Alemania

Death of a Ladies’ Man

Jesse Simon
Death of a Ladies’ Man
Berlin, lunes, 21 de octubre de 2013.
Schiller Theater. Mozart: Don Giovanni KV 527. Claus Guth, director. Christopher Maltman, Don Giovanni; Christine Schäfer, Donna Anna; Rolando Villazón, Don Ottavio; Jan Martiník, Il Commendatore; Dorothea Röschmann, Donna Elvira; Adrian Sâmpetrean, Leporello; Adam Plachetka, Masetto; Anna Prohaska, Zerlina. Staatsoper Berlin Orchestra. Daniel Barenboim, conductor
9,82E-05

Of the three operas created by Mozart and the librettist Lorenzo da Ponte, it is Don Giovanni alone where the gauzy curtains of social comedy are pulled back far enough to reveal the unfathomable darkness that exists just beneath the actions and desires of the characters. It is a darkness that is easily ignored, as demonstrated by the numerous productions over the years that have treated the opera as a simple comedy with a necessarily moral ending. However in Claus Guth’s haunting production – which opened at the Staatsoper Berlin at the very end of the 2011/12 season and makes a welcome return this month – the darkness is brought to the fore to such an extent that it becomes endless and inescapable.

Although the production takes place in an identifiably modern world – Don Ottavio has a mobile phone and drives a Chrysler; Leporello dresses like a thug and shoots heroin; several characters carry guns – Herr Guth’s vision of the opera goes considerably further than mere modernisation. The action takes place within a dark forest, littered with beer cans and other detritus; but while there are a few identifiable places, including a clearing and an abandoned bus shelter, much of the story unfolds in a gloomy undifferentiated wilderness. As far as the characters may walk, the trees never end, the signs of human life never appear and the morning twilight never comes. The longer the story goes on, the more one arrives at an uneasy sense that the characters are trapped in some kind of nocturnal prison.

 

Mozart's Don Giovanni. Claus Guth, director. Daniel Barenboim, conductor. Berlin, Schiller Theater, october 2013

 

In addition to this sinister and vaguely existential setting, Herr Guth has made two rather inventive interpretive decisions which, although they do not in any way affect Da Ponte’s text, give the familiar story a new spin. The first of these concerns Don Giovanni himself who, in his altercation with the Commendatore, is fatally wounded; although he is bandaged by Leporello – and given a dose of smack to ease the pain – he essentially spends the whole of the opera slowly bleeding to death. His moribund condition makes his continued efforts at womanising seem all the more pathetic, and also allows for a more naturalistic – although no less bleak – reading of the opera’s great climactic reckoning.

Herr Guth’s other major point of interpretation involves the relationship between Donna Anna and Don Ottavio. In this telling, Anna is not only aware of who is trying to seduce her in the opening scene, but actively prefers the rakish Giovanni to the stultifyingly earnest Ottavio. One can see why; Ottavio has always been such an irredeemably dull character that even the most charismatic tenor in the world would have trouble rescuing him. Anna’s obsession with Giovanni – she dreams of him appearing while Ottavio bores her to death with ‘Dalla sua pace’ – has the pleasing effect of clarifying her awkwardness and rendering her character both more sympathetic and more complex.

 

Mozart's Don Giovanni. Claus Guth, director. Daniel Barenboim, conductor. Berlin, Schiller Theater, october 2013

 

As insightful as the direction was – and as much as it offered a uniquely dark vision of the story – it never interfered with the music, which remained as great a source of delight as ever. Daniel Barenboim’s musical direction, which was already strong in the production’s initial run, seemed to have developed new, more trenchant insights into the dramatic possibilities of the score; and among the cast – similar to the première cast, but with a few notable changes – there were mostly strong performances, with a handful that could justifiably described as exceptional.

Dorothea Röschmann was, once again, simply wonderful as Donna Elvira; not only did she bring a great humanity and a palpable sadness to the role, but she also navigated the technical demands of her solo passages with an elegance and poise that few on stage could match. Her Act II aria ‘Mi tradi quell’alma ingrata’ has rarely been performed with a more captivating sense of loss and regret. Meanwhile, Rolando Villazón made the most of Don Ottavio; although his ‘Dalla sua pace’ seemed oddly phrased in places, he delivered ‘Il mio tesoro’ with lyricism and passion, while subtly underlining the character’s essential ineffectuality. And Anna Prohaska’s Zerlina was a constant delight; her ‘Batti batti, O bel Masetto’ in Act I was beguilingly tender, although she was able to summon necessary levels of outrage during the wonderful second act sextet. However, perhaps the most surprising performance belonged to Christopher Maltman, who had seemed merely adequate last year but, on this evening, delivered an exciting, commanding and eminently charismatic Giovanni.

 

Mozart's Don Giovanni. Claus Guth, director. Daniel Barenboim, conductor. Berlin, Schiller Theater, october 2013

 

While the individual singers distinguished themselves, for the most part, in their arias and duets, it was the marvellous ensemble scenes that possessed the greatest energy and provided the evening with its most memorable moments. The sextet from the middle of the second act – already one of Mozart’s most dynamic displays of musical drama – managed to be considerably greater than the sum of its already impressive parts; and the extended finale to the first act was magnificent throughout. Not only was the orchestral playing of the highest possible quality – the fanfare that introduces Giovanni’s address to his servants has never sounded better – but the singing at times reached levels that were close to sublime; the quiet trio between Elvira, Anna and Ottavio was exquisite, while the final scene, in which Giovanni manages to elude his would-be captors, was among the two or three most inspired moments of the evening.

Herr Guth’s psychologically acute reading of Don Giovanni certainly did its utmost to emphasise the hopelessness and futility of the story and its principal characters; and the decision to omit the final sextet – which, in any event, has not always been considered a canonical part of the score – certainly ensured that no unwanted shafts of light would be allowed to interfere with the existential tragedy unfolding before us. Ultimately, however, the intriguing darkness of the production could not dim the inexhaustible joy that comes from hearing some of Mozart’s finest vocal music performed by such an estimable and committed ensemble of musicians.

Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.