Alemania

One Lesson, Four Songs, and a Sacrifice

Jesse Simon
One Lesson, Four Songs, and a Sacrifice
Berlin, martes, 18 de marzo de 2014.
Philharmonie. Dorothea Röschmann, soprano. Staatskapelle Berlin. Daniel Barenboim, conductor. Elliot Carter: Instances. Richard Strauss: Vier letzte Lieder. Igor Stravinsky: Le sacre du printemps
0,0001309

The fourth wall of the concert hall is as impermeable as that in any theatre; accordingly, there was a brief moment of disorientation when, instead of picking up his baton to lead the Staatskapelle, Daniel Barenboim picked up a microphone and turned to address the audience. Everything, he assured us, was fine: Dorothea Röschmann – scheduled to sing Strauss’ Vier letzte Lieder that evening – was not ill, and there had been no last minute changes to the programme. He simply wanted to say a few words about Elliott Carter’s Instances, on the occasion of its German première.

Mr Barenboim has been a devoted ambassador for Carter over the past several years, programming several of his later-period works into high-profile concerts, including Mr Barenboim’s own seventieth birthday concert, which featured Carter’s Dialogues II sandwiched between piano concertos by Beethoven and Tchaikovsky. On this evening, his works of outreach extended to a brief impromptu lecture – illustrated with musical examples performed by the Staatskapelle – designed to draw us into Carter’s unique and occasionally daunting sound world.

Instances, scored for a reasonably small ensemble, was Carter’s final work for orchestra. Although it lasts no longer than ten minutes, it presents a characteristically dense collection of sonic and harmonic events, juxtaposed in unexpected ways. While the piece would have stood comfortably on its own as an overture to the evening – it was given a performance that was precise, yet filled with a surprising warmth – the passion and enthusiasm of Mr Barenboim’s introduction allowed us to better glimpse some of the humour and humanism that lay beneath Carter’s rigorous formality.

For many in the audience, the main attraction of the evening was a chance to hear Dorothea Röschmann singing Vier letzte Lieder, those exquisite miniature masterpieces from the end of Strauss’ life. Last year at the Staatsoper, Ms Röschmann displayed a understated and affecting approach to Strauss with an exceptional performance as the Feldmarschallin; on this evening, however, her reading of the opening song ‘Frühling’ seemed a touch too emphatic, as if the swirling melody of Strauss had been torn loose from the words of Hesse by a tremendous gust of wind. Although there was nothing out of place musically, there were a few moments when the transition from introspection to strident emotion seemed a shade abrupt.

Her performance of ‘September’ however was an absolute delight. Here the passions suggested in the melody were delivered with magnificent restraint and a hint of resignation. ‘Beim Schlafengehen’ – which also featured a lyrical violin obbligato from the concert-master – was similarly moving, as was the concluding song ‘Im Abendrot’, which found Ms Röschmann summoning sublime melancholy from her delicate lower register. Throughout the four songs, Mr Barenboim and the Staatskapelle provided accompaniment of ideal transparency, frequently luminous but never overpowering; the quiet finale of the fourth song, in particular, was an impressive exercise in sustained tranquillity.

Stravinsky’s Le sacre du printemps – which formed the second half of the programme – turned 101 this year, although it has long since made the transition from succès de scandale to unimpeachable staple of the twentieth-century repertoire. But in the century since its shocking initial appearance, there has been a tendency to sand down some of the score’s rougher edges; Stravinsky himself famously criticised certain recordings for being too pretty. On this evening, however, Mr Barenboim and the Staatskapelle made few attempts to squeeze Stravinsky’s unkempt creation into a dinner jacket and tie.

If the first part was not the most visceral performance that has ever been heard, it was certainly among the most gnarly. Even from the beginning, the knotted tangle of overlapping woodwinds created a captivating mood of unease. The orchestra, which had swelled to occupy the whole of the stage, created a suitably large, suitably deep sound that conveyed the impression of a chaos just barely controlled. It was not an especially brisk Sacre, but it was rarely lacking in suspense.

While the first part flirted with chaos, the second proceeded with an unstoppable rhythmic force that, at various times, seemed positively hypnotic. Mr Barenboim has, in the past year, conducted the piece as part of a ballet performance, but on this evening, free from the demands of choreographic action, he seemed more determined than ever to plunge into the ritual mysticism of Stravinsky’s pagan vision. If the second part was able to maintain a constant excitement, it came not from the surprise twists in the score, but rather from a sense that the piece was building toward some terrible, inevitable conclusion.

Le sacre du printemps was first performed in 1913, and was one of the pieces that announced the decisive end of late nineteenth-century romanticism; even though Carter’s Instances received its première in 2013, one can hear the culmination of a twentieth-century tradition in its musical language. Between those two poles, Vier letzte Lieder appeared roughly in the middle, although it too looked backward toward an unrecoverable time. The evening’s three pieces – the ballet, the song cycle, and the chamber work – may have been considerably different in their structure, their intent and their demand on resources, but when performed together they made for an emotionally engaging and musically satisfying snapshot of a century that is, for better or worse, now behind us.

Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.