Alemania

Venusberg to Wartburg

Jesse Simon
Venusberg to Wartburg
Berlin, jueves, 4 de diciembre de 2014.
Schiller Theater. Wagner: Tannhäuser. Sasha Waltz, Director. Cast: René Pape (Landgraf Hermann), Peter Seiffert (Tannhäuser), Peter Mattei (Wolfram von Eschenbach), Peter Sonn (Walther von der Vogelweide), Tobias Schabel (Biterolf), Jürgen Sacher (Heinrich der Schreiber), Jan Martiník (Reinmar von Zweter), Ann Petersen (Elisabeth), Marina Prudenskaya (Venus), Sónia Grané (A Shepherd). Staatsoper Berlin Choir and Orchestra. Daniel Barenboim, Conductor
0,0003286

Wagner may still have his detractors, but his gloriously outsized works of musical drama are still one of the most reliable ways to fill an opera house. Thus, as the centrepiece of this year’s Festtage, the Staatsoper have assembled a high-profile new Tannhäuser, featuring musical direction from Daniel Barenboim, choreography and staging from the occasionally controversial Sasha Waltz, and a cast of singers that would be difficult to surpass; and while Ms Waltz’s archly minimal, dance-heavy production appeared to anger some, the première performance had all the markings of a future classic.

When Ms Waltz appeared on stage during the curtain calls, a few hearty boos from the back of the house could be heard through the applause. Such a harsh reaction seemed not only mean-spirited, but also wholly misguided: while, admittedly, not without its faults – most notably, its over-reliance on the continuous movement of the dancers – Ms Waltz’s staging was dramatically satisfying, visually engaging and, most importantly, subservient to the singers and the music. Its minimalism may have been born of a desire to keep the stage empty for dancing, but the subtle lighting, costume colours and groupings of singers on the stage resulted in no shortage of effective scenes and tableaux that would not have looked out of place on the cover of a sixties LP box.

Prudenskaya, Seiffert y bailarines en 'Tannhäuser' de Wagner. Dirección escénica, Sasha Waltz. Dirección musical, Daniel Barenboim. Berlín, Staatsoper im Schiller Theater, abril de 2014

Apart from the opening scene in the Venusberg – set in a perspective-defying set that looked like a rotunda tipped on its side and functioned (perhaps accidentally) as a parabolic sound reflector – much of the action unfolded in a series of empty spaces given character and texture primarily through lighting and fog. When Tannhäuser awoke in the forest of Thuringia, the bright whites and undulating flesh tones of Venus’ grotto had been replaced with an all-consuming grey; the hopelessness of the third act played out against little more than a copper-coloured floor and fog-enshrouded darkness. Only the second act, with its grand hall made from closely spaced hanging poles, suggested anything as definite as a location.

The indistinct setting was further enhanced by costumes which only barely alluded to a fixed temporal reality. Tannhäuser’s fellow knights went hunting in grey suits of early twentieth-century appearance, while the female guests at the song contest arrived in gorgeous pale blue-green gowns borrowed whole-cloth from one of Douglas Sirk’s Technicolor melodramas. Ultimately, this was a Tannhäuser that took place neither in the thirteenth century nor the modern age, but rather in the compellingly artificial world of the stage, a world where narrative and emotion are created through colour, sound and movement.

Momento de la representación de Tannhäuser de Wagner. Dirección escénica, Sasha Waltz. Dirección musical, Daniel Barenboim. Berlín, Staatsoper im Schiller Theater, abril de 2014

It was the heightened sense of movement, however, that didn’t always serve the production. While the writhing, semi-naked bodies created an effectively hedonistic Venusberg – the orchestra opened with the Overture and Bacchanale from the Paris version to allow for extra writhing time – the group of grey suited dancers twirling around the knights at the end of the first act were both distracting and unnecessary. The dancers were more effective in the second act, where their increasingly carnal movements provided a visual counterpoint to Tannhäuser’s interjections about the less-than-courtly aspects of love; too often, however, the dancing had an uneasy, unintegrated relationship with the action as though Ms Waltz, not quite trusting the engagement of the music and drama alone, had decided to return to more familiar terrain.

However if there were moments when the dancing seemed intrusive, there were many passages in which there was nothing to distract from the tremendous singing occurring on the stage. The cast was, simply, one of the strongest assembled for a production of Tannhäuser in recent years; there were few weaknesses to be found among the supporting cast of knights, and the quintet of lead roles received performances that ranged from merely excellent to utterly magnificent.

Peter Seiffert’s Tannhäuser seems to have grown both more fervent and nuanced in the decade since his Grammy-winning recording. The clarity of his delivery and the elegance of his phrasing seem to exist at an ideal midpoint between vocal acting and singing, and his full-bodied Heldentenor can command an entire auditorium with little effort. His songs to Venus, on this evening, soared with nostalgic ecstasy, his sudden exclamations of joy (Act 1) and woe (Act 2) were arresting, and the narration of his pilgrimage in the third act contained terrifying levels of anger and despair; and despite spending nearly all of the opera’s three-and-a-half hours on the stage, his voice at the end remained full of passion and untroubled by fatigue. If Mr Seiffert is remembered as the great Tannhäuser of his age, it will be on the strength of evenings such as this.

Momento de la representación de 'Tannhäuser' de Wagner. Dirección escénica, Sasha Waltz. Dirección musical, Daniel Barenboim. Berlín, Staatsoper im Schiller Theater, abril de 2014


Yet Mr Seiffert was only one of the singers to deliver an exceptional performance: Peter Mattei’s Wolfram von Eschenbach – a continual marvel of restrained piety and sympathetic lyricism – was hardly less impressive. There was a refreshing lack of pomposity in the high poetry of his second-act song and a genuine excitement in his first-act discovery of Tannhäuser; but it was not until the third act that he was really able to distinguish himself. Here, at last, was a Wolfram whose solicitude toward Elisabeth seemed to spring not from opportunistic passion, but from a vast well of noble intention. His attempts to console Elisabeth and his subsequent song to the evening star were arguably the most quietly devastating parts of the entire evening.

To the role of Elisabeth, Ann Petersen brought a voice that was strident, forthright and generally less demure than the character might demand. Although she seemed entirely too strong a figure to die of grief, she was precisely the kind of Elisabeth who, near the end of the second act, could quiet a group of bloodthirsty knights with a single commanding word; and if her voice lacked some of the meek reserve that one often associates with the character, Ms Petersen was nonetheless responsible for numerous wonderful moments, perhaps most notably her glorious duet with Mr Seiffert at the beginning of the second act.

Marina Prudenskaya, at the other end of Wagner’s romantic spectrum, was an absolutely superb Venus. She brought a powerful humanity to the goddess, moving effortlessly between rage and conciliation as she struggled to keep Tannhäuser from leaving; even at her most impassioned, her voice retained an appealing fullness and clarity. Finally, as Landgraf Hermann, the effortlessly engaging René Pape brought a reassuring sense of authority, strength and serenity to the increasing disorder of the second act.

The evening’s greatest performance, however, was arguably going on beneath the stage. Under the guidance of Daniel Barenboim, the Staatskapelle delivered a reading of Wagner’s score that, without drawing undue attention to itself, never failed to hit its emotional mark. Mr Barenboim’s interpretation – even more so than his Ring cycle from last year’s Festtage – was a master-class in good judgement, long phrasing and heightened dramatic tension; and the orchestra remained thrillingly attuned to the cascades and climaxes of the score from beginning to end. It was a performance that, with its near-perfect mixture of subtlety and immediacy, would sit comfortably next to any of the great recordings.

Despite some minor misgivings about the preponderance of dance, the quality of the singing and playing were such that it would really be difficult to imagine a more compelling, more fully-realised Tannhäuser. The minimalism of the setting worked to the advantage of the singers, whose great artistry was allowed to flourish in a world largely free of theatrical contrivance; and when combined with the peerless musicianship of Mr Barenboim and the Staatskapelle, the result was an evening that will surely be remembered in reverential terms by anyone who happened to be there.
Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.