Reino Unido

A Royal Opera Classic

Enrique Sacau
A Royal Opera Classic
Londres, viernes, 10 de junio de 2011.
The Royal Opera House, Covent Garden. Giuseppe Verdi, Macbeth. Phyllida Lloyd, director. Anthony Ward, sets and costume designs. Paule Constable, lighting design. Simon Keenlyside (Macbeth), Raymond Aceto (Banquo), Liudmyla Monastyrska (Lady Macbeth), Dmitri Pittas (Macduff), Steven Ebel (Malcolm), Elisabeth Meister (Lady-in-waiting), Lukas Jakobski (Doctor). Orchestra and Chorus of the Royal Opera House, Covent Garden. Antonio Pappano, conductor
0,0001095 Opera productions can often seem like exercises in interior design: detailed attempts at stage decoration or the recreation of landscape, which play little or no part in the telling of the story. This is thankfully not the case in Phyllida Lloyd’s now classic Royal Opera staging of Giuseppe Verdi’s Macbeth. Her take on Verdi’s uneven piece arguably looks very dated, but the ideas are still meaningful. The enhanced role of the witches - who make sure their prophecy holds true - together with the symbiotic relationship between the protagonist pair’s bed and the throne, are perhaps the two most salient ways in which the director actively contributes to shaping the opera. Anthony Ward’s sets lend themselves to these games, as they effectively give Macbeth and his wife the space they need to think and plot in rather claustrophobic sets, whilst surrounding them by their remorse even when they sleep - as happens, rather wonderfully, during the choir’s ‘Patria oppressa’, half-way between dream and reality.

Musically, this perfectly serviceable Macbeth will not go down in history as particularly memorable. Antonio Pappano’s Verdi often favours depth of tone at the expense of rhythmic urgency, savouring tonal detail rather than finding musical meaning in the buoyancy of Verdi’s trademark triplets. As a result, some moments are beautifully dramatic whilst not enough work seems to go into turning the strette and other less obviously “profound” passages into enjoyable, thrilling musical journeys. On the whole, his tempi were often ponderous, even if intelligent support for the singers and great work with the timbre were never lacking. Whilst perfectly good, Pappano really is at his best when conducting Puccini, whilst Verdi is often better served, at least at the Royal Opera, by Sir Mark Elder.



Momento de la representación
© 2011 by Clive Barda. Gentileza de ROH-Covent Garden


Simon Keenlyside’s Macbeth was very solid indeed in a part which suits his current vocal condition. A baritone who can be histrionic, he tamed his instinct and opted for an introspective portrayal of Shakespeare’s character; he turns most characters he sings into vulnerable human beings, leaving bravado and macho singing to other baritones. I like him very much for this reason. In this approach, Macbeth truly was the instrument of Lady Macbeth and as usual his voice sounded rounded ( if a bit colourless on the top end) and always carried perfectly. The Lady Macbeth to whose vicious temper Keenlyside deferred was loudly sung by Liudmyla Monastyrska, who had made her debut at the Royal Opera as Aida only two months ago. As Aida, always aiming for subtle phrasing and delicate floating sounds, she showed us her lyric side and an infallible musical instinct. As Lady Macbeth she chose to show us her canons-blazing sound, to mixed results. There is no denying that her imposing voice did shock and awe (good for her), but sometimes that seemed to be her only trick, one that she occasionally deployed at the expense of accurate intonation. Her "here-I-am" take on Lady Macbeth didn’t prevent her from intelligently and effectively portraying the increasingly deranged mental state of her character- an acting quality that was no surprise for those who enjoyed her convincing Aida. She will undoubtedly be back at the house soon.

Raymond Aceto delivered an imposing Banquo and Dmitri Pittas offered a grief-ridden Macduff, nearly making me forget Joseph Calleja the last time Macbeth was done at the Royal Opera. The chorus displayed their usual excellence and happily rounded off a good revival of Verdi’s early work. All in all, a solid start to the summer season.
Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.