Alemania
The Calm and the Storm
Maurizio Pollini has recorded the first Brahms piano concerto no fewer than three times for the Deutsche Grammophon label – with Karl Böhm, Claudio Abbado and, most recently, Christian Thielemann – and has long since secured himself a place in the pantheon of the work’s greatest interpreters. However one should not forget that, back in the sixties, Daniel Barenboim was also responsible for an excellent recording under the direction of Sir John Barbirolli, and is still performing the work as a soloist today. While both musicians – born in the same year – are now recognised as giants of the romantic repertoire, they approach their Brahms from very different directions. But on this evening, the two would come together for an unforgettable reading of a nineteenth century masterpiece.
The D minor concerto, which formed the first half of the evening’s programme, began with a magnificent storm of low strings and timpani, followed swiftly by the wild anguish of the opening theme. The sound coming from the stage – aided subtly by the unique acoustic of the Konzerthaus, which tends to flatter much of the romantic repertoire – was gloriously rich, and the strings especially retained a great clarity even when fully immersed in the vastness of Brahms’ tempestuous introduction.
Against these titanic swells of sound, Mr Pollini’s playing was muscular, confident and largely undaunted by the storm into which he had willingly entered. His approach – which seemed closer to the wise guide than the romantic wanderer – articulated the fine detailing in Brahms’ score with a technical assurance that was dazzling but never ostentatious; and while there was little sentimentality in his reading, it was not without vast reserves of feeling. However this feeling rarely took the form of easy solutions or uncontrolled outpourings of emotion; rather it appeared as a deep knowledge, born of struggle but emerging at last as a heightened sense of awareness.
After the thunderous conclusion of the first movement, the opening of the second had an exquisite, almost surprising calmness to it. Without relinquishing any of the outward romanticism that had made the first movement so stirring, Mr. Barenboim coaxed playing of great refinement from the orchestra; a small exchange between the piano and some breathtakingly pianissimo strings offered one of the most sublime moments in a performance that was never lacking in greatness. However the second movement was also where the disparity between conductor and soloist seemed most pronounced. Even as the orchestra began to surge, Mr Pollini maintained a level-headed concentration and a steadiness of pulse that seemed to push against the edges of the orchestra’s spacious adagio.
The Rondo movement – the opening of which came as a sudden jolt from the serenity at the end of the previous movement – proceeded with a vigorous momentum that grew more triumphant as it grew nearer to its conclusion. If the first movement had favoured the emotion of the orchestra and the second had been guided by the directness of the soloist, then the third was a perfect marriage of the two. Mr Pollini and Mr Barenboim may have come to the piece from two very different places, but the success of their performance lay not in the subjugation of one approach to the other, but in their ability to make the two approaches seem perfectly complementary. While there are, ultimately, many right ways to play the D minor concerto, there are few who would wish to argue that this evening’s performance had been anything less than astonishing.
In the canon of Strauss’ tone poems, there is always a sense that Don Quixote – which made up the second half of the evening’s programme – is somewhat undervalued. Audiences may love the familiar grandness of Zarathustra or the genial excitement of Till Eulenspiegel and, in Berlin at least, one must make some considerable effort if one wishes to avoid hearing Heldenleben; Don Quixote, despite its wonderful score, does not appear to be held in the same regard. Admittedly, it is not the easiest work to perform: in addition to its fearsome solo-cello part, about which students of that instrument are said to have nightmares, it also requires a violist of the highest calibre; and, in the hands of an unconfident orchestra, Strauss’ lexicon of unconventional techniques can be a recipe for disaster. When played well, however, it is easily the equal of Strauss’ best orchestral work.
Even for an orchestra as distinguished as the Staatskapelle – who have, in the past years, delivered some mighty Strauss performances from the pit of the Schiller Theater – the piece is not without its challenges; and while the orchestra did not always exhibit quite the same degree of meticulous preparation as they had during the Brahms concerto, they were nonetheless able to deliver a performance of good humour and knightly grandeur, with several moments of inspired lyricism.
Claudius Popp, who had the unenviable task of playing the solo-cello passages, had a strong attack and an impulsive phrasing that suited the delusions of the errant knight. However he also possessed considerable restraint, approaching the part less from the perspective of a star virtuoso and more as a member of the orchestra who had been called upon to play an extended obbligato. He was well matched by Felix Schwartz, whose agile, animated viola acted as the Sancho Panza to Mr. Popp’s Quixote. Their dialogues throughout (but especially in Variation III) were a source of great delight.
Surrounding these two soloists – three, if one counts the concertmaster, who had a number of lyrical solo passages of his own – the orchestra did an excellent job of conjuring the fabulous adventures encountered by knight and squire. The muted horns in the episode with the flock of sheep conveyed a wonderfully sinister strangeness, the ride through the air was suitably turbulent and, in the final variations, there was some glorious playing that recalled the storm clouds of the earlier Brahms concerto. Although the episodes themselves were often brilliant, one was occasionally left with a sense that the individual parts had not been made to fit together quite as seamlessly as one might like. Yet when the piece reached its conclusion, one could not deny that it had been a stirring journey and, in sum, a truly wonderful evening.
Comentarios