Alemania
Re-consecration of the House
It is easy to take the concert hall for granted, perhaps because the relationship between music and space is so elusive; and yet, would the Vienna Philharmonic sound the same without the special acoustics of the Musikverein? Would operas at Bayreuth be quite so special if they were performed in an ordinary theatre? While an excellent orchestra will almost certainly sound excellent anywhere, the nature of the concert hall – not merely its acoustic properties, but the cumulative weight of history and the indefinable sensation of being there – can have the power to elevate a performance in ways that are rarely considered.
Thus, on the occasion of its 50th birthday, it is worth saying a few words in praise of Hans Scharoun’s Philharmonie. Since its opening in October of 1963 – with an auspicious performance of Beethoven’s Ninth under Herbert von Karajan – the building has become a fixture of Berlin’s musical life and has, in its subtle way, lent an unmistakable greatness to innumerable performances. The happy relationship between music and space is certainly not lost on the Berlin Philharmonic who, in honour of the hall’s anniversary, have programmed a week of celebratory concerts, each of which has been designed to take full advantage of Scharoun’s unique space.
The first of these concerts featured a performance of Bach’s Matthäus-Passion, a work with no less a sense of occasion than the Beethoven symphony used to consecrate the stage fifty years earlier. However the evening was no mere konzertant performance of a sacred work; it was, instead, presented in a site-specific semi-staging by theatre director Peter Sellars, in which the combined forces or the Philharmonic under the direction of Sir Simon Rattle, the Rundfunkchor, and a dream-team of vocal soloists transformed Bach’s setting for the Good Friday vespers into something close to a modern-day mystery play.
When critics discuss the innovations of the Philharmonie, they often mention the wonderful acoustics – aided, in no small part, by the now-iconic wooden sails that hang above the stage – and the fact that it was one of the first halls in the world to arrange the audience around the stage. Perhaps the greatest success of Scharoun’s design, however, is the absence of conspicuous structural elements common to halls of the nineteenth and early twentieth century; there are no columns, no proscenium arches, no overhanging balconies, no loges and no boxes. Instead, the space is open and unconstricted; as a result, it is virtually impossible to find a seat with bad views or poor sound.
This spatial and acoustic openness was crucial to the evening’s performance: although the orchestra remained on the stage, the choir and soloists were free to position themselves in different parts of the auditorium as needs dictated. The children’s choir in the opening chorus, for instance, emerged from one of the high terraces; Pontius Pilate, no doubt to the great surprise of the people sitting next to him, stood up and delivered his lines from one of the seats in E-block, directly above the stage; most effectively, the figure of Jesus – sung with magnificent warmth by Christian Gerhaher – appeared in different, increasingly higher parts of the auditorium during the second part.
All these movements and sudden appearances could easily have come across as theatrical gimmicks had they not been backed by such a tightly controlled sense of solemnity. The choir seem to have been instructed to spend their downtime looking as grief-stricken as possible, and the utterly captivating Magdalena Kožená wandered on and off the stage for her arias with the shell-shocked expression of someone who had just lost her entire family in a car accident; the lines of her recitatives were delivered as if she might burst into tears at any moment. Even the orchestra managed to maintain sombre expressions throughout. As with other works directed by Peter Sellars, there seemed to be a drama-school fascination with how much emotional impact one could coax from just a few wooden boxes, some stylised movements and a lot of people wearing black. It took some time to settle into Sellars’ world, but after a while it became increasingly easy to forget that there was anything else.
And then, of course, there was the music. The choruses, in many ways, form the central thread of the Passion and the Rundfunkchor Berlin delivered a performance that was never less than extraordinary, capturing both the severity and humanity of what remains some of Bach’s most inspired part writing. But as monumental as the Passion can be when the full resources are employed, many of the work’s most affecting moments are the simple chamber pieces that succeed or fail on the strength of a single voice and a group of merely two or three instrumentalists.
Thus, among the highlights of the evening were Camilla Tilling’s ‘Aus Liebe will mein Heiland sterben’ surrounded by a flute and two oboes de caccia, and the bass aria ‘Gebt mir meinen Jesum wieder’, which was as much a showcase for singer Eric Owens as it was for the solo-violinist who provided his principal accompaniment. In her different arias, Magdalena Kožená was responsible for several of the evening’s high-points, including a suitably tragic ‘Ach, nun ist mein Jesus hin’ and a devastating ‘Sehet, Jesus hat die Hand’. However the hardest working person on stage – apart, perhaps, from the continuo organist – was undoubtedly the tenor Mark Padmore, who gave a magnificent performance as the Evangelist. Herr Padmore – who, in addition to singing, was called upon to spend much of his time contorted into different positions of pain and suffering – executed this challenging role with a near perfect blend of declamatory authority and dramatic anguish.
The orchestra, who started the evening with tempi that seemed almost too urgent and forceful for the subject at hand, grew more spacious and contemplative as the piece edged toward its denouement. The last half hour, especially, achieved a remarkable intensity; as the orchestra, the choirs and the soloists rose to higher levels, the light in the auditorium began to dim. At the very end, once the final bars of ‘Wir setzen uns mit Tränen nieder’ – surely one of Bach’s most moving choruses – had faded away, the last of the light too began to disappear, until finally there was nothing left except silence and darkness.
Would the evening have been any different had the performance occurred in a church, or even in the ornate shoebox-style hall of the pre-1944 Philharmonie? Of course it would have, although it is impossible to say precisely how. In a way, the question is irrelevant. The evening’s performance of the Matthäus-Passion was both a ceremonial act of reconsecration for a much-belovèd building, and an essential reminder that music and space have always been inseparable. The music of Bach’s Passion has moved audiences – both in the church and the concert hall – for nearly three centuries; perhaps in two hundred years, if the forces of history are favourable, the people of Berlin will still be able to spend a Friday evening in Scharoun’s magnificent auditorium and witness some of the same magic that we have been fortunate enough to experience over the past half century.
Comentarios