Alemania
Hidden Treasures
Bernard Haitink didn’t bother telling anyone it was his birthday. He took the stage, led the Berlin Philharmonic through two intriguing, often brilliant performances of Beethoven pieces, tolerated the applause of the audience, then returned to the backstage whence he had emerged. Just an ordinary night, then. But if Mr Haitink seemed largely indifferent to the spotlight, his reserve left ample room for Isabelle Faust – who performed the solo part of the Violin Concerto in the first half of the programme – to establish herself as the star of the evening.
Yet Ms Faust has never been one to draw attention to her own considerable talents. Her performances of Bach’s Sonatas and Partitas at the Kammermusiksaal last year – an evening which belongs near the top of a short list of genuinely extraordinary recitals – were remarkable for their great humility. Indeed Ms Faust seems less interested in dazzling the audience with bravura than with putting her resources at the command of the score; and on this evening the sum of those resources resulted in a Violin Concerto that was technically accomplished, musically insightful and, quite simply, a joy to hear.
There was little obviously romantic in Ms Faust’s performance, which is not to say that it lacked anything in depth or feeling, but rather that it was free of grand gesture and sentimental effect. Yet while her playing was characterised by a great clarity and control – even in the most crowded passages, the individual notes never sounded as though they were getting in the way of one another – it never came at the expense of excitement.
Perhaps the most impressive aspect of Ms Faust’s performance was the way that she managed to conceal the brilliance of her technique. While there were a few passages in which one was forced to consider the physical demands of the piece – the subtle diminuendo during the long trill that precedes the reappearance of the principal theme in the first movement was all the more astonishing if one stopped to consider its difficulty – her virtuosity was never presented as an end unto itself. If indeed she was trying to impress us, it was with Beethoven’s score rather than her own skill.
Even the first movement cadenza – Ms Faust performed her own arrangement of the version written by Beethoven when he reworked the piece as a piano concerto – managed to be invigorating without being flashy. The cadenza, with its unexpected appearance of the timpani, is both unashamedly heroic and fiendishly complex, but the assurance and vigour of Ms Faust’s playing allowed its musical spirit to emerge triumphant. At the end of the second movement, she achieved a stunning lyricism that was all the more expressive for sounding so unforced; and in the Rondo, her spirited dance through the main theme was bold and energetic.
For the duration of the concerto, Ms Faust received support from Mr Haitink and the Berlin Philharmonic that was unquestionably solid and frequently opulent. Although Mr Haitink was not without the occasional idiosyncrasy – the opening of the first movement, especially, sounded oddly deliberate – he was able to summon a sound from the orchestra that many conductors are simply unable to achieve. The tuttis were muscular and substantial rather than merely loud, and the strings possessed an appealing weight. Indeed the generous heft of the orchestra provided a perfect balance to the incisive grace of the violin. Yet when it was all over, one was left with the sense that Ms Faust would have elevated any performance of the concerto. The fact that she had a great orchestra and a venerable conductor was more luxury than necessity.
After much applause, Ms Faust returned to the stage for an encore as remarkable as it was brief. The ‘Doloroso’ from György Kurtág’s Signs, Games and Messages for Strings was a strange, highly concentrated and completely mesmerising exercise in oblique form. While this introspective miniature was worlds removed from the preceding concerto, it was performed with a similar dedication and selflessness.
The orchestral forces were slightly expanded – more strings, more brass – for the second half of the programme, which featured Beethoven’s Sixth Symphony (a work that was delightfully at odds with the surprise snowstorm through which most of the audience had been forced to walk earlier that evening). If Mr Haitink’s interpretation was fascinatingly uneven – there were many extraordinary passages, along with one or two that seemed curiously restrained – there could be no doubting his mastery of the orchestra. Even by the standards of the Berlin Philharmonic, there was something endlessly compelling about the rich sounds emerging from the stage on this evening.
Mr Haitink took the first movement at a tempo that was close to ideal, not slow by any means, but spacious and unhurried. If there were occasional passages that sounded a touch rigid, they were soon forgotten when the sound of the strings began to expand with organic splendour. If Mr Haitink was applying his own interpretive touches to the movement, he was doing so with such subtlety as to be almost undetected; one was far more aware of the composer than the conductor.
It was the second movement, however, that would prove to be the most astonishing part of the performance. The mood of quiet serenity that is so often imposed onto Beethoven’s ‘Scene by the brook’ was largely abandoned in favour of a constant, almost hypnotic sense of movement. However Mr Haitink’s surprisingly brisk (albeit remarkably effective) pace was less arresting than the textural details he was able to bring so casually to the surface; there was hardly a single bar in which something was not fluttering or murmuring or undulating, carrying the piece forward with rhythmic insistence and natural beauty. Few other performances of this movement have sounded so fully alive.
If the remainder of the symphony could not quite recapture that magic, there were nonetheless a handful of wonderful passages. The peasant dance sounded a touch driven – only a sober peasant could dance with such precision – but the storm was genuinely thrilling, featuring a terrifyingly large full orchestra sound and excellent playing from the double basses. Only in the meandering final movement, which sounded pleasant enough but seemed to lack something in focus, was there a sense that the performance was starting to run out of steam.
But such concerns did not ultimately detract from the impression of having heard two Beethoven performances of a very high calibre. While Mr Haitink or Ms Faust would undoubtedly wish to draw attention away from themselves and give credit to Beethoven’s scores, it is worth remembering how easy it is for these two much-performed works to sound merely average. It requires the highest level of skill to conceal oneself so successfully behind one’s own performance.
Comentarios