Alemania

Musikfest Berlin, part 2: The Lutoslawski Show

Jesse Simon
Musikfest Berlin, part 2: The Lutoslawski Show
Berlin, viernes, 6 de septiembre de 2013.
Philharmonie [6 September]. Lutosławski: Concerto for Orchestra. Bartók: Concerto for Orchestra. Symphonieorchester des Bayerischen Rundfunks. Mariss Jansons, conductor. Philharmonie [9 September]. Debussy: Prélude à l’après-midi d’un faune. Lutosławski: Les Espaces du sommeil. Ravel: Ma Mère l’Oye Suite. Lutosławski: Symphony No. 3. Matthias Goerne, Baritone. Philharmonia Orchestra. Esa-Pekka Salonen, conductor.
0,0001651

In the sixty years since its première, Lutosławski’s Concerto for Orchestra has been recorded a handful of times and has started to gain a tentative foothold within the established concert repertoire. However, in all that time, few people have made a case for the Concerto being a towering masterpiece of the twentieth century quite as persuasively as Mariss Jansons and the Symphonieorchester des Bayerischen Rundfunks, who delivered a triumphant performance as part of their appearance at Musikfest Berlin. Indeed, the whole evening – which featured an equally magnificent reading of Bartók’s Concerto for Orchestra – was thrilling from beginning to end and will certainly stand as one of the highlights of this year’s festival.

Lutosławski’s Concerto – a three movement work dedicated to the memory of Bartók – was completed in 1954, and is the earliest of the composer’s works to be represented at Musikfest. At this point in his career Lutosławski had not fully developed his highly personal sonic vocabulary and, as a result, the sound of the orchestra is remarkably traditional, at least by the standards of the early-twentieth century. Where Lutosławski is able to surprise us is not so much in his textural conception, but rather in his dramatic architecture and his inventive mixture of melodic themes and modernist devices. And yet, for all the technical skill required of a successful performance, the Concerto is not merely accessible, but can also, in the rights hands, be tremendously exciting.

Even from the opening bars, it was obvious that the evening’s performance was going to be something extraordinary. Mariss Jansons can bring great discipline to just about any orchestra he happens to be leading, but occasionally the dazzling precision of his control can seem overly mannered. However, when matched with the Concertgebouw or, especially, the Symphonieorchester des Bayerischen Rundfunks, he has the ability to reveal both subtleties and magnificences that other conductors might simply have neglected.

On this evening, Herr Jansons seemed determined to silence anyone who would write off Lutosławski’s Concerto as a minor work; and his reading – in which fierce urgency was balanced by meticulous judgment – was executed with orchestral playing that was close to faultless. While there was stunning work from each section – including some noteworthy playing from the percussionists in the second movement – it was the cohesion and vitality of the orchestra as a whole that ultimately proved most impressive. There could be few people in the Philharmonie unmoved by the music being created on the stage; and when the last notes of the piece had died away – soon to be replaced by vigorous applause – one could only wonder how such a monumental work had remained hidden in plain sight for so long.

Bartók’s Concerto – completed ten years before Lutosławski’s, and only a year before the composer’s own death – received a performance that was hardly less authoritative. As with the previous work, Bartók’s conception of the orchestra as a series of virtuoso groups required individual and collective playing of the highest calibre, a task for which the Symphonieorchester des Bayerischen Rundfunks had already demonstrated their credentials. The piece featured some especially fine work from the solo piccolo and oboe and, in the second movement, a sense of profound unity emerged from the brass. The strings in the third movement were rich and lyrical, and the fourth movement – with its Shostakovich quotation and quasi-comical slide trombones – was a delight from beginning to end.

One could not, again, help but marvel at the exceptional togetherness of the orchestra; however there was never a sense that the razor-sharp dynamic shifts and highly concentrated ensemble playing were being paraded as a gimmick or were in any way obscuring the humanity of the piece. Everything that happened on the stage occurred purely in the service of the music, and the result was an evening where the brilliance of these two orchestral concerti became impossible to ignore. It was a concert that will not soon be forgotten by anyone fortunate enough to be there.

Philharmonia Orchestra concert on September 9. Salonen acknowledging. Berlin Musikfest 2013

Three nights later, Lutosławski was once again given a prominent place within the programme, this time in a concert given by London’s Philharmonia Orchestra under the direction of Esa-Pekka Salonen. Where the Bartók of the previous concert had given context to one of Lutosławski’s early major works, the mid-period pieces on this evening – Les Espaces du Sommeil and the Symphony No. 3 – were further illuminated by two gems from turn-of-the-century France, Debussy’s Prélude à l’après-midi d’un faune and Ravel’s Ma Mère l’Oye suite.

The evening began with a suitably languid reading of Debussy’s Prélude, one of music’s most inexhaustible sources of delight. Herr Salonen managed to coax some truly alchemical playing from the string section, and the principal flautist – upon whom so much of the piece depends – did an excellent job of weaving his solo parts into the diaphanous textures of Debussy’s late-romantic orchestra. For the principal flautist, however, the Prélude was merely a warm-up, as each of the subsequent pieces of the evening would feature solo passages of varying complexity.

Debussy’s Prélude turned out to be an ideal introduction to Lutosławski’s Les Espaces du Sommeil, a beautiful extended song for baritone and orchestra in which distant echoes of the early twentieth-century French school could still be heard within the composer’s personal sound world. The piece – a setting of a poem by Robert Desnos – describes a series of wanderings through a nocturnal landscape of dreams and half-thoughts; it was given an extraordinary performance by Matthias Goerne, who captured the heavy-lidded somnambulance and brooding uncertainty of Desnos’ imagery. Meanwhile, the Philharmonia created an enveloping sense of unease beneath the words. It was, for all its impenetrable darkness, a wonderfully inviting place to be, and the only criticism that one might justifiably level at the piece is that is was over far too soon. Had they played the entire song again as an encore, I very much doubt anyone would have complained.

The second half of the programme – which mirrored the first half in its arrangement –began with Ravel’s Ma Mère l’Oye suite. As with the Debussy, Herr Salonen demonstrated his great affinity for the French school, offering a reading that was both appealingly spacious and constantly attuned to the expressive orchestration of which Ravel was such a master; and as with the first half, the Ravel suite acted as an apt prelude to a more demanding work on an altogether different scale.

Lutosławski’s Symphony No. 3, composed throughout the seventies and completed in 1983, is both a work of contrasts and a large-scale summation of the composer’s considerable capabilities. It is not, perhaps, an easy work to approach, but it can yield great rewards to those who make the attempt. Herr Salonen has long been a persuasive ambassador for Lutosławski’s symphonic output – his recordings are still, arguably, the finest available – and on this evening he directed the Philharmonia through a gripping performance that gained steadily in momentum and intensity. After the music had ended, the enthusiastic audience called Herr Salonen back to the podium no fewer than five times. On his fifth appearance, instead of bowing, he picked up the Symphony’s score and held it aloft to the sound of renewed cheering.

Of the three composers who formed the core of this year’s Musikfest Berlin programme – Janácek, Bartók and Lutosławski – it is perhaps the latter whose works have offered the most consistent sense of revelation. While his name may be well known to concert hall regulars – and while his music seems to command a profound respect and admiration from the conductors and soloists who perform it – Lutosławski’s oeuvre is still struggling for its place in the established canon. However if the music retailers of Berlin notice a sudden spike in sales of Lutosławski CDs this month, it may well be on the strength of these two extraordinary concerts.

 

 

Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.