Alemania
Some Enchanted Evening
There are many things that can go wrong in the course of an opera performance: even when ninety percent is wonderful, a lacklustre orchestra, uninspired stage direction, a baffling production design or a sub-par singer can be disproportionately detrimental to the whole. However, at a recent performance of Tristan und Isolde at the Staatsoper – in Harry Kupfer’s venerable staging – the audience were treated to that rare kind of evening where everything seemed to be in near-perfect alignment. With Waltraud Meier and Peter Seiffert in the leading roles and a profound reading of the score from Daniel Barenboim and the Staatskapelle, it was a Tristan that ended up being considerably greater than the sum of its already impressive parts.
Harry Kupfer was virtually synonymous with the Staatsoper’s Wagner productions in the nineties and, although his famous Ring cycle was recently shelved and his Parsifal is due to be replaced in the coming year, his Tristan – now fifteen years old – remains a welcome fixture of the repertoire. Regardless of how one may feel about the stage concept – a giant half-submerged weeping angel sculpture on which much of the action takes place – one cannot deny Mr Kupfer’s extraordinary gift for translating the drama of the music into physical action.
The story of Tristan und Isolde should not be unfamiliar to anyone with a passing interest in opera, but Mr Kupfer’s production contained countless small moments offering insight into the psychology of the characters; the idea of the two lovers as a lofty romantic archetype was, in Mr Kupfer’s telling, counterbalanced with a reassuringly flawed humanity. Certainly, the scene in the first act in which Tristan and Isolde wait for death after consuming what they believe to be poison has rarely been rendered with greater plausibility: we experience with them the fear and resignation, followed swiftly by the lightness of a second chance at living.
Mr Kupfer’s direction, on this evening, was fully realised by two singers with the ability to combine astonishing vocal command with an absolute committment to physical acting. In terms of presence alone, it would be impossible to praise Waltraud Meier too highly. She has been singing Isolde for over two decades – indeed, she appears on Daniel Barenboim’s 1994 recording – and by this point she presumably has the role down to a science. Yet watching her, one was struck with the sensation of a drama unfolding for the first time; her sudden explosions in the first act, her delirious passions in the second and her chilling resolve in the third were woven into a fully coherent vision of the character. Whenever she was on stage, she immediately brought the emotion of the story into sharp focus.
Vocallly, she was no less impressive. If her voice no longer has quite the roundness it had a decade ago, she was more than able to compensate with an endlessly nuanced, fully dramatic delivery. In some of her more conversational passages – notably her first dialogue with Brangäne – there was a measured, almost constricted quality to her voice; but it disappeared quickly when she needed it to. Her second scene with Brangäne in the first act was gripping, and her ecstatic pronouncements in the long second act duet conveyed a sense of pure enchantment; but her scene with Tristan at the end of the first act was, alone, enough to secure her place within the pantheon of great Isoldes. Only a handful of singers have rendered the transformative effects of the love potion more credibly.
While Ms Meier’s performance would have been an emotional tour-de-force in any setting, she was fortunate to have Peter Seiffert as her romantic foil. Mr Seiffert’s Tristan was a marvel of vocal ardour and physical presence situated firmly in the borderland between passion and madness. He was wonderfully awkward trying to maintain a degree of knightly decorum in his first act duet with Isolde, and his lengthy third act monologues contained enough unhinged desperation to be genuinely unsettling. But he was at his best in those scenes – the end of the first act, and his subsequent meeting with Isolde in the second – when he was carried away by uncontrollable desire.
For Tristan und Isolde to be successful, the title characters must effectively eclipse everything around them, and both Mr Seiffert and Ms Meier were able to accomplish this with little effort. However the two lovers did not suffer from a lack of remarkable support. As King Marke, René Pape achieved an ideal balance between regal outrage and personal heartbreak. There was a certain amount of angry bluster in his second act repriment, but when he grew quiet at the line ‘Tristan mich verriet’, it had the effect of making the tragedy seem suddenly very personal and very human.
Ekaterina Gubanova sang an appealing, elegantly-phrased Brangäne, although there were a few moments where she seemed to struggle to be heard over the might of the orchestra; however her attempts to calm Isolde in the first act were deeply heartfelt and her first offstage warning in the second act was beautiful. As Kurwenal, Roman Trekel was lighter of voice and younger of spirit than some proponents of the role, although this worked in his favour more often than not; he sounded suitably cocky in his first act response to Brangäne and unconsolably distressed for the entirety of the third act.
However it was the orchestra and their conductor who, along with the two title characters, really elevated the evening into the realm of greatness. Daniel Barenboim, whose knowledge and appreciation of the score was apparent in every bar, fashioned the music into a completely fluid body of tidal emotion. The Prelude – which, apart from a brief stage tableau, unfolded in the darkness of the theatre – was unbearably beautiful; but Mr Barenboim and the orchestra somehow managed to maintain that same level of intensity for the next three and a half hours. Yet there were no scenes or moments that seemed unnecessarily drawn out; the orchestra played with agility and dramatic pace, surging magnificently when appropriate, and growing languid and dreamlike only during the remarkable love duet at the centre of the second act. Orchestrally, it would be difficult to imagine a more perfectly crafted Tristan.
After Isolde had sung her final note – Waltraud Meier always sings a rapturous Liebestod, and this was no exception – and the swell of the orchestra had subsided, there was a tremendous silence in the theatre, as if applause might somehow diminish the effect of what we had just experienced. But when Ms Meier and Mr Seiffert emerged from the behind the curtain, the audience rose to their feet with no hesitation. The curtain calls went on for far longer than normal, and there seemed to be a general agreement among everyone in the room that we had been witness to one of those rare evenings where the consitutent parts of an opera had come together in an extraordinary way.
Comentarios