Alemania

Musikfest Part 5: Strange Overtones

Jesse Simon
Musikfest Part 5: Strange Overtones
Berlin, lunes, 15 de septiembre de 2014.
Philharmonie. Haas: concerto grosso No. 1. Bruckner: Symphony No. 8 in C minor. Hornroh Modern Alphorn Quartet. SWR Sinfonieorchester. François-Xavier Roth, conductor
0,0001627

These days, the alphorn is most commonly spotted on poster advertisements extolling the virtues of spending your holiday in Switzerland; they are less frequently seen – or, for that matter, heard – in the concert hall. Yet Georg Friedrich Haas’ baffling and strangely brilliant concerto grosso no. 1 – performed by the Hornroh Modern Alphorn Quartet with the SWR Sinfonieorchester under the direction of François-Xavier Roth – was no mere novelty piece. And while the concerto was paired with an uneven sprint through Bruckner’s Eighth symphony, the deep stirring sonorities of the alphorns as reimagined by Haas made for one of the most memorable programmes of this year’s Musikfest.

Before getting to the evening’s unconventional highlight, it is perhaps worth saying a few brief words about the programme’s second half. François-Xavier Roth may be justly respected for his articulate readings of works from the twentieth and twenty-first centuries, but his approach to Bruckner’s Eighth was so cursory as to drain it of its essential vitality. What should stand as one of the supreme achievements of symphonic writing was, on this evening, presented with such haste that it seemed oddly unmoving.

The first movement – which, in Mr Roth’s defence, is marked Allegro – was taken at a clip that seemed to ignore the ‘moderato’ part of the composer’s instruction. Admittedly, the themes were presented with great clarity, and the brisk pace made light work of any structural difficulties the movement may possess. But what came across as an excess of motivation in the first and second movements sounded increasingly like discomfort in the third; in that vast Adagio, it too often felt as though Mr Roth was either unwilling to engage with Bruckner’s grand vision, or afraid that the score would not stand up to a more expansive reading.

The velocity of Mr Roth’s reading may also have had a negative effect on some of the playing. At various points throughout the first and second movements, some of the ensembles sounded rough around the edges; there was a touch of shrillness in the higher massed winds, and a sense of the finer details being lost. In the fourth movement, an attempt to mould the opening horn theme into something coherent ended up propelling the strings forward at a dangerous pace. This is not to say that symphony was devoid of good moments – the conclusion was genuinely thrilling, as it should be – but the best moments seemed to disappear as quickly as they had arrived.

One would struggle to make similar criticisms of either the orchestra or the conductor during their lucid, highly-charged performance of the piece which formed the first half of the programme. Haas’ concerto grosso no. 1 featured a quartet of alphorns set against a moderately large (albeit reasonably conventional) orchestra; and while the four long horns were an unusual sight, it was nowhere nearly as unusual as the sounds that began to emerge from the stage as the piece began.

Oddly tuned drones, sounding more like a Tibetan Buddhist ritual than anything from an alpine meadow, created an uneasy bed for a dense fog of pizzicato strings. From there, the piece evolved into a series of curious – and curiously beautiful – clusters of sliding sound. The horns themselves had interchangeable neck pieces, which allowed them to be tuned to different pitches, and Haas took full advantage of this feature, setting horns a semi-tone apart against one another to create deep overtones that fluttered through the concert hall. Sometimes the close harmonic intervals were mirrored in the strings; sometimes the percussion would start to build in the background, adding more unease and disorientation to the mix.

As the piece developed it started to hint at some kind of tonal resolution that never quite arrived. In the extended middle section – perhaps the most impressive and sonically compelling part of the piece – the strings and horns created continuous waves of sound, swelling and receding, while the alphorns played something like a damaged chorale that seemed to disintegrate with each repetition. Although it occasionally came closer to ambient electronic music than anything notated for a traditional orchestra, the cumulative effect was undeniably striking.

The momentum of the piece – for there was a pronounced rhythmic foundation – was accompanied by constant sense that something big was about to happen, although it was impossible to predict what it might be. At last, the orchestra crested and fell away leaving, for a few second, only the resonant sound of the horns filling the hall with a cluster of tones that suggested no key in particular; but the dissonance itself was compelling. As the orchestra returned and the piece reached its conclusion, one could not help but feel overwhelmed – in the best way possible – by the experience of the previous half hour.

After being called back to the stage several times, the members of the Hornroh Quartet performed a well-deserved encore that started with the four of them playing conch shells. One by one, they switched back to alphorn for a four part exercise in rising harmonic clouds which sounded as though they might turn into the opening of Das Rheingold at any moment. Although it was fascinating to hear the alphorns in something closer to their natural setting, one had to commend Georg Friedrich Haas for seeing the greater harmonic potential in these ancient mountain instruments.

Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.