s serviceable production when it was premiered in 1981 – nowadays, Paolo is too much for Summers, once a distinguished baritone.

Maltese tenor Joseph Calleja was at his best as Gabriele Adorno. I used to be quite sceptical about Calleja, but every time he comes to Covent Garden he has improved a notch and I have warmed up to him. The voice is there, resplendent; it is only the phrasing that can be occasionally wooden, brutish. More work is needed, therefore, in articulating better, more subtly – when he gets it right, he makes you melt.

Poplavskaya’s problem is quite the opposite. She means well when it comes to phrasing, aims high and attempts subtle singing, with high piano notes and beautiful ornaments. It is the voice that lets her down. In the top, her timbre sounds often strangled and intonation problems are not uncommon. As a result, she sounds effortful which doesn’t help when you have to sing the floating ‘Come in quest’ora bruna’, an aria that was rightly met with silence by the audience (not one person clapped). In all, Poplavskaya is a good singer, but it is quite difficult to understand why she is casted so often as the prima donna at so many Royal Opera shows – she is simply not good enough for that yet. Perhaps she has been overexposed? Harteros, who was the previous Amelia at Covent Garden, was sorely missed.

Pappano was amongst the top performers of the evening. If I usually prefer him with Puccini, Shostakovich or Britten than with Verdi (who should be left to Mark Elder), as the opera progressed he weaved together an instrumentally beautiful cloth, stained with tears in his simply superb accompaniment of Domingo as he passes away. This very enjoyable musical evening took place in the frame of quite boring yet still usable 1981 Moshinsky production, one of the few relics of Covent Garden’s not-so-recent past.
Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.