Alemania
Charlottenburg to Genoa
A well-cast evening of Wagner will always fill the house – as witness the Staatsoper’s recent Tannhäuser – but it takes a living legend to bring that house to its feet. So when Plácido Domingo appeared from behind the curtain after a dramatically satisfying and frequently triumphant performance of Verdi’s Simon Boccanegra, it was only a matter of seconds before the audience was standing; and, while Mr Domingo had undoubtedly been the star of the evening, an arresting performance from tenor Fabio Sartori and a probing, pensive account of the score from Daniel Barenboim and the Staatskapelle made for an evening that sat comfortably among the other great evenings at this year’s Festtage.
Much has been made of Plácido Domingo’s late-career switch from tenor to baritone, with many critics hastening to point out that he is not as accomplished in the lower register. This may be true: but when one has spent the better part of four decades being one of the most extraordinary – and most versatile – tenors of the twentieth century, expecting him to be equally good in a different vocal range is simply unrealistic. The fact remains that he is still tremendously good … and in Simon Boccanegra, he has found a role ideally suited to his strengths.
The character of Boccanegra, Genoa’s first doge, possesses a hard-won benevolence born from a life of constant embattlement; during the course of the opera, he searches only for peace – for his daughter, for his city and for himself – but fails to find it. On this evening, Mr Domingo was able to transform the futility of Boccanegra’s search into a tragic nobility at the core of the drama. Vocally he lacked nothing in warmth and strength – his first-act duet with Amelia was especially wonderful – and, in the prologue especially, he was able to summon an emphatic passion that recalled his days as a heldentenor. But there was also a weariness at the edges that gave nuance and pathos to the doomed doge.
It should also be noted that – vocal considerations aside – Mr Domingo still possesses a commanding presence and an actor’s willingness to invest himself fully in the role. As Verdi’s mid-period operas grow less reliant on huge tunes and begin their transformation from melodrama to drama, acting becomes increasingly important to a successful performance and, on this evening, Mr Domingo captured perfectly the physical deterioration of the doge as the slow-acting poison began to take effect.
While Boccanegra very much remained the focus of the action, his tragedy unfolded alongside a generally excellent cast. Dmitry Belosselskiy, in particular, brought a voice of great depth to Fiesco, whose cold determination in the prologue offered a stark contrast to Boccanegra’s peaceful pleas. As Amelia, Maria Agresta’s fully-rounded soprano had enough power to thrive in the dramatic scenes, but enough delicate restraint to give her scenes with the doge an affecting tenderness. Meanwhile, the Paolo of Àngel Òdena was convincingly malicious and, in the council chamber scene, suitably fearful.
Perhaps the most impressive vocal performance, however, belonged to Fabio Sartori, whose compellingly full tenor was a constant model of lyrical ardour. His aria in the second act was a genuine show-stopper, and in his first-act duet with Amelia – and, even more so, in the gripping, finely-balanced trio at the end of Act II – he was able to generate a palpable excitement. In a season that has witnessed no shortage of Verdi operas, few other tenor performances have been as memorably grand as the Adorno of Mr Sartori.
The orchestra – despite what must have been an exhausting Festtage schedule – sounded as fresh and focused as ever, with an exceptionally rich low-end sound that underscored the gravitas of the narrative. Daniel Barenboim’s thoughtful reading, which tended to favour slower tempi and a monumentally scaled sense of drama, produced countless moments of breathtaking intensity. Although his approach didn’t always produce ideal results – the rhythmic pulse of Amelia’s first-act aria seemed a touch heavy-handed – there was no shortage of passages, including a thrillingly tense council chamber scene and a sepulchral finale, where Mr Barenboim was able to reveal the full dramatic potential of Verdi’s great score.
The music-making of the orchestra and singers played out against a production that possessed an effortless understanding of the narrative’s convoluted machinations and that, moreover, appeared to take place in something resembling fourteenth century Genoa. Five years after its première at the Staatsoper, Federico Tiezzi’s staging remains a source of considerable delight, dramatically coherent and visually memorable but never obtrusive.
Even though the ending of Simon Boccanegra is one of the great downers in Verdi’s oeuvre – the composer seems to have been unwilling to summon the orchestral fireworks that so often bring his operas to a close – the combination of a finely wrought production, excellent singing and superb orchestral playing was able to send the audience home fully satisfied. Indeed, between the Mozart Symphonies, the excellent new Tannhäuser and a now a distinguished Simon Boccanegra, the Staatsoper’s 2014 Festtage had been every bit as wonderful as one might have hoped. With performances such as these, why would anyone want to spend their Easter break anywhere else?
Comentarios