Alemania
Musikfest Berlin Part 1: A Lesson in Chemistry
Berlin’s annual Musikfest – three weeks of orchestral concerts, chamber music and solo recitals, imaginatively curated by the Berliner Festspiele – is currently in its tenth year, and it is only showing signs of getting better with age. This year’s festival, loosely but intriguingly organised around the theme of the horn, will feature appearances from some of the world’s leading orchestras and soloists, alongside the six Berlin orchestras who form the stable core of the event. In addition to central works of later romanticism from Schumann, Brahms and Bruckner, and a handful of concerts paying tribute to the 150th birthday of Strauss, the festival will also offer a chance to hear works by living composers such as Jörg Widmann, Wolfgang Rihm and Georg Friedrich Haas. As in previous years, Musikfest has made September an exciting time to be in Berlin.
This year’s edition of the festival got underway in a truly grand style, with a programme featuring the two Piano Concertos of Brahms performed by the Staatskapelle Berlin. Daniel Barenboim, whom one might expect to find on the podium, took on the role of soloist, ceding the baton to the able hands of Gustavo Dudamel. The result was a First concerto of tremendous depth, discipline and inner strength, followed by an even more astonishing Second concerto that could change the opinion of anyone who might accuse that work of being the less vital of the two.
When it comes to the piano concertos of Brahms, the idea of ‘accompaniment’ is somewhat misleading. Unlike the piano-led models of Mozart and Beethoven (or, the soloist-aggrandising style of Liszt), Brahms entrusts his orchestra with considerable responsibilities and, indeed, it is the opposition of piano and orchestra as roughly equal forces which generates some of the spark that makes these works so continually rewarding.
On this evening, however, Mr Dudamel and Mr Barenboim achieved greatness through the remarkable feat of remaining on the same interpretive page throughout the course of each piece. The nearly complete lack of tension between piano and orchestra – the piano never wanted to race ahead of the orchestra or hold it back – allowed the pieces to unfold in a way that was consistently impressive and not infrequently sublime.
Under the direction of Mr Dudamel, the Staatskapelle sounded especially magnificent. The strings, in particular, achieved a rounded smoothness that was matched only by an unerring precision: one could hear each 16th note clearly, but the overall effect never sounded deliberate or pedantic. Indeed, there were few things about Mr Dudamel’s reading that seemed especially mannered. Rather, he appeared to have tapped into the secret of concealing his artistry and generating a performance which had so few visible joins that it became impossible to isolate the patient craftsmanship hidden beneath the immaculate surface. If his direction of the First concerto was so satisfying, it was precisely because conductor and orchestra drew so little attention to themselves, labouring in the background while the spotlight fell squarely on Brahms’ score.
Faced with such a high level of orchestral refinement, Daniel Barenboim delivered a performance of great composure. This is not to suggest he was in any way lacking in dramatic expression, but rather that his grand pianistic gestures were delivered with a redoubtable assurance. When he performed the same concerto last season with the Berlin Philharmonic under Sir Simon Rattle, there was a much greater sense of unhinged romantic fervour; on this evening it had been replaced with a more measured quality that placed it in near perfect alignment with Mr Dudamel and the orchestra.
The obvious synergy between pianist and conductor resulted in a gripping first movement that achieved its turbulence and grand drama with little apparent effort. It was followed by a marvellously paced Adagio – graceful without ever threatening to lose its momentum – that contained some of the evening’s finest playing; the strings in the quieter sections conveyed a hushed reverence, and Mr Barenboim’s piano was suffused with nobility. By the end of the third movement – which featured an electrifying reading of the small fugue section in the middle – there could be few people in the audience who would argue that Messrs Dudamel and Barenboim, and the Staatskapelle, had delivered a Brahms performance of the highest order. It turned out, however, that they were just getting started.

Barenboim (piano), Staatskapelle Berlin and Dudamel at Philharmonie. Berlin Musikfest 2014 (September, 2nd)
© Matthias Creutziger / UNITEL, 2014
The Second piano concerto – written two decades after the First and only a few years after Brahms had finally broken the symphony barrier – is undoubtedly a more mature work than the First; but while it is not without its moments of eloquence and invention, the stormy quality that drives and illuminates its predecessor has been largely excised in favour of a more studied version of itself. Formally speaking, the second may be the better work, but that does not necessarily make it the more interesting.
On this evening, however, those observations did not necessarily hold. While the two concertos were presented as works of very different character, the Second was given such a generous reading that one could not help but be delighted by its qualities. It began – befitting the theme of this year’s festival – with an elegant dialogue between piano and solo horn, which culminated in the entry of the full orchestra. Mr Dudamel and the Staatskapelle imparted an unmistakable warmth to the heroic principal theme, and Mr Barenboim continued to play with great poise and distinction.
In terms of performance, the strengths of the Second concerto were not dissimilar to those of the First: a great transparency of sound, wonderfully rich strings, and an astonishing rapport between soloist and orchestra. Where this concerto bettered the evening’s opening half was in its sheer effervescence and good humour. The second movement especially, with its echoes of the Hungarian dances that so fascinated Brahms, was propelled by a lightness of pace and some supremely delicate playing.
However it was the third movement that provided the evening with its most sustained display of musical brilliance. Opening with a gloriously-played passage for solo cello, the Andante unfolded slowly and gently, swelling in all the right places, but impressing most with the tranquility of its quietest moments. Until the very end of the movement, when Mr Barenboim launched into a brief unaccompanied passage full of difficult trills, the piano and orchestra had been so fully integrated as to seem inseparable.
The finale, too, was beautifully rendered, and its transitions between buoyant rhythms and lyrical ardour were accomplished with remarkable ease. When it was all over, the applause was so great that, after returning to the stage five times, Mr Barenboim performed one of Chopin’s Nocturnes (No. 5) as an encore. However even Mr Barenboim would probably admit that the greatness of the evening had come not solely from the pianist, nor the conductor, nor even the orchestra, but rather from the remarkable chemistry that had developed between the three.
Comentarios