Alemania
Humourists
If Shostakovich is remembered today in reverent terms, it is based perhaps on the cumulative impact of his most haunted works –the Fourteenth symphony, the final string quartets– as well as his most devastating and savage. But the man had an unmistakable sense of humour; and while much of his later work may have been the product of cautious scepticism and genuine anguish, one finds ample evidence in the late-twenties and early-thirties of a composer whose works were shaped by a provocative wit.
It was this lighter side of Shostakovich -complemented by two similarly good-natured works form Prokofiev- that formed the programme of an immensely delightful concert recently given by the Rundfunk-Sinfonieorchester Berlin under the direction of Dima Slobodeniouk. While the four pieces -one piano concerto and one suite from each composer- demonstrated artists who were well on their way to achieving a mature style, they also possessed a certain youthful irreverence that gave the evening its overarching theme.
The Suite from The Golden Age -a ballet about the misadventures of a Soviet football team in the greedy capitalist west- provided the evening with a lively overture. In the opening movement, which features a number of sudden changes in tempo and style, Mr Slobodeniouk presided over the chaos with great control; one climax died down to reveal a comedic waltz, halfway between luxury and parody, but it was only a matter of bars before the piece was off in a completely new direction. It was disorienting, to be sure, but also firmly engaging.
Mr Slobodeniouk, although not lacking in energy, seemed to be distancing himself somewhat from the furious school of Shostakovich conducting practiced especially by Mravinsky (and to some extent Rostropovich); there was an understated intelligence and clearly defined spaciousness in his approach that did not, thankfully, come at the expense of excitement. He achieved striking results in the second movement, which removed Shostakovich momentarily from the vanguard of the twentieth century and reimagined him as the final practitioner of late romanticism. It worked, in no small part, due to the gorgeous playing of the strings, and an especially lovely solo violin passage.
Despite a few traces of disorganisation in the third movement -the brass didn’t always sound as though they were on the same page as the strings- there was some wonderful xylophone and a pleasing lilt to the rhythm; and the fourth movement -which, in this performance at least, may be the closest Shostakovich ever came to sounding like Stravinsky- featured a soaring full-orchestra and a swift pace that brought the piece to a rousing conclusion.
Prokofiev’s First piano concerto -written and published, as the legend has it, so the judges of a piano competition wouldn’t be able to tell if the composer was performing his chosen work poorly or not- exudes an infectious good humour and, on this evening, pianist Simon Trpčeski proved an enthusiastic ambassador for the work, tackling the most difficult passages with clarity, poise and a lightness of spirit. He clearly delighted in every note and had no difficulty communicating that delight to the audience.
As in the opening piece, Mr Slobodeniouk seemed to possess a direct line to the string section, who responded to his direction with great sensitivity. That control, alas, did not seem to extend as far back as the trumpets, who in the concerto’s initial section had a bit of trouble keeping it together (the problem had cleared up by the final section). However this was a minor point next to the exciting (and excitable) pianism unfolding at the front of the stage. The more complex the part grew, the more nimble Mr Trpčeski seemed to become, sending silvery sparks from the uppermost octave of the instrument, and emphasising a certain breadth of sound in those passages that took their inspiration more from the dance hall than the concert hall. As the concerto neared its conclusion, Mr Trpčeski was given an ever more fearsome workout until, at last, the final note caused him to spring triumphant from his bench, overflowing with more energy than one man and one piano could bear.
Mr Trpčeski returned in the second half of the programme for a performance of Shostakovich’s Concerto for Piano, Trumpet and Strings that was, without question, the highlight of the evening. The lightness that he had displayed in the Prokofiev concerto was still very much in evidence, but it was now balanced by a pleasing seriousness that managed to locate the emotional core beneath the work’s complex network of musical allusions. In some ways, this concerto was the most irreverent piece of the evening … but in this performance it also ended up being the most satisfyingly substantial.
Although a double concerto in name, it is the piano which dominates the opening movement and Mr Trpčeski performed with great vigour. It was in the second movement however where the animation of the piano was eclipsed by a candid lyricism. Once again Mr Slobodeniouk coaxed marvellous playing from the strings and, while the opening trill of the piano may have disturbed their tranquillity, the solo part soon settled into a mode that was both placidly expansive and quietly unsettled.
It was also in the second movement that trumpeter Florian Dörpholz quietly wrested attention away from the piano with a beautiful passage for muted trumpet. The arresting quality of his tone -which sounded like no muted trumpet that has ever appeared on any jazz record, but rather some mournful, alien instrument from a distant land- was matched by an equally haunting articulation of the melody.
A brief moderato interlude led directly into the boisterous final movement, in which the irreverent spirit of the piece was most apparent. Yet despite the comedic exaggerations -the loud piano thud midway through one of the trumpet’s sprightlier solos managed to get a chuckle from the audience- neither the soloists nor the conductor seemed inclined to overplay the more burlesque passages. At the same time, it was clear that everyone on the stage was enjoying themselves immensely and, even more so than in the Prokofiev concerto, the high spirits on stage quickly found their way into the audience. When the piece reached its breathless conclusion, the audience was so enthusiastic that Mr Trpčeski and Mr Dörpholz were called back to the stage some five times before the concert could resume.
After such a brilliant performance, the final piece of the evening -the orchestral suite from Prokofiev’s opera The Love of Three Oranges- could not help but feel somewhat pedestrian. The large orchestra handled the grand effects and dramatic flourishes -and the suite is essentially a compendium of dramatic flourishes- with full dedication, and there were numerous passages (perhaps most notably the march section) which delighted through their giddy momentum. But for all the dazzling gestures, it never quite reached the heights of inspiration of the preceding concerto.
Both Prokofiev and Shostakovich would go on to write works of greater seriousness, some patriotic, some introspective, and some despairing. While neither would ever lose their sense of humour entirely -just listen for the quotations in Shostakovich’s Fifteenth symphony- the joyful irreverence of their earlier works would become less pronounced as their compositional horizons expanded. The pieces performed on this evening may have been youthful in spirit but it was the serious commitment of the performances that allowed their good humour to shine.
Comentarios