Alemania

Musikfest Berlin Part 3: Premonitions and Refraction

Jesse Simon
Musikfest Berlin Part 3: Premonitions and Refraction
Berlin, viernes, 5 de septiembre de 2014.
Philharmonie. Gubaidulina: In tempus praesens. Bruckner: Symphony No. 9 in D minor. Gidon Kremer, violin. Sächsische Staatskapelle Dresden. Christian Thielemann, conductor. Musikfest Berlin 2014
9,9E-05

Near the end of Bruckner’s Ninth Symphony – written in the final decade of the nineteenth century and left incomplete when Bruckner died in 1896 – there is a terrifying scream from the orchestra, a sound far more disconsolate than anything that had previously appeared in his corpus of orchestral work. A similar mood of spiritual unease pervades much of Sofia Gubaidulina’s In tempus praesens, a concerto for violin and orchestra completed in 2007. The whole of the twentieth century separates these two dark works, but they complemented one another wonderfully in a gripping and often cathartic concert given by Gidon Kremer, Christian Thielemann and the Sächsische Staatskapelle as part of Musikfest Berlin.

Even before a note of Ms Gubaidulina’s concerto had been played, it was clear from the disposition of the orchestra that this would be no ordinary piece. The cellos and double basses far outnumbered the higher strings, there were six percussionists arranged around an intimidating collection of marimbas and metallophones, and the orchestra shared the stage with a celesta, a piano and a harpsichord. It was, without question, a modern orchestra, one fully capable of generating the kind of textures that rose to prominence after the second world war.

But while the modernist surfaces of Ms Gubaidulina’s concerto could occasionally sound icy, one was never allowed to ignore the hot-blooded anguish that existed just beneath. Indeed, parts of the piece were vaguely redolent of another great violin concerto that achieved its unique sound through the admixture of fire and ice – that of Sibelius – albeit refracted through the various personal and political traumas of the twentieth century. Even the most abstract passages were suffused with enormous feeling.

Although the work was written for and premièred by Anne-Sophie Mutter, Gidon Kremer was a natural fit for the role of soloist. In addition to a longstanding relationship with Ms Gubaidulina’s work – her first Violin concerto is dedicated to him – his astonishing blend of visceral emotion and meticulous control was well matched to a violin part that frequently pushed instrumental technique to its very limits. In Mr Kremer’s performance, however, there was a constant sense that the technical extremes were there to serve some larger purpose.

Indeed Mr Kremer appeared to have little trouble with the demanding violin part, creating odd textures and chasing notes all the way to the bridge with the poise of a master playing a simple etude; and yet his playing was often mesmerising. Near the end of the piece there was a savage solo passage – something like a pained cadenza – followed shortly by a riveting section in which he tapped out a quiet col legno figure in dialogue with a barrage of percussion; the brilliance of Mr Kremer’s performance lay in his ability to locate the full emotional potential in these sudden contrasts.

The Sächsische Staatskapelle offered a performance of no less commitment. Mr Thielemann’s penchant for absolute clarity could not always withstand the dense orchestration of Ms Gubaidulina’s score, but even in those moments where the orchestral definition grew blurred around the edges, the effect was always powerful. Mr Thielemann did a wonderful job of organising the textures and sonic events into a total performance of considerable depth; when the piece reached its climactic moment, the sound was beautifully alien, like no full orchestra has sounded before.

Audiences of a century earlier may have been similarly enthralled by the sonic world created by Bruckner in his later symphonies, and the acceptance of those works into the mainstream classical repertoire has done little to diminish their epic scope and raw intensity. Played poorly, they can be interminable; but, on this evening, Mr Thielemann and the Sächsische Staatskapelle gave the Ninth symphony such a commanding performance that few in the audience could have been left doubting Bruckner’s orchestral mastery.

The appearance of the full orchestra early in the first movement achieved a Bruckner sound that was close to perfect, with big smouldering trombones pressing hard against thickly massed strings. Mr Thielemann’s idea of how the orchestra should sound was matched by an almost instinctive feel for how the different sections needed to fit together to form a cohesive whole. His subtle changes in tempo dealt effectively with some of the score’s more problematic transitions, and his sense of rise and fall over the longer term presented the first movement as a single, continuously unfolding idea. The tempi were generally moderate, striking a balance between the deliberate reverence of some conductors and the ‘let’s get this over with’ approach of others.

While there are many ways to interpret Bruckner, it was difficult, in the first movement at least, to argue with any of Mr Thielemann’s choices; and, fortunately, this high level of good judgment did not come at the expense of emotional engagement. Where the first movement alternated between the singing lyricism of the second theme and the dark premonitions of the first, the opening of the second movement held back none of the savage intensity of Bruckner’s despairing vision.

The strengths of the Sächsische Staatskapelle are ideally suited to the symphonies of Bruckner, and the playing on this evening was as excellent as one might expect. The first violins were especially wonderful as they reached for that higher note in the opening of the third movement, and the Wagner tubas managed the rare feat of not sounding woozy in their ensemble sections. Near the middle of the third movement there were one or two shifts in tempo that sounded a touch forced, especially when compared to the seamlessness of the first two movements, but the big climax was as breathtaking as they come, and the quiet aftermath in which the symphony reaches its hushed conclusion was exquisite (Contrary to what was printed in the programme, they did not append a fourth movement reconstruction).

Neither Bruckner’s symphony nor Ms Gubaidulina’s concerto could be described as undemanding – either for orchestra or audience – but, under the stewardship of the Sächsische Staatskapelle, the two works made for a wholly compelling and often exhilarating programme. Although Bruckner’s Ninth is hardly a concert-hall rarity, it is certainly rare to hear it performed with such great understanding; as for In tempus praesens, so long as it enjoys the support of soloists as committed as Mr Kremer, it should have no trouble finding a place for itself within the modern repertoire.

Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.