Alemania

Heroics: a manual for beginners

Jesse Simon
Heroics: a manual for beginners
Berlin, viernes, 10 de enero de 2014.
Deutsche Oper Berlin. Richard Wagner: Siegfried (Der Ring des Nibelungen: Day 2). Götz Friedrich, director. Cast: Lance Ryan (Siegfried), Burkhard Ulrich (Mime), Mark Delavan (The Wanderer), Eric Owens (Alberich), Ante Jerkunica (Fafner), Ewa Wolak (Erda), Susan Bullock (Brünnhilde), Siobhan Stagg (Waldvogel). Deutsche Oper Choir and Orchestra. Donald Runnicles, conductor
0,0002338

Few people – if any – would argue that Siegfried is the high point of the Ring. Wagner himself didn’t quite seem to know what to do with the essential bridge between Die Walküre and Götterdämmerung, which may explain why Wotan shows up in disguise to narrate the plots of the first two operas, and why we are treated to nearly half an hour of Siegfried forging a sword in something close to real-time. If the two operas on either side gain dramatic charge from the inevitable tragedy of their flawed characters, Siegfried’s lack of drama is clearly born of heroic predestination. From the youthful hero’s first appearance, there is never any doubt that he will re-forge his father’s sword, slay the evil dragon, kill the scheming dwarf, climb the fiery mountain and awaken the beautiful sleeping maiden. There are few things less interesting than a fait-accompli.

A more significant problem with Siegfried is the fact that, with the exception of the wood-bird, it is nearly three hours before we hear a female voice, and closer to four before the dramatic soprano finally wakes up. And an opera without a soprano is like a football match without beer: it’s alright, but something is definitely missing. Just as a sequence of heroic deeds is no match for genuine drama, no amount of dragon slaying can match a good love duet. Thus, even if Siegfried has the best cast in the world – and there were certainly a few exceptional performances – the story of the hero’s formation is always destined to be eclipsed by the stories of his conception and his eventual downfall.

Having said that, the evening did have some fairly substantial marks in its favour, perhaps the most notable of which was Burkhard Ulrich’s inspired performance as Mime. Herr Ulrich – who, only two nights earlier, delivered an equally distinguished Loge – seemed not only to possess the ideal voice for the role, but was able to support it with a physical performance of great depth and commitment. His kinetic, slightly obsessive-compulsive Mime was never still for very long; and while he never let vocal exaggeration get in the way of the right notes, his lines were often delivered with the pleasing fluency of speech.

Mime and Siegfried lived together in a part of the time tunnel that was halfway between a blacksmith’s shop and an alternative-education day-care from the seventies. There was a construction paper rainbow, a big smiling sun, and some toys which Siegfried – if Lance Ryan’s angry-teenager performance was anything to go by – had only recently outgrown. Indeed, Herr Ryan offered a thoroughly credible performance as the unformed hero, his clear tenor a pleasing mix of cocky youth and unprepared farm-boy out in the world for the first time. He was excitable while re-forging his father’s sword, naïve and contemplative on his own in the forest, and suitably terrified during his initial encounter with the sleeping Brünnhilde.

Richard Wagner's Siegfried. Donald Runnicles, conductor. Götz Friedrich, director. Berlin, Deutsche Oper, January 2014

In the opera’s final half hour, Susan Bullock did an excellent job of navigating the doubt and despair that accompanied Brünnhilde’s acknowledgement of her newfound mortality. However, while one could hardly fault her vocal performance, there seemed to be a distinct lack of chemistry between her and Herr Ryan’s Siegfried. Brünnhilde’s constant reticence in the face of Siegfried’s ardour and her subtle but perceptible ‘get your hands off me’ demeanour may have merely been a feature of Götz Friedrich’s conception of the character, but it resulted in a final love duet that was never wholly convincing (and that certainly didn’t approach the heights of Siegmund and Sieglinde from the evening before). Perhaps Brünnhilde was concerned about the fact that, even though they weren’t brother and sister, she and Siegfried were definitely still related.

The supporting characters received generally solid performances, with Ewa Wolak captivating in her brief appearance as the mysterious, deep-voiced Erda, and Siobhan Stagg as a graceful wood-bird. Mark Delavan, Eric Owens and Ante Jerkunica all reprised their Rheingold roles of Wotan (here in the guise of the Wanderer), Alberich and Fafner, respectively. Herr Delavan’s Wanderer was somewhat variable, underwhelming in his initial appearance, but gathering in depth and authority during his lengthy Q&A with Mime; Herr Owens’ Alberich, however, was as delightfully bitter as he had been two evenings earlier. Herr Jerkunica possessed a suitably ominous dragon voice, but had the misfortune of having to sing while hiding behind a ridiculous and truly un-terrifying mechanical contraption with flashing lights and music-disrupting blasts of steam. As with the Valkyries from the evening before and Nibelheim the evening before that, this incarnation of Fafner may have appealed to the industrial spirit of 1984, but managed to earn little more than a nervous chuckle from the audience of 2014.

Richard Wagner's Siegfried. Donald Runnicles, conductor. Götz Friedrich, director. Berlin, Deutsche Oper, January 2014

Down in the pit, Donald Runnicles once again kept the drama moving at a pace that was neither rushed nor overly deliberate. He was able to conjure some wonderfully lush playing from the orchestra – most notably during the forest murmurs of the second act, and Brünnhilde’s awakening in the third – and dealt efficiently with the longueurs that can, in less capable hands, destroy the momentum of the opera. Indeed, the playing, the singing and (for the most part) the scenography combined to make for a Siegfried that was both accomplished and entertaining. Indeed, perhaps the only notable flaw of the evening was the simple existence of the two neighbouring operas; for even Siegfried’s greatest scenes of love and death cannot quite compare with the grand (albeit incestuous) passions of Die Walküre, and the spectacular end-of-all-things dénouement still to come.

Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.