Alemania
The State of the Symphony
How do you write a symphony after Beethoven? This was one of the inescapable problems that most composers of the nineteenth century were forced to address … and few of them came to the same conclusions. While Bruckner rebuilt the basic structures at a much larger scale, and Mahler tested the boundaries of the form by adding anything he could think of, Schumann and Brahms sought to advance the form through a process of gradual and continual refinement; it was these latter two composers – both of whom composed four symphonies each over a combined span of half a century – who formed the focus of a fascinating double cycle performed by the Berlin Philharmonic over the course of four consecutive nights.
There was a simple logic that dictated the structure of each evening: each began with a symphony by Schumann and was followed, after an interval, by the correspondingly numbered symphony by Brahms. However the arrangement made for programmes of intriguing contrast. The excitable First and the jubilant Fourth of Schumann were counterbalanced by Brahms’ two most darkly tempestuous symphonies; between those bookend concerts, the (relatively) lighter middle works of Brahms were paired with Schumann’s more mature, and more profound, symphonic creations.
The cycle was organised as part of Berlin’s Musikfest, but a second series of performances the following week doubled as a belated release party for the lavishly packaged boxed set of Schumann’s symphonies released earlier this year by the Berlin Philharmonic’s new record label; time will tell if they were also an opportunity for Sir Simon Rattle and the orchestra to commit a new Brahms cycle to tape for future release. Regardless, the chance to hear a great orchestra tackle these essential works of the romantic repertoire left few seats in the Philharmonie unoccupied; and if some of the symphonies inevitably came off better than others, there was no evening that did not offer some degree of satisfying insight into the composers, their works, and the state of the symphony at the pinnacle of its existence.
The Firsts
Expectations were undoubtedly high for the cycle to begin, but the first concert got off to a somewhat uneven start with a performance of Schumann’s First that, despite some inspired orchestral playing, never entirely managed to cohere. The opening andante sounded a touch bulbous where it should have been incisive, and there was a curious imbalance between the brass and the strings. Things improved as the allegro section began; Sir Simon, consistent with his recent recording, adopted a classicising approach that was light and lean, and the orchestra responded with playing of refinement. However as the end of the movement came into view, the pace, already at a brisk trot, turned into a gallop; these sudden bursts of speed (usually at the end of a movement) would recur at various times throughout the subsequent evenings.
If the second movement also seemed on the quick side, it was at least consistent with Sir Simon’s attempts to excise any hints of heavy romanticism that some interpreters have found in Schumann’s symphonies. However the restless momentum which had lightened the slow movement gave a certain recklessness to the Scherzo – the second trio, especially, sounded like the work of a more youthful, less experienced composer – and the final movement might have benefitted from a little more space to let the music breathe. Nonetheless, there was still much to commend the symphony: there was playing of great depth from the strings – most notably their warm naturalistic sound in the second movement – and the flutes were excellent throughout. Yet the performance as a whole did little to illuminate Schumann’s first outing as a symphonist.
The same, however, could not be said of Brahms’ First symphony, which received a sympathetic reading and a performance of suitable weight. Where the Schumann had come across as over-thought and somewhat over-driven, the mannerisms of the first half were replaced in the second by lucidity, natural flow and judicious restraint: the tempi were more measured, the interpretive choices were rendered with greater subtlety, and the orchestra played with a warmth and opulence that fit the symphony well.
Other conductors have approached the monolithic solemnity of the opening movement with greater reverence, but Sir Simon was able to balance gravitas with a compelling urgency that allowed the themes to unfold and develop with an unforced clarity. If there were perhaps a few moments in the slow movement that seemed to lack in absolute focus, there were also extended passages of considerable beauty along with some exquisite solo oboe and violin playing. The third movement managed to locate the emotional depth beneath the buoyancy of the surface, and the long build of the final movement’s great theme generated no shortage of palpable excitement.
There is little need, in the present day, for a conductor to make a case for the worth of Brahms’ First symphony, but hearing an engaging performance is never an unwelcome experience. And if, on this evening, Sir Simon and the orchestra had presented Schumann’s symphony as an impulsive creation by a composer who would go on to reach greater heights, their approach to Brahms conveyed the success of a master craftsman who had spent half his life tormented by symphonic form, only to emerge triumphant at the end.
The Seconds
The second evening of the cycle was, in some respects, an inversion of the first, with a well-judged and strongly played Schumann symphony followed by a performance of Brahms’ Second which, despite several inspired moments, remained somehow unsatisfying. Nonetheless, the evening began with an introduction to the first movement that was slow, spacious and pleasingly grand. Unlike the hurried pace of the first symphony from the day before, the tempi felt more restrained, lively without being overly quick. Even the sound itself, perhaps due to Schumann’s increased mastery of orchestration, seemed more expansive and more clearly defined.
Although there were a few instances where Sir Simon seemed intent on giving the score his own interpretive spin – a sudden burst of speed at the end of the second movement and a few less-than-subtle diminuendi in the fourth – he seemed mostly content to let the symphony unfurl according to its own logic. After an exciting first movement, the Scherzo was energetic and forthright, less mysterious than some readings, but a delight to hear. This was followed by a wonderful slow movement, distinguished by a breathtaking pianissimo section and some superb playing from the principal flute and oboe, as well as the two horns.
After a first half of such marvellous vitality and focus, the second symphony of Brahms seemed – in its first two movements at very least – oddly muted. To some extent the problem lay neither with the orchestra nor the conductor, but with the symphony itself; unlike the First or the Fourth, both of which possess an immediate emotional accessibility, the Second is more ambiguous. Although Brahms himself described it a work of great melancholy, its darknesses remain, for the most part, deeply buried beneath a surface of genial formality; of Brahms’ symphonies, it is perhaps the most traditional in terms of its construction, and while the themes are undoubtedly pleasant, the work as a whole can come across as curiously uninvolving.
The performance on this evening featured magnificent orchestral playing throughout and no shortage of stunning individual moments; but those moments never quite added up to the impression of a great symphony. The first appearance of the Wiegenlied theme in the first movement was played with a sweeping lyricism that avoided outright sentimentality, but during parts of the development the movement seemed to lack the focus that had been so prominent in the earlier Schumann symphony. The second movement was eminently agreeable and also featured some of the most glorious strings of the entire cycle. But something was missing. The grand sound of the orchestra was unable to mask the dispassionate formality of Brahms conception.
Things improved somewhat in the scherzo, which began in a pastoral mood, but soon restored some of the fire that had been missing from the earlier movements. This drive and energy continued into the concluding movement, which featured a wonderfully calm section and a genuinely stirring finale to send us into the evening. But even the dazzling effect of those final moments could not quite alleviate the suspicion that the symphony had ultimately been little more than a collage of brilliant fragments.
The Thirds
Of the four evenings, the third may have been the most satisfyingly balanced. There had been some great moments to that point – and Brahms’ Fourth, arguably the finest performance of the cycle, was still to come – but the third symphonies of Schumann and Brahms made for a consistently engaging and even somewhat revelatory concert. Following the precedent of the other evenings (and contrary to what was printed in the programme), it was Schumann’s Third that started the opening half; and while there certainly would have been an argument for using the mightier ‘Rheinishe’ symphony to conclude the evening, the order of chronology and increasing orchestral size yielded its own rewards.
Although it was published before the revised Fourth, the Third was actually Schumann’s final symphony, and as such it represents both a summation of his orchestral skill and a curious hint as to where he might have gone with the symphonic form had he not died a mere five years later. It is the only one of his symphonies to push beyond the traditional four movement structure, and within it one can sense both an increased mastery and a certain restlessness.
On this evening the piece opened with great warmth and, over the course of the first movement, worked its way toward bracing grandeur. Sir Simon’s reading, very much like the one on the recent recording, had a few moments where the dynamic fluctuation in the strings seemed a shade too drastic, but the overall impression was of a magnificent vista onto a joyous scene. While retaining the general leanness of sound that had characterised the earlier Schumann symphonies, the opening of the Third had an appealingly earthy foundation that set the humanity of the piece on prominent display. This good-natured manner continued into the second movement, with a beautifully rendered opening theme that rolled forward with all the majesty of the river it sought to describe.
However it was the final triptych of movements, played without pause, that proved the most memorable. After a pleasant third movement, the severity of the fourth came as something of a surprise, with the sunny disposition of the work suddenly growing dark. The brass section in general, and the horns in particular, had already been having an especially good night but, in the solemn fourth movement, they glowed with an overwhelming beauty. By the opening of the fifth movement, however, the sepulchral mood had dissipated and the symphony moved forth toward its conclusion, propelled by more great playing from the horns and a reading that accentuated the details of Schumann’s score rather than exaggerate them. As a whole, the symphony would stand as one of the finest performances of the cycle.
The most pleasantly surprising performance of the cycle was soon to follow. Brahms’ Third, even more so than the Second, is a work where the modesty of its construction almost seems to deflect enthusiasm. But if it is the quietest and most unassuming of Brahms’ symphonies, it is perhaps the one with the most secrets; and on this evening, Sir Simon and the orchestra seemed determined to uncover the depths hidden beneath its placid surface.
The opening movement – the first bars of which bore an uncanny similarity to the Schumann symphony from earlier in the evening – was presented with a rich sound and sense of purpose that had been sometimes lacking from the Second symphony the previous evening. However it was the probing slow movement that provided one of the unmistakable highlights of the evening: between the movement’s few grand gestures was a captivating mood of lyrical introspection, taken at a perfectly measured pace and presided over with expert control.
The third movement began with a mannered phrasing that successfully offset any potential for sentimentality, choosing instead to transform its lilting momentum and languid pace into a disquieting elegy; and in the fourth movement, there was an energy and tension that managed to hint at the tragedy of the symphony to follow. Nonetheless, the symphony drew to a quietly optimistic conclusion that seemed neither forced nor subdued. Between a thoughtful reading and extraordinary orchestral playing, Sir Simon and the Berlin Philharmonic had managed to find their way into Brahms’ most misunderstood symphonic work.
The Fourths
Schumann’s Fourth was actually his second completed symphony; he returned to it ten years later, after he had written the third, and made some substantial alterations to the orchestration. While the revised version is most often performed and recorded today, Sir Simon – in keeping with his recent recording – returned to the original version of 1841 to begin the final evening of the Berlin Philharmonic’s Brahms and Schumann cycle.
His reading was, if anything, more rigorous and more precise than his previous outings with the symphony. The pace was brisk and the playing tidy, especially from the strings, who did an excellent job of highlighting the small flourishes in the score without overstating them. But if the opening movement exuded absolute control, it did not sound especially relaxed. The relentless forward motion of the beginning – which necessarily dictated a faster tempo for the subsequent slow movement – admitted nothing that did not adhere to the pulse. The concert-master handled his second movement solo passage with skilful fluidity, but there was a sense that the momentum of the piece did not allow quite enough room for lyricism.
Only at the end of the third movement did things grow calm. The transition into the final movement – in which one can almost discern hints of the vastness that Bruckner would later attempt to capture in his symphonies – is one of the most grand utterances in all of Schumann’s symphonic work, and Sir Simon seemed determined to extract the full measure of its profundity. He was successful; the transition was as mighty and mysterious as one might hope. But when the transition was over, the nervous pace returned and the symphony sped forth to a breathless conclusion.
If the exuberance of the Schumann was not to all tastes, there could be few in the audience left unmoved by Brahms’ Fourth, which would eclipse Schumann’s Third as the high point of the cycle. Here there was no excess of speed, but instead a carefully judged, deeply felt reading that was both piercingly emotional and wholly free of affectation; and even though the orchestra had performed with great unity throughout the cycle, their playing during this final symphony was a marvel of subtlety and elemental power.
In the opening movement one could hear all of the drama, solemnity and mystery that would shape the symphony. Here at last one was able to stop thinking in terms of orchestra sections and interpretive decisions and become fully immersed in the music. Nothing stood out as being too quick or too moulded. If there was a sense of urgency in the unfolding drama it was unforced and organic, the natural consequence of what had come before. This sense of purpose carried over to the second movement, which was magnificent in its introspection.
The final movements were in no way inferior to the first two. The third movement was fiery and expansive with a sense of dynamic that generated no small amount of excitement. (By complete coincidence, it was also the first movement to feature a triangle since the opening Schumann symphony three nights earlier). Brahms was famously dismissive of Wagner and Bruckner, but in Sir Simon’s reading, the distance between the three composers was not quite as great as Brahms may have wished to believe. The darkly euphoric third movement led directly into a tempestuous fourth; if the final movement was the most driven of the four, it also possessed tremendous emotional force. Great surges from the orchestra – who, to their credit, can grow terrifyingly loud while losing nothing in clarity – brought Brahms’ great tragedy, and the cycle itself, to a memorably moving conclusion.
The Berlin Philharmonic have been performing the symphonies of Schumann and Brahms since the time of their foundation in 1882 and, in that time, those works have been subjected to as many different readings as there are conductors. The symphonies may be so many notes on so many sheets of paper, but the performances themselves are a marker of time; they bind us to a particular era and remind us that we are fortunate to be witnesses to history. When time has made these evenings in 2014 legendary, there will be a new generation of music lovers filling the seats of the Philharmonie to hear the same orchestra perform these same works that have, since they were written, never ceased to inspire us.
Comentarios