Alemania

Milestones and Memorials

Jesse Simon
Milestones and Memorials
Berlin, miércoles, 18 de junio de 2014.
Philharmonie. Daniel Barenboim, Piano. Berlin Philharmonic. Sir Simon Rattle, Conductor. Ives: The Unanswered Question. Strauss: Metamorphosen. Brahms: Piano Concerto No. 1 in D minor
0,0002104

For their final regular concert of the 2013/14 season, the Berlin Philharmonic paid tribute to two very different musicians. Richard Strauss, born 150 years ago this June, was honoured with a lucid performance of his late-career masterpiece Metamorphosen, while Daniel Barenboim – who made his debut with the Philharmonic in June of 1964 – celebrated his fifty-year association with the orchestra by appearing as soloist in Brahms’ D minor piano concerto. The concert, which also featured Ives’ The Unanswered Question, offered a pleasing balance between chamber-music clarity in the first half and full-orchestra romanticism in the second.

The first half, in particular, succeeded not merely through the quality of its performances, but also through the fluid ingenuity of its stage-management. As the lights dimmed, a small group of string players took the stage and arranged themselves into a semi-circle; they were followed by Sir Simon Rattle who, rather than assuming the customary pose, turned to face the audience. When he raised his hand, the musicians remained still but a quiet cluster of strings began to fill the hall.

The sound – the opening of Ives’ The Unanswered Question – was coming from another string group hidden on one of the uppermost terraces in the Philharmonie. Meanwhile, other musicians – a solo trumpet and several flutes – had been situated around the auditorium. From behind the stage the trumpet began to play the question figure, and the flutes offered their increasingly frenzied rejoinders from the sidelines. Regardless of how one may feel about Ives’ programmatic mysticism, the performance possessed no shortage of beauty and mystery.

When at last the question went unanswered and the musicians offstage fell silent, Sir Simon turned to face the group of strings behind him and, without a pause, drew forth the opening bars of Metamorphosen. It was an effectively solemn way of introducing what may be the most harrowing work Strauss would ever compose.

In 1942, when Strauss had completed Capriccio, the Nationaltheater in Munich was still standing; even the opera house on Unter den Linden in Berlin – where Strauss had enjoyed success as a conductor decades earlier – had been quickly restored after being struck by an errant bomb the year before. Three years later, most of Germany’s concert halls and opera houses had been reduced to ruins. For Strauss, who would not live to see the restoration of any of these buildings, the destruction of his country’s musical tradition must have seemed a far greater tragedy than any of the ancient stories he had set to music during his career. In Metamorphosen, scored for 23 solo strings, he was able to translate the weight of that grief into almost thirty of the century’s most elegiac minutes.

Although Metamorphosen – which, oddly enough, had not been programmed by the orchestra in more than two decades – may not be cheerful, it can be highly cathartic; and on this evening, the group of strings on stage made a convincing journey from vague disillusion to outright anguish. The ensemble distinguished itself both through individual virtuosity, which made audible the full complexity of Strauss’ score, but also through an unerring sense of collective balance.

Sir Simon’s vision of the piece was not wholly conventional, but it worked nonetheless. There were a few notable fluctuations in tempo – especially in the lead up to the work’s great climactic pause, here slowed down about as far as it would go – that seemed engineered to force more emotion than the score itself was willing to give. However apart from a few minor reservations, the piece was given a reading of great clarity and nuance. The final few bars were particularly moving.

If the first half of the programme offered a demonstration of what the orchestra could do as a series of smaller ensembles, the second provided a showcase for their strengths in a more conventional romantic setting. The evening’s soloist, Daniel Barenboim, has been appearing with the Berlin Philharmonic for fifty years, and has been performing the first Brahms piano concerto for roughly the same length of time. Only a month earlier he had directed a memorable performance by the Staatskapelle Berlin with Maurizio Pollini at the piano; with Mr Barenboim as soloist and Sir Simon on the podium, the concerto would be a very different, although equally rewarding proposition.

The orchestral introduction, much like parts of Metamorphosen, featured variations in tempo that seemed odd, although not perhaps without their own logic. The opening was taken very slowly, although the pace was quickened considerably in the bars leading up to the initial entry of the piano; the movement, however, did not lack in excitement, especially in the second half where there were some moments of wonderfully wrought magnificence.

Mr Barenboim’s playing in the first movement was full of energy and emotion, with little evidence of reserve. The quieter moments were delivered with an outgoing majesty, while the more frantic sections – of which there are several in the course of the movement – possessed a stormy expressionism that could barely be contained within the frame of the instrument; his attack of the ascending figure that brings the movement to its conclusion was especially thrilling. However in the second movement – an adagio that landed firmly in the livelier end of the spectrum – his playing was as thoughtful as it had been dramatic only moments earlier. Still there was nothing about his performance that could be described as introverted; the lengthy series of trills at the end of the movement shimmered with a grand romantic sensibility.

The third movement, however, was arguably the finest of the three. Mr Barenboim, shedding the drama of the earlier movements, played with a light touch, while the orchestra seemed at its most refined and assured. The piece ended in triumph – far from the storms of the opening – and neither the conductor nor the soloist had to leave the stage before a handful of people had already risen to their feet. The applause continued – interrupted by a few brief but appreciative words from Sir Simon and an encore from Mr Barenboim – even after the musicians had left the stage; the adulation of the audience was directed not merely at this one performance, but also at a lifetime of performances and a musical partnership that looks set to continue when the new concert season begins in only a few months.

Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.