Alemania

A Drama of Lamentation

Jesse Simon
A Drama of Lamentation
Berlin, jueves, 22 de enero de 2015.
Philharmonie. Brahms: Ein deutsches Requiem, op. 45. Siobhan Stagg, Soprano. Christian Gerhaher, Baritone. Rundfunkchor Berlin. Gijs Leenaars, Choir Master. Berlin Philharmonic. Christian Thielemann, Conductor
0,0001685

There are many who praise Brahms, quite justly, for his eloquence, craftsmanship and rigorous consideration of form; yet for all his refinement, he is arguably at his best when aiming for the gut. Thus one may appreciate the sophistication and ingenuity of his Second symphony, but a great performance of the Fourth can leave one breathless. The German Requiem falls somewhere in between those two extremes, and a great performance must be able to highlight not merely the austere beauty, but also the emotional volatility of Brahms’ concept.

Christian Thielemann, for his second guest appearance of the season, led the combined forces of the Berlin Philharmonic and the Rundfunkchor Berlin in a performance of the German Requiem that seemed less interested in creating a mood of sustained reverence than in drawing forth the seismic shifts between sorrow and jubilation. It was, in its own way, tremendously moving, a performance in which the thrills were more physical than spiritual.

Throughout the evening, Mr Thielemann – conducting without a score – favoured tempi which, although never excessively brisk, were decidedly animated. In the deeply-felt opening movement, one was always aware of the underlying pulse moving the piece forward, while the magnificently apocalyptic second movement proceeded with an urgency that served to heighten the drama. Where some conductors have approached the Requiem as a work of profound reflection, Mr Thielemann’s reading was restless and passionate; it channelled the Brahms of the First piano concerto far more than, say, the Brahms of the Third symphony.

Perhaps the most fully realised (and immediately gripping) example of Mr Thielemann’s approach came in the third movement. With its opening lamentation ‘Herr, lehre doch mich, dass ein Ende mit mir haben muss’, it is easy to approach this movement as the dark centre of the Requiem, and its moment of greatest despair. Under Mr Thielemann’s direction, however, there was a stinging torment that cut through the gloom and made the text sound more anguished than resigned. The sudden orchestral outburst that silences the solo-baritone was both a cry from the depths and a wonderful introduction to the movement’s final section in which the battle between tempestuous violins and the tidal pull of the choir resulted in one of the most gloriously affecting moments of the evening.

Mr Thielemann’s approach was not without its minor flaws. The incisive strings that underpinned ‘mein Leib und Seele freuen sich’ in the fourth movement seemed a shade too emphatic, and there was more than one closing cadence that seemed elongated to an unnatural degree. But such moments were infrequent and they did little to upset the prevailing impression of the Requiem as a mighty work of untempered emotion.

If Mr Thielemann’s vision of the piece came across with such immediacy, it was due in no small part to a performance from the Rundfunkchor that was astonishing from beginning to end. Like a grand organ, the choir offered nearly limitless tonal possibilities while remaining a single, indivisible instrument. It would be impossible, without quoting the entire text of the Requiem, to enumerate the memorable moments for which the choir were responsible. The ‘Hölle, wo ist dein Sieg’ passage from the sixth movement was among the most tremendous of the evening, and it is safe to say that few in the audience could have escaped the second movement’s terrifying, climactic ‘Denn alles Fleisch’ unmoved.

In addition to the endlessly formidable choir, the evening boasted strong vocal performances from the two soloists. As a late replacement for Sibylla Rubens, Siobhan Stagg brought a voice of tenderness and purity to the fifth movement. Christian Gerhaher, on the other hand, delivered his two passages with a perfect mixture of steely determination and restrained anguish. Mr Gerhaher, who was a memorable Jesus in last year’s Matthäus-Passion, summoned a similar declamatory authority in the third movement, where the unwavering resolve in his voice worked wonderfully against the searching of the choir. If there was a greater passion in his voice during the sixth movement, it never came at the expense of gravitas.

The Berlin Philharmonic, for their part, were able to sustain the heightened drama of Mr Thielemann’s reading with little apparent effort. Various soloists and groups distinguished themselves throughout the evening: the trombones in the final movement were stunning, the solo flute and oboe offered several moments of illumination in the darker movements, and of course the timpanist did a wonderful job of summoning terror in the second movement. Mostly, however, the orchestra impressed through their unity of purpose and their sensitivity to the choir. The balance between instruments and vocals was faultless.

Over the past two decades, Mr Thielemann has made a name for himself as a great opera conductor, and on this evening one could discern evidence of an operatic approach in his attention to the vocal drama; and for all that the results were undeniably stirring, it seemed probable that his vision of the German Requiem would have been somehow too indecorously emotional to be performed comfortably within a real church as an actual mass of lamentation. But in the secular space of the Philharmonie, the highly charged moments of anguish and triumph – and especially the overwhelming beauty of the choir – offered an encompassing sense of affirmation.

Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.