Alemania
Twenty-First Century Mahler
The twenty-first century is still in the process of auditioning its first great Mahler conductor. With the age of Kubelík, Barbirolli and Bernstein long behind us, and even the legacies of Abbado, Tennstedt and Boulez beginning to grow fixed in the past, the time has come for a new generation of interpreters who are unafraid of the grandly scaled emotions found within Mahler’s scores. Of the younger conductors working today, Andris Nelsons has suggested he might be up to the task. Although his reading of the Fifth symphony – performed as part of a recent guest appearance with the Berlin Philharmonic – was not without its flaws, it had the merits of being consistently intriguing and frequently exciting; most importantly, it revealed a conductor who seemed to have little interest in playing it safe.
Before the Mahler, however, the programme opened with a performance of HK Gruber’s Aerial, a trumpet concerto written for Håkan Hardenberger, who was on hand to perform the solo part. It was a curious piece; to write it off simply as a compendium of extended technique would be to gloss over its strangely adversarial quality. Indeed, the first movement appeared to be guided by some strange desire to undermine the role of the solo instrument. The first appearance of the trumpet sounded like a fluffed note. This was followed by a series of sustained notes which started clearly but soon degenerated into a multiphonic buzz. It was hard to tell if the composer was playing a joke on the soloist or the audience, but the idea of a world-class trumpet player producing such sputtering, murky sounds – regardless of the extraordinary skill that would have been involved in playing them accurately – was both faintly amusing and somewhat uncomfortable.
Subsequent passages involved muted glissandi, and several sections in which Mr Hardenberger removed the tuning slides before playing, creating a series of defiantly uncrystalline squeals. He switched momentarily to a piccolo trumpet, and there was a longer passage for cow horn that was, for its unearthly sound, not unpleasant. Yet despite its near-constant invention, the piece seemed intent on denying the audience the one sound that one might expect to hear in a trumpet concerto: that of a normally-played trumpet.
The second movement was arguably the more interesting of the two; there were fewer instrument changes, and every so often the orchestra would lock into something resembling an uneasy groove, albeit one that seemed at odds with the solo part. Still, one could hardly doubt the commitment of Mr Hardenberger’s performance. Although he was constantly modifying his instrument, reaching for mutes – or, at the end, walking over to the piano to blow the final note onto the sounding board – he dealt with the unusual technical requirements with natural grace. Mr Hardenberger and Mr Nelsons, a former trumpet player himself, have performed this piece together in other cities over the past several months and the experience was evident; as odd as the piece may have sounded, its oddities were at least consummately executed.
If Aerial had been entertaining for its theatricality, Mahler’s Fifth, which made up the second half of the programme, was the evening’s more substantial achievement. Yet it was clear from the outset that this would be no polite performance of an established symphonic masterwork. When the full orchestra came in after the introductory trumpet, it sounded immense, cataclysmic and not a little dangerous. Mr Nelsons took the opening movement at the slowest possible pace, but he used the slowness to tease out every emotive lament from the strings and to underline the rhythmic force that pushed the music ever forward. If the movement was deliberate, it was never tentative; it may have walked with a limp but it also conveyed a sense of being unstoppable.
While the tempo may have seemed more suited to an older conductor, the impetuous outbursts definitely belonged to a young man in search of elusive truths. Mr Nelsons is often a lively presence on the podium, but here his gestures seemed stretched to the breaking point, as though he had internalised the struggle of the music and was straining to contain it. Under his direction, the orchestra had an edge of rawness; the sound was neither muddy nor undisciplined nor, with a few minor exceptions, excessively unbalanced, but the orchestra’s usual refinement had been replaced with a certain volatility. This was not necessarily a bad thing; a Mahler symphony will often benefit from a dash of grit.
After the deliberate tempi of the first movement, the opening of the second had the furious gallop of a scherzo, although it was not long before things settled back into a funereal pace. If parts of the second movement seemed more loosely formed, there were also some wonderful moments – including an extraordinary passage for timpani and cellos – and the conclusion was genuinely exciting.
Unfortunately the third movement never quite came together. The opening sounded more like a stately dance than a Scherzo, and from there the music fragmented into a series of introverted moments that, despite their occasional brilliance, seemed perpetually disconnected from the architecture of the movement as a whole. The quiet pizzicato sections were articulated to the point of exaggeration – they were fascinating, but also disruptive to the flow of the music – and while the end of the movement was actually quite thrilling, it required some extreme and none-too-subtle shifts in tempo to get there.
The final two movements, however, were magnificent. If the tempo of the Adagietto tended toward the slower end of the spectrum, the ability of Mr Nelsons to sculpt the individual phrases into a compelling whole – conducting without a baton, it occasionally looked as though he was swimming – was matched by playing from the strings that was rarely less than sublime. If other conductors might have kept the music moving more briskly, or attempted to wrest more emotion from the climaxes, the direct, immediate beauty of the Adagietto on this evening proved absolutely mesmerising.
Refreshed from the fourth-movement idyll, the full orchestra returned for the finale with renewed momentum and vigour. In terms of pace and detail, the fifth movement was arguably the most conventional reading of the evening, but the results were neither staid nor predictable. Both Mr Nelsons and the orchestra seemed to have reached a state of absolute focus, and together they navigated the dynamic shifts and inevitable build with an eloquence and exuberance that would have been difficult to surpass. Even a few brief moments when the orchestral balance seemed a touch unstable – the trombones, although on excellent form, threatened to dominate the final bars – could not undermine the infectious joy of the conclusion.
Although Mr Nelsons’ reading of the symphony may ultimately have suggested a work in progress rather than a set interpretation, the amount of excitement he was able to generate from a familiar score was certainly not negligible. On the strength of the evening’s performance, there is ample reason to hope that he will continue his exploration of Mahler’s symphonic corpus; a great cycle for the twenty-first century may yet come of it.
Comentarios