Alemania
Major and minor fourths
Not every piece written by a great composer is great … but the corpus of any decent composer will contain a number of works which remain neglected simply because no one has bothered to draw attention to their greatness. Schubert’s Fourth Symphony was composed in 1816 but, in the two subsequent centuries, it has remained poorly served on record and is infrequently spotted on concert programmes. At long last, however, the symphony may have found its most ardent ambassador in Gustavo Dudamel.
Herr Dudamel has been a frequent and welcome visitor to the podium of the Philharmonie in recent years, and he has captivated audiences with his tense, stirring and often brilliant readings of the big classics. Certainly there can be no doubting the grace and majesty he is able to bring to a large-scale showpiece such as Also Sprach Zarathustra; but his most recent programme as guest conductor of the Berlin Philharmonic – which, in addition to the Schubert, also featured Beethoven’s underrated Fourth symphony and Stravinsky’s two brief Suites for Small Orchestra – seemed almost pointedly devoted to works that might normally be considered slight, or counted among the more minor achievements of each composer. In the end, however, it was an inspired selection, a memorable concert and, in the case of the Schubert, something of a revelation.
The two suites by Stravinsky – both in four movements, neither longer than ten minutes in total – were employed as something like an amuse-bouche, one before each symphony. The first – lively and eminently Stravinskian – was over almost before one had a chance to acclimatise one’s self to the dimmed lights of the concert hall. Each movement was a self-contained miniature, full of rhythmic dynamism and good humour. It was the second of the suites, however, which proved to the more intriguing; propelled by some extraordinary playing from the woodwinds, the pieces were infused with a delightful swagger and momentum. The second movement in particular, with its drunken waltz time kept by the clarinets and some breathless flute playing, so delighted the audience that it was followed by a small round of mid-piece applause.
The bulk of the evening, however, was devoted to the two symphonies numbered ‘four’. Schubert’s symphony – in the key of C minor, and bearing the composer’s own subtitle ‘Tragic’ – was written when the composer was only nineteen, and it is often judged a minor work, closer to a study than a mature composition. Apparently no one bothered to inform Herr Dudamel, who burrowed into the opening Adagio section as if it were Schubert’s other minor-key symphony, the justly beloved ‘Unfinished’. Suddenly the Adagio became an Allegro, and an agitated figure in the strings exploded into a profound cry of anguish. It was clear, from that moment, that we were witnessing something very special, a minor masterpiece emerging from its secret hiding place.
The first movement proceeded with magnificent tension; it may have represented an attempt, on the part of the youthful Schubert, to emulate the classical sonata form, but the melodic and rhythmic invention captured in Herr Dudamel’s reading suggested the restless energy of a composer who would one day expand upon the idea of what a symphony could be. The second and third movements – an introspective Andante and a Menuet/Trio respectively – also possessed numerous moments of beauty and inspiration, while the dramatic closing movement was every bit as revelatory as the opening.
It may have been Herr Dudamel who possessed the insight into Schubert’s score, but it was the Berlin Philharmonic who deserve full credit for realising his vision. The strings appeared to be having an especially good evening, articulating the details of the piece with wonderful richness and clarity. However the whole orchestra were on excellent form and it seemed that there was not a person on stage who wasn’t fully committed to demonstrating just how great this ‘minor’ symphony could sound.
Beethoven’s Fourth – which, along with the second Stravinsky suite, made up the programme’s second half – has a more assured place in the pantheon and, over the years, has inspired numerous persuasive advocates. Nonetheless, it is rarely mentioned in the same breath as any of the odd-numbered symphonies, and is perhaps more beloved of musicians and composers – Berlioz and Schumann were both fans – than concert audiences. Once again, Herr Dudamel seemed determined to show us how exciting the work could be; and if it proved to be marginally less of a revelation than the Schubert, it was simply because Beethoven’s symphony has been more comprehensively explored.
Herr Dudamel’s insights were nowhere more apparent than in the thrilling opening movement, which took the prefatory adagio at the lower limits of that tempo and, for good measure, added a healthy dose of misterioso; this resulted in an allegro section that, when it arrived, seemed almost dangerously rapid, but lacked nothing in clarity and refinement. Herr Dudamel, who has demonstrated his great affinity for Beethoven in the past, had no trouble conjuring appropriate grandeur for the second movement, finding a lively dance pace for the third, and zeroing in on the restless rhythmic momentum of the conclusion. As with the rest of the concert, the playing of the orchestra was never less than superb.
The evening’s concert, in addition to featuring on the Philharmonic’s online video streaming service, was also broadcast live to a number of cinemas around Europe, meaning that a higher than average number of people will have been able to witness the chemistry that clearly exists between the young, charismatic conductor and the august orchestra. The filming also meant that there appeared to be a higher than average number of microphones suspended above the stage, and one can hope that at least a few of those microphones belonged to the sound engineers at Deutsche Grammophon; such a vivid account of Schubert’s Fourth would be a welcome addition to any music library. In the meantime, we can look forward to the surprises and revelations that will invariably come when Herr Dudamel decides to draw our attention to pieces we may have underestimated.
Comentarios