Reportajes

Postmodernity: the doubt as a form of civilization; certainty as barbarism

Enrique Sacau
9,61E-05 Postmodernity has aroused many reactions among historians around the world. As was expected, musicology has not been apart from this process of debate and the own musical interpretation has been affected by the new philosophical tendencies.One of the last contribuitions has been Prof. Reinhard Strohm's article Postmodern Thought and the Historiy of Music: Some Intersections, published at the Revista Portuguesa de Musicologia, 9, directed by Manuel Carlos de Brito. This synthesis, suported on a precise bibliography, offers a reflection on some points of essential interest focused on some aspects: periodizations, perspectives of anti-modernity, the reception of premodern music, the conflict that serious opera represents to differenciate between modern and postmodern perspectives, and the interpretation of Ancient Music in relation to the concept of author and composition.It has been assumed, on the one hand, that postmodernity is a cultural atmosphere and not a specific theory -something that Strohm makes clear form the introduction-, what implies that postmodern thought must be regarded as a form of critic to modernity that may allow to observe what is what it has left behind. With the progressive abolition of absolute truth in favour of paradigms -a contribuition if not totally postmodern, at least adopted by this tendency- we move along a path of doubts that permits to work in a critic way on traditional concepts.Postmodernity as an open concept of progress which allows us to doubt in a methodical way of former modernity has sometimes led the scholar to the consider the past two hundred and fifty years -the modern era- as a period of obscurity and slavery of reaseon and technique. This way, the postmodern thought is associated to irrationalism and to the antiuniversalism by which the postmodern accuses rationalism of deceiving the world with its kindness to destroy it afterwards with its method.The postmodern does not pretend to destroy the world it inherits, but to settle down in it and to persevere in its critics to the ruling modernity. It has been asserted many times that Nietzsche is the first postmodern (Vattimo asserts this of the defender of will as human being's legitimate motor and as one of the antirationalistic philosophers). In this continuity, the central element of the structure of social relations shall be the consumer and not the worker. Thus, in this intellectual atmosphere, there is a sensation to be living a new stage of breaking with modernity, that would have led to the absence of any law and the tyranny of the market. Strohm speaks of divided retrospection to refer this phenomenon in which the grandson seems to be admiring more his grandfather than his father, due to the feeling of nostalgia that he feels for the former. The importance of this nostalgia leads to the search of any truth in a past that is not well enough discovered and whose traces are reality and not the past himself. This way, as Croce asserted, any history is contemporary history.Besides, literary critic is introduced in the historic discourse, something that has a dangerous side since, exaggerated, could lead us to take Snow White as a text of similar rank as The invention of Tradition, by Eric Hobsbawm -to propose but two extreme examples-. These exaggerations, which have happened in the theories of the communication and the relativity of the truth, make Baudrillard speak of a inexistant Gulf War, only valid while it was possible to watch it on television. The bombed's suffering, unverifiable and unobserved through it, seems not to exist for the French philosopher.The question of periodizations and Europe out of the centre of the Universe This open concept of the vision of history permits to doubt about periodizations and tries to establish new settings to study a past that has become multilinear.The charge of antiuniversalism brought against postmodernity could be lessened because it has permitted the reduction of eurocentrism in the production and the consumption of music. In a non-eurocentric world, African or Asian music will have to share in the ways of studying the common past of the musical phenomenon. To differeciate stages implies, besides, the great teleology of progress that Strohm mentions, something that the postmoderns fight, but in which they fall inevitably, for they are aware of their own time differentiated from modernity and a stage of changes that implies the failure of the former process. The postmodern fights, therefore, against the traditional periodizations, but offers new ones that frequently rests on the similar criteria to which they renounce. In this way, the postmodern tries to remove the periodization's barriers and tries not to conquer history -which means for a postmodern that he tries not to know history-, but to approach it ironically. This will have a large repercution on the postmodern musical production and will link with the premodern musical forms of production. For the postmoderns there is a time in which the rigid eurocentric concept of author and composition wins the power by the hand of modernity and reason, something that the postmoderns reject as monotonous and excessively directed.Antimodern perspectives This stage would lead to a progressive stagnation of the forms -something inseparable from the great germanic tradition defended by some philosophers like Adorno-, that has ended up by leading the romantic musicians to enlarge the dimensions of their compositions -Mahler is a splendid example-. The music evolves towards atonality and dodecafonism and detaches from the public's taste -a consumer for the postmoderns-, which leads to the lack of communication between musician and spectator. After them, the postmoderns go back to a past that is not contaminated by this exacerbated tradition and produce to sell. For the postmoderns, modernity is the way that has led with her the concepts of reason -as formula of progress- and idealism -as essence of progress-, that has led most of the central-european musical tradition to a divorce with the public. The case of opera, which we sall mention later on, was very different.Strohm's proposal depends on a necessary reopening of modernity, but not on the postmodern's tendence to irrationalism planned by some postmoderns.The reception of premodern music This field has been the main one for the postmoderns from the Second World War and even before, with the definitive Händel and Bach boom during the inter-war period. The similarity founded between the postmodern forms of composition (far from reality from the rigidity raised from the concepts of author and composition, linked, by the way, to a historiographic tendency as historicism, anchored in the event and the figure) and those preceding the XVIIIth century lead to a new interpretative field in which the performance, with its implicit spontaneity, replaces the concert.Leon Botstein, in a similar position as the one held by the reformers of modernity from inside, proposes the need of a change in the way of offering pure romantic music to the public, in order to permit her survival. John Cage, on his part, is a perfect example of the musician that has tried to remove the idea of the composer as Deus et machina and the concert's traditional liturgy. The composition, the result of a certain context, does not belong any more only to the composer and belongs to the performer and the public too -something of which 4'33'' is a celebrated example-.The island of opera In the middle of this strong discussion, the opera has remained in the centre and the changes have been minimum. The repertoire has changed less than what it may seem because, though scores have been recovered by hundreds, mainly from the XVIIth and XVIIIth centuries, only a few of them have entered the theatres' standard schedulings. Most of the little-known operas frequent recordings -rare operas, as said by some label- from before the XVIIIth century has not put them in the theatres but for ephimere tours. It is interesting, anyway, to dispose of this rarities, for it allows us a more profound knowledge of the history of music. The problem of opera's constant reform is posed in the usual dichotomy Hasse / Glück. The modern thought belives in opera's reforms supported by its ideal of progress and considers that there lies the survival of a genre in good health. This confrontation, somehow Manichean, prevents from following the impossibility of formal changes strong enough as to hinder us to realise of the mozartian synthesis, in whose subjects we find the Romanticism, but in whose forms we are yet too near to Händel and the da capo aria. This way, the discussion about opera is lessened because the genre has known how to survive and has brought, even in the second half of the XXth century, some titles that have found an important place in the international repertoire, to begin with some operas by Benjamin Britten.The interpretation and its great revolution The ways of interpretation are basic to understand the postmodern atmosphere in the music background. It is basic to pose some questions. To what extent the postmodern does not contradict itself when it applies criteria that are thought to be objective to ancient music's musical interpretation and pretending to reproduce canonically the interpretative techniques of those far-off times? Can the word canonic be associated to a sentence in which we speak about postmodern thought? Yet, in practice they are associated. And it is done because postmodernity is at the same time the sublimation of the modernity and the critic to it, logical (inevitable?) consequence and constant scourge. The liberty in the accompaniment in any pretendedly historicist interpretation of Ancient Music is another bridge between postmodernity and premodernity, not to forget -as Strohm asserts- that talking about postmodernity we talk about three periods. If any history is contemporary history, so can be any music.Some important questions Upon professor Strohm's text I have tried to pose some questions and my doubts, started from the postmodern critic. I will resume them in a questionnaire which I consider basic.1. It is clear that postmodernity has contributed to eradicate eurocentrism from the musical phenomenon. To what extent can we accuse postmodernity of being antiuniversalist?2. Historians have assumed that a History based upon the concepts of personage and event must be banished. It seems obvious that musicologists should equally banish the study of Music according to author and composition with another reason to add to those of historians, provided that if any event is blocked in the past (a battle or a treaty's firm), any composition is present every time that it is played. The author is reborn every time that the composition is played, something that does not happen with a historic personage. We must therefore pose this question: is any musical interpretation contemporary music?3. In the dissipation of the rigidity of the concept of authorship and composition we must think about this: which is the real relation between the forms of musical production and diffusion in the postmodern and premodern worlds?4. As Strohm raises in his conclusion, asserting the close relation between the postmodern and the modern discourse in musicology, do we really live a different phase from the former as to speak of a new era?5. Which is the real problem of periodizations? What have the postmoderns brought to this field?6. Until when can we conceive the history of music from the traditional eurocentric perspective?References-BARROS, Carlos: Historiografía fin de siglo Ed. Tórculo. 1998.-BAUDRILLARD: El paroxista indiferente-BRITO, Manuel Carlos de: Historiography Bärenreiter-Verlag Basel. Acta Musicológica. Sociète International de Musicologie. Vol. LXIX-1997. Fasc. I Enero-Junio. Pp. 22-29.-BOTSTEIN, Leon: The audience The Musical Quarterly. Winter 1999. Volume 83. Number 4-BOURDÉ, Guy y MARTIN, Hervé: Las escuelas históricas Ed. Akal.-BURKHOLDER, Peter J.: Music theory and musicology The journal of Musicology. Vol. XI. Nº 1. Winter. California. 1993.-CARRERAS, Juan José: La Historiografía artística de la música (AULLÓN DE HARO, Pedro (dir.): Teoría de la historia de la literatura y el arte Revista publicada por el Seminario de de Teoría de la Literatura y Literatura comparada de la Universidad de Alicante. Alicante. 1994. Pp. 277-307)-CASCUDO, Teresa: El lenguaje de la música: Variaciones sobre una metáfora sugerente Ed. Verbum. Universidad de Alicante. Revista Teoría/Crítica. Alicante.1996.-DAHLHAUS, Carl: Foundations of music history Cambridge University Press. New York. 1983.-GRIFFITHS, Paul: Brève histoire de la musique moderne: de Debussy à Boulez Les chemins de la musique. Fayard. Paris, 1992.-GROUT, D. J.: Current Historiography and Music History (Editado en POWERS, H.: Studies in Music History. Essays for Oliver Strunk Princeton. 1968)-HUTCHEON, Linda: The Pastime of Past Time (PERLOFF, Marjorie (dir.): Postmodern genres University of Oklahoma Press. Norman, Oklahoma. 1988. Pp. 54-57)-KERMAN, Joseph: Musicology Fontana Press/Collins. London. 1985-LYON, David: Postmodernidad Alianza editorial. Madrid. 1996.-LÓPEZ-CALO, José: Barbieri y la Historiografía de la Música española (En Documentos sobre Música y Músicos españoles Madrid. 1986)-MOLINO, Jean: L'art aujourd'hui Esprit. París. Julio-Agosto. 1991.-RAMEAU, Jean-Philippe: Traité de l'harmonie Imprimerie Ballard. París. 1722 (Edición facsímil realizada por Arte Tripharia en Madrid en abril de 1984)-ROUSSEAU, Jean-Jacques: Traitès sur la Musique (De las Obras Completas. Tomo XVI. Ginebra. 1782)-STROHM, Reinhard: Postmodern Thought and the History of Music: Some Intersections Revista Portuguesa de Musicología (Número 9). Lisboa. 1999.-TREITLER, Leo: Music and the historical Imagination Harvard University Press. Cambridge, Massachusets. 1989.-WEISS, Piero y TARUSKIN, Peter: Music in the western world. A history in documents Schirmer Books. New York. 1984.
Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.