Alemania

Musikfest Berlin Part 2: A World of Fugue

Jesse Simon
Musikfest Berlin Part 2: A World of Fugue
Berlin, jueves, 4 de septiembre de 2014.
Kammermusiksaal. Bach: The Well-Tempered Clavier Book I, BWV 846–869. Pierre-Laurent Aimard, piano. Musikfest Berlin 2014
0,0002134

Pierre-Laurent Aimard has been responsible for a handful of the more extraordinary solo-piano recordings of the past two decades, although the pieces with which he has enjoyed his greatest success – Messiaen’s Vingt Régards, Ligeti’s Études – have been firmly situated at the contemporary end of the repertoire. In recent years, however, Mr. Aimard has turned his attention to the contrapuntal works of Bach; after a thoughtful, often absorbing Art of Fugue a few years back, he has taken the next logical step and tackled the first volume of the Well-Tempered Clavier.

In addition to a new recording for Deutsche Grammophon, he has taken the first 24 of the ‘48’ on the road for a series of recitals, including a stop at the Kammermusiksaal as part of Berlin’s Musikfest; and while Mr Aimard’s vision of Bach’s masterpiece was no more definitive than those of the great pianists who have come before, hearing him perform the preludes and especially the fugues was a delightful, thought-provoking and often mesmerising experience that will not soon be forgotten.

If the Well-Tempered Clavier has exerted a fascination over musicians for close to three centuries it is not merely because of Bach’s unparalleled craftsmanship, but also because of all the variables so tantalisingly absent from his manuscript. There is, first of all, the question of instrument: should one perform the works on a clavichord? a fortepiano? or a modern instrument? (On this evening, Mr Aimard used a Steinway). Then there are the myriad questions of dynamic, tempo and technique. Many musicians have approached this compendious work, but few (if any) have arrived at the same conclusions.

It became apparent very quickly that Mr Aimard had given considerable thought not just to each prelude and fugue, but to their position within the collection as a whole. He had discovered in the pieces an inner logic to govern his performance and he wasted no time delineating its boundaries. Between the moment he sat down at the piano and the appearance of the first familiar notes of the C major prelude there was an almost exaggeratedly long pause which served as a decisive break between the universe of Bach and the ordinary world we’d just left behind.

When the music did begin it was slow and deliberate, articulating the notes and their relationships with a resolve and determination that was compelling if also, at certain moments, wilfully un-lyrical. Slowness, however, would not be a defining element of Mr Aimard’s interpretation. Although he would employ introspective pacing to brilliant effect later in the evening – notably in the B flat minor prelude and the B minor fugue – his tempi remained generally moderate throughout, rarely racing and never dragging, working always in the service of the notes that needed to be heard.

From a technical point of view Mr Aimard’s playing was beyond reproach. His use of pedal was subtle and judicious, adding texture to the overall sound without compromising the clarity of the individual parts; his application of dynamic was similarly refined, serving mostly to bring a particular line into focus. While some interpreters have adopted a more legato style or relied more heavily on the dynamic range of the piano, the precision and restraint of Mr Aimard’s playing gave some of the more complex passages the lucidity of a harpsichord. There was, moreover, a great balance of voices in Mr Aimard’s style; his willingness to give prominence to the bass resulted in a series of readings that examined both the surface of the piece and the architecture which lay immediately behind it.

While this approach was frequently illuminating, it could occasionally result in preludes that sounded mannered. His desire to emphasise structure sometimes imparted a certain heaviness to those preludes with the liveliest rhythms, for instance the C minor or D major. Furthermore, if there was a chance to eschew the lyrical approach in favour of probing abstraction – for example, in the C sharp minor and E flat minor preludes – he would often take it. However he could just as easily highlight the exuberance and good humour that lay beneath a rigorous facade, as he did with the F sharp major; and whatever his preludes may have occasionally wanted in absolute fluidity, they always made up for in insight.

But then there were the fugues. In the course of the evening there was not a single fugue that failed to impress. Mr Aimard himself seemed endlessly fascinated by the complexities and structural depths of these perfectly formed works, and his enthusiasm was both apparent and infectious. If the preludes could occasionally sound studied, the fugues, with their introspection, their ferocity, their excitement and their satisfying logic revealed themselves to be the true emotional core of Mr Aimard’s interpretation. There was a whole world of musical possibilities contained within the fugues alone.

Each fugue was executed with flawless technical skill and no small amount of inspiration. The D major was performed as though it were a direct ancestor of Beethoven’s Hammerklavier fugue, a driven reading with silvery flashes of grandeur. By contrast, the F minor which brought the first half of the programme to an end, was almost hypnotic in its methodical intensity. Later in the evening, the A minor stunned with its stormy passion and the B flat minor made a great impact with its solemnity; however it was the G major – a deceptively light-hearted fugue, here given a performance of triumphant transcendence – that offered perhaps the most effective summary of Mr Aimard’s artistry and Bach’s genius.

Preludes and fugues from the Well-Tempered Clavier appear often within recitals, but opportunities to hear them performed together are less frequent; however Mr Aimard made a strong argument for the first book standing on its own as an enormously satisfying concert programme. His meticulously crafted and consistently engaging performances managed to yield further insight into an inexhaustible masterpiece, and those in attendance will almost certainly be looking forward to his explorations of the second book.

Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.