Alemania
Modern Passions
When the lights in the Philharmonie began to dim, the orchestra and choir filed onto the stage as if this were just another normal performance; the only thing slightly out of the ordinary was a large, very bright light hanging at chest height over the centre of the stage. But at the very moment Sir Simon Rattle raised his baton, the whole choir fell to the ground and remained on their backs while the orchestra played the introductory bars of ‘Herr, unser Herrscher’, the stirring chorus which opens Bach’s Johannes-Passion. From that moment, it was clear that we were back in the strange alluring world of secret ritual that had been established by director Peter Sellars and the Berlin Philharmonic in their previous collaborative foray into the sacred music of Bach.
The orchestra and Mr Sellars first worked together on a semi-staged production of the Matthäus-Passion in 2010, which was brought back last October as part of the fiftieth anniversary celebrations for the Philharmonie. Many of the musicians involved in that production - including the wonderful Rundfunkchor and a highly accomplished team of soloists - returned for a similarly involving take on Bach’s other great passion. However, where Matthäus is weighted more toward arias and melodic set-pieces, Johannes offers a dramatic focus that is more streamlined and, in many ways, far more intense.
Mr Sellars had arranged his vision of Matthäus around a series of boxes, but on this evening the stage remained largely bare. Instead the action unfolded around, and often beneath, the low hanging light; in the second part, especially, a blindfolded Jesus spent much of his time growing ever weaker beneath its unforgiving glare. But even with a minimum of props, Mr Sellars was able to summon an affecting - and often quite brutal - sense of the unfolding tragedy using only movements, gestures and expressions.
The high degree of narrative focus in the Johannes-Passion places a tremendous burden on the Evangelist; in this challenging role, however, Mark Padmore was close to perfect. His resilient tenor, exceptionally strong in the upper reaches of the register, possessed an ideal balance between assurance and sensitivity, and his recitatives - backed by some exceptional playing from the continuo - propelled the drama with agility and solemnity.
After the Evangelist, much of the Passion was driven by some extraordinary singing from the Rundfunkchor. The choir - who were also called upon to make dramatic movements with their arms and, occasionally, rush around the auditorium - delivered a fiery performance of the opening ‘Herr, unser Herrscher’ and maintained a level of similar intensity for the rest of the evening. Their pianissimo entry in the bass aria ‘Mein teurer Heiland’ was sublime, and the magnificent closing chorale ‘Ach Herr, lass dein lieb’ Engelein’ radiated an incandescent nobility.
While the choir and the Evangelist may have dominated the evening, there were really no weaknesses to be found among the soloists. The always-compelling Christian Gerhaher delivered a cold and imperious Pilatus - there was a wonderful scene of him lying on the floor in order to interrogate the collapsed Jesus face-to-face - but was able to make an effortless transition, for his arias, to a voice of tremendous warmth and compassion. Magdalena Kožená, although she appeared only briefly, was also excellent, perhaps nowhere more so than in the quiet, despairing section of ‘Es ist vollbracht’; and Camilla Tilling, whose appearance was also, sadly, limited to two arias, sang ‘Zerfließe, mein Herze’ with an arresting fragility. Finally, Topi Lehtipuu handled the tenor arias with finely measured phrasing, and Roderick Williams was a suitably profound Jesus.
The orchestra - reduced, on this evening, to a lean ensemble - were on fine form, and there was some excellent playing from the two oboes d’amore. Sir Simon Rattle’s approach to the score was ultimately effective, but it was certainly not designed to appeal to those in the audience who preferred their sacred Bach performed with a heavy dose of gravitas. From the very beginning, he kept the tempi brisk, a strategy which suited both the size of the orchestra and the forward momentum of the action; on the few occasions where he did slow things down - as in the wonderfully spacious opening of the Alto aria ‘Es ist vollbracht’ - the effect was deeply moving. However the performance very much remained a Johannes-Passion for the stage rather than the church, and if certain moments of profundity had to be sacrificed, it was usually to the benefit of the narrative pacing.
If Bach’s Passions were intended to be instructional as well as musical, the message is often relegated to a place of secondary importance when they are performed in the concert hall; and while the staging of Peter Sellars may have been too obliquely secular to convey the story of John’s gospel with any kind of exegetical precision, it succeed admirably in reclaiming some of the fundamental mysteries and emotions that make the story so powerful. The Berlin Philharmonic, the Rundfunkchor and the soloists may have ensured that the Johannes-Passion remained unerringly musical in its execution, but the curiously affecting dramatic vision of Mr Sellars was able to transform an ordinary concert into a modern-day approximation of the cathartic collective experience that Bach had originally intended.
Comentarios