Alemania

The Human Factor

Jesse Simon
The Human Factor
Berlin, jueves, 9 de enero de 2014.
Deutsche Oper Berlin. Richard Wagner: Die Walküre (Der Ring des Nibelungen: Day 1). Götz Friedrich, director. Cast: Peter Seiffert (Siegmund), Reinhard Hagen (Hunding), Terje Stensvold (Wotan), Heidi Melton (Sieglinde), Daniela Sindram (Fricka), Linda Watson (Brünnhilde). Deutsche Oper Choir and Orchestra. Donald Runnicles, conductor
0,0001953

It’s fine to spend a bit of time in the company of the gods, but the deeply flawed nature of humans is always going to make for a better story. If Das Rheingold relies too heavily on the presentation of mythological events through stage-craft and special effects, Die Walküre shifts the balance back in the direction of the singers, the music, and the drama of human emotion. Although there are still shattered swords and magic fire, there are also intertwined tales of doomed love (doomed, incestuous love, no less), and one character’s mighty fall from grace; and, on this evening, those stories were brought to life through the inspired musical direction of Donald Runnicles and – in the Siegmund of Peter Seiffert and the Sieglinde of Heidi Melton – two of the finest vocal performances in the entire cycle.

Even from the opening bars, it was apparent that we were in for an altogether higher level of performance than the evening before. The stormy prelude was delivered with such ferocity that, by the time Siegmund burst through the door and collapsed on the floor of Hunding’s dwelling – yet another ominous bunker in the time tunnel – it was hard not to feel his exhaustion. This promising introduction was only a small taste of the magnificent intensity that would continue to build as the act progressed.

The success of Walküre’s first act depends largely on the strength of its Siegmund and Sieglinde and, on this evening, the performances were about as strong as they come. Peter Seiffert can probably sing the role of Siegmund in his sleep and, when he is on top form, there are few singers who can match his level of absolute commitment. He doesn’t merely sing the right words and the right notes, but he sings whole lines with such conviction and urgency that you wouldn’t be wholly surprised if, on his way to the opera house that afternoon, he had actually slain an entire wedding party and lost his sword in the process. In the first act, especially, his exhaustion, his initial tenderness toward Sieglinde, his desperate invocation of his father and, most extraordinarily, his ecstasy at learning his own name all seemed to spring from a reality that even Wagner himself might not have imagined. He was, quite simply, magnificent to watch and to hear.

Wagner's Die Walküre. Donald Runnicles, conductor. Götz Friedrich, director. Berlin, Deutsche Oper, January, 2014

Equally magnificent was Heidi Melton’s Sieglinde. Although a reasonably young singer, Frau Melton’s voice in her earliest scenes had a mature weariness that immediately established the depths of Sieglinde’s suffering. Added to this was a wonderful, if chilling, moment where an affectionate advance from Siegmund was met with an instinctive recoil, which told you everything you needed to know about her marriage to Hunding (sung, on this evening, with understated malevolence by Reinhard Hagen). However, as Sieglinde’s confidence began to increase, so Frau Melton’s voice grew more radiant; her description of the wedding feast and the sword in the tree was one of the most captivating moments of the evening, and her eventual exclamation ‘Du bist der Lenz’ came close to matching Herr Seiffert in terms of pure ardour. Indeed, the final twenty minutes of the first act – which also featured some rapt playing from the orchestra – were an undisputed highlight, both of the evening and of the cycle as a whole.

With such dominant humans, the gods had their work cut out for them. Terje Stensvold approached Wotan not as proud chieftain among the gods, but as flawed, indecisive and harassed. He seemed to be perpetually straightening himself up, gathering his resolve, and trying to get a more commanding grip on his spear, as if being a god was somehow an act. This physical uncertainty was matched in his voice, which threatened to buckle beneath the weight of Fricka’s all-too-reasonable demands, but which gathered in gravitas as the inevitability of his situation became more certain. His scene of rage before the Valkyries and his tender farewell to Brünnhilde were both especially good. Meanwhile, Daniela Sindram proved as impressive in the role of Fricka as she had the evening before. Although her appearance was brief, she conveyed perfectly the resolve of a wife who had simply had enough of arguments and schemes.

Wagner's Die Walküre. Donald Runnicles, conductor. Götz Friedrich, director. Berlin, Deutsche Oper, January, 2014

Linda Watson’s Brünnhilde was slightly more problematic. Her voice, although strident enough for a Valkyrie, veered dangerously close to shrill at certain points, and her introductory ‘Hojotoho’s seemed oddly out of step with the orchestra. She fared far better in the third act, where she rendered Brünnhilde’s transformation from warrior maiden to vulnerable human wholly convincing. Indeed, the final scene between her and Wotan, although it could not match the ecstatic heights of the first act, was nonetheless excellent.

Many of the greatest scenes in the evening’s performance owed as much to Donald Runnicles and the orchestra as to the quality of the singing. If Herr Runnicles’ fiercely dramatic approach to Rheingold missed out on some of the subtleties of that opera, it proved an ideal strategy for Walküre’s march toward the inevitable. His reading captured both the frenzied joy of Siegmund and Sieglinde’s escape in the first act, and the sepulchral cloud of fate hanging over the meeting between Siegmund and Brünnhilde in the second act, without ever seeming forced or rushed. Instead, the music swelled and cascaded in perfect time with the unfolding narrative, both propelling and underscoring the drama.

Wagner's Die Walküre. Donald Runnicles, conductor. Götz Friedrich, director. Berlin, Deutsche Oper, January, 2014

As with each evening of the cycle, there was at least one aspect of the production which now seemed ridiculously dated and, on this evening, it was the Valkyries themselves. With their big hair, leather overcoats and black officer’s caps, they seemed more suited to an eighties fetish club than to the rocky summits near Valhalla. The evening did, however, end with Wotan summoning real fire which, of course, is what used to happen in the days before video projection; and, as the curtain went down on that fiery scene, it was reassuring to think that the bulk of the cycle still lay ahead of us. Yet, while there would be further memorable moments and great performances in the days to come – most notably a superb second act of Götterdämmerung – there would be few things to rival Siegmund and Sieglinde, in this evening’s first act, realising that escape from their tormented lives was as simple as running off together into the night.

Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.