Alemania
Forces of Nature
Anyone who has ever looked at the cast lists of old opera recordings and wondered why it no longer seems possible to see such a great concentration of talent on a single stage may find some consolation in the Semperoper’s new production of Elektra. With a cast featuring Evelyn Herlitzius, Waltraud Meier and Anne Schwanewilms, and musical direction from Christian Thielemann, it would be difficult to imagine a team of musicians more perfectly suited to what may be Strauss’ most dramatically charged work for the stage; and while one would have needed to travel to Dresden to see this group of singers in Barbara Frey’s new production, Berlin audiences were fortunate enough to have the orchestra, conductor and cast deliver a stunning konzertant performance at the Philharmonie.
At this point in her career, Evelyn Herlitzius is well on her way to becoming the finest Elektra of the twenty-first century. Her singing on this evening – largely unhindered by the demands of having to lose her mind on stage – only reinforced the impressions left by her extraordinary performance at Aix-en-Provence this past summer; not only is she an unnervingly physical Elektra, but she is also one of the most unerringly musical. The role itself is full of stark emotion and seismic mood-swings, and it can be all too easy for even the most disciplined soprano to let dramatic expression trump vocal clarity; in Frau Herlitzius’ performance, however, drama and music were integrated into a seamless whole. Her lustrous voice – powerful enough to carve an effortless path through the massed forces of the Sächsische Staatskapelle, yet nuanced enough to keep one hanging on every word – conveyed the full range of Elektra’s anger, madness and despair with thrilling intensity.
Even though Frau Herlitzius was dressed for the concert hall, everything else about her performance suggested the stage; she may not have had to collapse in anguish or break into a mad dance, but the lack of sets and props did not seem to have any effect on her total commitment to the character. Her exchanges with Chrysothemis were delivered with a vengeful thousand-yard stare and, in her extended scene with Klytämnestra, she could barely hold back her malicious disdain. Indeed, between her haunted physical presence and her extraordinary voice, Frau Herlitzius was not so much a dramatic soprano as a force of nature, utterly captivating to watch and completely magnificent to hear.
If there was no one else on the stage who could match Frau Herlitzius in vocal intensity, Waltraud Meier brought a similarly astonishing presence to the role of Klytämnestra. Although she could not have been on stage for any longer than twenty-five minutes, the dramatic immediacy of her words and actions – her pained expressions, her contemptuous glances at her daughter, and the terrified narration of her dreams – had the effect of rendering the character remarkably sympathetic … and of making it easy to forget that we were, in fact, watching a konzertant performance. Between Frau Meier and Frau Herlitzius – both of whom are scheduled to reprise these roles at La Scala later this year – it would be difficult to imagine a more vocally compelling or dramatically exciting confrontation between Elektra and her mother; even without the sets and costumes, seeing and hearing the two of them together was an experience that will not soon be forgotten.
Although Elektra and Klytämnestra were the dominant forces of the evening, the supporting roles also received highly accomplished performances. With a steely voice and crisp delivery, René Pape was an ideal Orest; his commanding tone – calm and measured but with a palpable edge of anger – suggested a son who was more than ready to avenge his father’s death. Meanwhile, Frank van Aken approached the opportunistic Aegisth with a clarity of tone that is rare for the role, but that still managed to convey the right amount of sleaze. Among the major characters, the only casting decision that did not seem wholly successful was Anne Schwanewilms as Chrysothemis. Frau Schwanewilms, of course, has a voice of tremendous beauty, and while her singing on this evening was almost impossible to fault on a technical level, there was something about her voice that seemed unsuited to the divided loyalties of Elektra’s anguished half-sister.
It was, however, an evening of memorable singing, and the luxury of the vocal performances was matched by some extraordinary playing from the Sächsische Staatskapelle. The orchestra have a long history with Elektra: not only did they première the work in 1909, but they were also, in 1961, responsible for what remains perhaps the finest studio recording. More than half a century later, their legacy with the work remains firmly intact. Elektra may not be especially long, but Strauss’ score is a tour-de-force of sustained drama, and a great performance requires one hundred minutes of total concentration. On this evening Christian Thielemann’s direction struck a perfect balance between stormy emotion and textural clarity, and the numerous dynamic transitions between passages of chamber-music intimacy and full-orchestra immensity were handled with a wonderfully unforced precision.
If Wagner’s great soprano roles are an endurance test, Strauss’ are closer to an obstacle course; and while the Feldmarschallin, the Countess and the Empress are all allowed a few moments of rest during the course of their respective operas, Elektra is forced to unravel before us in uninterrupted real-time. However, when the role is sung well, Elektra can – despite her terrible darkness and bloody obsessions – be one of the great joys of the operatic repertoire. On this evening, Evelyn Herlitzius’ vividly rendered performance reminded us just how terrifying and wonderful Elektra can be.
Comentarios