Reino Unido
A great new Aida “due to pregnancy”
The Royal Opera House, Covent Garden. Giuseppe Verdi, Aida. David McVicar, Director. Jean-Marc Puissant, Set designs. Moritz Junge, Costume designs. Jennifer Tipton, Lighting. Fin Walker, Choreography. David Greeves, Martial arts director. Leah Hausman, Associate director. Vitalij Kowaljow (Ramfis), Carlo Ventre (Radames), Olga Borodina (Amneris), Liudmila Monastyrska (Aida), Brindley Sherratt (King of Egypt), Steven Ebel (Messenger), Madeleine Pierard (High Priestess), Carlos Almaguer (Amonasro). Orchestra and Chorus of the Royal Opera House, Covent Garden. Renato Balsadonna, Chorus director. Fabio Luisi, Conductor
Indeed, despite the fact that McVicar concentrated most of his movement on the chorus (but seemingly did little with the soloists), Liudmila Monastryska navigated the production rather gracefully. And she acted with the voice, which is after all what opera is about. Her solid 'Ritorna vincitor', with adequate use of the colours of her voice to express both excitement and anxiety, was perhaps the weakest link of a brilliant rendition of Aida with two cherries on top. The first one was 'O patria mia', which Monastyrska attacked like all the great and the good of the Aida tradition. A tense line, thoughtful and subtle inflections and a sense of climax that made her pace herself adequately and give it all at the right moments achieving the desired effect. The second was the final scene performed with determination (Aida is determined to be buried alive alongside Radames) yet with moments of utter terror when it dawns upon her the grave decision she has made. Are her voice or technique truly exceptional? Perhaps not, but I will reserve my judgement in the light of such a musical, heart-felt, deeply moving rendition of a very difficult role. I can only say that I’m looking forward to her next visit to the Royal Opera as Lady Macbeth in June.
In contrast, Carlo Ventre’s Royal Opera debut as Radames was fairly pedestrian. With 'Celeste Aida' he seemed unsure, phrased it without any flair, used portamento much too often, yet admittedly nailed the final note. In a way, it seemed as though he was simply saving himself for that moment. It didn’t quite pay off, as the audience acknowledged the feat with a discreet applause. His performance, it must be said, improved gradually and reached its best moment in the final scene, which left us all with a good aftertaste. Generally, however, he may be young but he doesn’t sound fresh. Perhaps a primo uomo role at one of the top opera houses in the world is a bit much for him, at least for the time being.
I have never felt Borodina is the most communicative of singers, yet one whose voice is so magnificent and imperious that you can’t help but surrender and applaud. A bit like Fiorenza Cosotto, one I don’t listen to when I want to cry or to laugh, but one whose masterful singing makes me take off my hat. Once the voice of such singers falters, even a bit, then they become far less interesting. At the risk of sounding harsh, and making a point about my tremendous respect for Borodina, her last two appearances at the Royal Opera (now as Amneris and the previous one this very season as Princess de Bouillon) have left me quite cold. Her top notes are no longer ringing, but pushed, shrieked, whilst her middle and lower ones are still impressive. In act 3, her top moment, she sang well, yet not well enough to support a rendition of Amneris that lacked Monastyrska´s range of nuance.
Making his Royal Opera debut, Fabio Luisi conducted authoritatively. He provided us with many an enjoyable moment and the singers with the necessary support. In all, this performance was far better than the first run of performances. I think this for a number of reasons: I have got used to the perfectly workable production; this Aida was infinitely better; and Luisi did, if anything, make it all come together much more nicely. Shame I can’t report on Alagna’s Radames, but there will be other opportunities. Performed as on this occasion, Aida deserves regular revivals.
Comentarios