Alemania

Beethoven 9 : Wall 0

Jesse Simon
Beethoven 9 : Wall 0
Berlin, domingo, 9 de noviembre de 2014.
Philharmonie. Szymanowski: Stabat mater, op. 53. Beethoven: Symphony No. 9 in D minor, op. 125. Sally Matthews (Soprano). Bernarda Fink (Alto). Christian Elsner (Tenor). Hanno Müller-Brachmann (Baritone). Rundfunkchor Berlin. Berlin Philharmonic. Sir Simon Rattle, conductor
0,0002323

On 9 November 1989, at a few minutes past seven in the evening, news began to circulate that the border between East and West Berlin had been dissolved. By the end of the evening, images of people dancing on the Berlin Wall were being broadcast to televisions around the world, and the events of that night would set in motion a process culminating in the reunification of Germany. Twenty-five years later, how does one even begin to mark the anniversary of such a momentous occasion. For the people of Berlin, the answer would appear to be: Beethoven.

Beethoven was present almost as soon as the Wall had come down. A quickly-organised concert given by the Berlin Philharmonic under Daniel Barenboim only three days later welcomed East Berliners to the West with Beethoven’s First Piano Concerto and his Seventh Symphony. The following month, Leonard Bernstein led a famous performance of the Ninth where the word ‘Freude’ (Joy) in the final movement was replaced with ‘Freiheit’ (Freedom).

From an historical perspective alone, the Ninth seemed an obvious choice for the twenty-fifth anniversary celebrations. Even without the widely recognised theme of its finale, the symphony possesses both the solemnity and jubilation of a mass while remaining effectively secular. God may appear in the text of Schiller’s Ode to Joy, but – for Schiller and Beethoven – its titular subject exists independently of religion, as both a universal emotion and an inalienable human right.

Thus, on the evening of 9 November 2014, it was possible to hear the symphony (or, at least, parts of it) from two separate orchestras at two separate locations. While the fourth movement alone was performed at the Brandenburger Tor as part of an extended son et lumière, a different kind of observance was taking place a few hundred yards away at the Philharmonie.The concert – featuring the Berlin Philharmonic, an accomplished group of soloists, and the ever-formidable Rundfunkchor, all under the direction of Sir Simon Rattle – paired the full Ninth with a more contemplative opening half consisting of Szymanowski’s Stabat mater. This latter piece provided a necessary counterbalance to the Beethoven, serving as a poignant reminder that sorrow and joy are forever inseparable.

On this evening, the orchestra performed the Stabat mater with a great deal of restraint. Although they lacked nothing in intensity – indeed, the sense of occasion seemed to inspire playing of exceptional feeling – their often luminous sound was consistently deferential to the voices of the soloists and choir. The soloists, in turn, seemed committed to making the most of the text. In particular, Sally Matthews – whose sturdy, subtly declamatory soprano was ideally suited to the solemnity of the music – delivered an extraordinary performance, opening the piece with exquisite lamentation and bringing it to a close with a mood of cautious tranquillity.

However perhaps the most consistently impressive performance came from the Rundfunkchor, who managed to be overwhelming without being overpowering: their contribution to the volatile second section was filled with an explosive energy, but it was their quiet interjections in the final section that had the greatest impact. Between excellent singing and playing, the Stabat mater seemed to posit the concert as an evening of remembrance rather than celebration.

Beethoven’s Ninth may be more explicitly celebratory, but its emotionally ambiguous opening movement – introduced by a severe, decisive descending figure – is closer to a description of a struggle. On this evening, the movement – which features a series of dramatic outbursts that are frequently thrilling, but rarely reassuring – was given a truly stirring performance. Sir Simon’s reading – which has been reasonably consistent over the past few years – benefitted from a touch of extra urgency, paired with a greater willingness to allow the symphony to inhabit its own epic space. Where his Beethoven performances can, at times, sound almost too tightly controlled, his rhythmic focus and unforced transitions resulted in a darkly invigorating whole.

The second movement was possibly even better; indeed, the ferocity and agility of the playing was so great that, even if Sir Simon had laid down his baton, it is doubtful he would have been able to stop the music he had set in motion. Rather, the music appeared to be governed by its own will, reaching a level of intensity that the orchestra was just barely able to contain. It was as thrilling a second movement as one might hope to hear. Only with the third movement was a sense of peace restored to the auditorium of the Philharmonie. The strings played with an unparalleled warmth, and there were several moments during which Sir Simon abandoned the baton entirely, preferring to sculpt the contours of the music rather than fixate strictly on pulse. As a result, the movement proceeded with an encompassing sense of inner calm.

That stillness, however, was brought to an end by the opening of the fourth movement. If the symphony’s great finale ended up being slightly more mannered than the three supremely focused preceding movements, there was still no shortage of wonderful sections. The beginning of the initial fugue, in which the theme makes its first full appearance in the quiet double basses, was breathtaking, as was the mighty ‘steht vor Gott’ that brought the first choral section to its conclusion. Hanno Müller-Brachmann’s introductory ‘O Freunde, nicht diese Töne’ was heavy on the ornamentation, but he quickly settled into an oratory groove with the first lines of Schiller’s ode; and Christian Elsner’s ‘Froh, Froh’ section sounded suitably spirited.

Bernarda Fink and Sally Matthews sounded wonderful together in all of the ensemble sections although, based on Ms Matthews’ performance earlier in the evening, one found themselves wishing that Beethoven had given the soprano a more prominent role in the finale; and, of course, the Rundfunkchor were magnificent from beginning to end, elevating Schiller’s text and Beethoven’s music with their every appearance. If one may have had some reservations about Sir Simon’s more overt dynamic tinkering and his choice of tempo in the final section – which transformed the concluding bars into something of a blur – they were insignificant compared to the effect of the symphony as a whole.

When the concert had ended, many of the people in the audience started back in the direction of Potsdamer Platz, where they would begin their journeys home. Anyone who had been there on that fateful night in 1989 would struggle to recognise the area now, with its glass towers and bland hotels. In the span of twenty-five years, the illusion of a continuous city had mostly been restored; and if no music can ultimately convey a true sense of what it must have felt like to witness history unfolding in the past, both Szymanowski’s Stabat mater and Beethoven’s Ninth gave us occasion to celebrate the joy that music will always bring to the present.

Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.