Estados Unidos

Reveries and Passions Part 2: Exotic Visions

Jesse Simon
Reveries and Passions Part 2: Exotic Visions
Chicago, jueves, 21 de mayo de 2015.
Symphony Center. Debussy: Syrinx. Ravel: Piano Concerto in G Major. Messiaen: Turangalîla-symphonie. Samuel Coles, flute. Jean-Yves Thibaudet, piano. Valérie Hartmann-Claverie, ondes Martenot. Chicago Symphony Orchestra. Esa-Pekka Salonen, conductor
0,0001475

The final orchestral programme of the Reveries and Passions festival -a three week series of French music organised by the Chicago Symphony Orchestra and Esa-Pekka Salonen- featured three works of vastly different scale, connected by their respective fascinations with the exotic. Syrinx, Debussy’s brief meditation for solo flute, drew its inspiration from a Greek myth, while Ravel’s genial G major Piano Concerto added flourishes of American jazz to the composer’s customary ibericisms. Together, these two works formed a prelude to Messiaen’s mighty Turangalîla-symphonie, which employs birdsong and the otherworldly sound of the ondes Martenot to illuminate of the myth of Tristan and Yseult. In the course of the evening, all three pieces would receive performances of considerable inspiration.

Although the concert would culminate in the sound of an ecstatic massed orchestra, it began in an entirely less assuming manner. The lights dimmed on an empty stage and a single spotlight illuminated the figure of flautist Samuel Coles who proceeded to give a delightful account of Debussy’s Syrinx. Mr Coles’ playing had an exceptional fluidity that was matched with a strong sense of the work’s internal rhythms; his quick runs up and down the stave emerged from his instrument less as notated music than as a single unbroken thought. While it lasted only a few moments, it served as a brilliant overture to the programme.

The continually searching stream of notes that formed Syrinx was mirrored to some extent in the solo part of Ravel’s G major Piano Concerto, which was given a memorably magnificent performance on this evening by Jean-Yves Thibaudet. During the whole of the first movement, Mr Thibaudet gave the impression that the sttings of the piano were being hit by something far more gentle than a hammer; even during his most rapid tours of the keyboard’s extremities, there was an arresting softness to his playing that was matched by an extraordinary agility. Yet for all the necessary virtuosity, Mr Thibaudet played with a lack of ostentation; rather than articulating and underlining the suggestions of melody, he allowed them to emerge naturally from the continuous flow of notes. The calm but intensely focused introduction to the second movement was especially compelling.

Mr Thibaudet received near-ideal support from Mr Salonen and the orchestra. While Mr Salonen’s reading lacked nothing in energy and vigour, he managed to steer completely clear of bombast or caricature. Rather than overstating the exoticisms in Ravel’s orchestration, he preferred to tease out the subtleties, and the result was much closer in spirit to the gauzy sound-world of Debussy. Between the effervescent pianism of Mr Thibaudet and some superb playing from the orchestra, the Piano Concerto was an effortless triumph.

When the audience returned for the second half of the performance, the orchestra had doubled in size. To the left of the podium a celesta, a glockenspiel and a vibraphone had appeared behind the piano, while on the right sat the lesser-spotted ondes Martenot. By the late 1940s Messiaen was already no stranger to grand themes, but in the Turangalîla-symphonie he was able to match his expansive vision with orchestral forces of commensurate scale. On this evening, Mr Salonen presided over those forces with discipline and passion, flirting occasionally with chaos but never losing sight of the work’s grand architecture.

Mr Salonen’s opening movement was forceful, urgent and perhaps even a touch brisk – the first appearance of the tremendous ‘statue’ theme might have benefitted from a more spacious, reverent approach – but he was able to achieve a balanced, detailed orchestral sound that was immediately impressive. If the Ravel concerto in the first half had been notable for its refined softness, the opening of the Turangalîla-symphonie served as notice that the orchestra was equally capable of playing that was bold, incisive and invigorating.

While many of Messiaen’s works aim to convey a sense of spiritual awe, the Turangalîla-symphonie is somewhat unique in its fascination with the physical; the fact did not go unacknowledged by Mr Salonen, who seems to have instructed the orchestra to perform the second movement as though it were Le sacre du printemps. The wonderful contrasts between the calm, melodic string interludes and the rhythmic assurance of the full-orchestra sections gave the movement an appealing sense of controlled abandon. Mr Salonen clearly had little intention of smoothing the edges of Messiaen’s volatile sonic constructions.

The symphony’s all-important piano part was given a consistently mesmerising performance by Mr Thibaudet. Although he was still capable of the delicate melodic flow that characterised the Ravel concerto, there was more clarity in his articulation and far greater force in his attack. He was excellent throughout, providing a bed of trills for the strings in the fourth movement, trading languid birdsong with the woodwinds in sixth and contributing to the feverish excitement of the fifth and tenth movements.

Valérie Hartmann-Claverie gave an equally distinguished (albeit very different) performance on the ondes Martenot. Indeed, the instrument itself seemed to generate a certain amount interest … after the performance, a number of people walked to the front of the hall for a closer look. Yet if the ondes Martenot remains a relatively rare sight, it nonetheless plays a crucial role in the Turangalîla-symphonie and Ms Hartmann-Claverie – who has appeared on numerous recordings over the past two decades and, on this evening, had the distinction of being the only musician on stage without a score – performed the part flawlessly.

However the whole orchestra seems to have been energised by the piece. The various metallophones performed with unfailing commitment, especially in what must have been a physically exhausting fifth movement, and the strings – who had been such a highlight of the previous week’s performances of Pelléas et Mélisande – were wonderful throughout. No less impressive were the trombones who managed to contribute tremendous weight to the orchestral sound without adding excessive volume, and whose profound interjections gave the piece its necessary gravitas.

Although Mr Salonen’s vision of the score had a remarkable consistency, he seemed to thrive in those sections where the music grew especially complex. Only in the fifth movement were there a few moments where the competing orchestral forces seemed in danger of obscuring the clarity of the music. For the most part, however, even the most unwieldy sections were handled with great assurance: the fourth movement was breathtaking and the continual climaxes of the eighth were rendered with a gripping intensity.

The Turangalîla-symphonie is undoubtedly a demanding work and it was a great privilege to hear performances of such commitment and inspiration from the soloists, the orchestra and the conductor; but while the monumental nature of Messiaen’s score could have easily overshadowed anything around it, the success of this particular evening lay not in the execution of any one piece, but rather in the curious balance between the three. The exotic visions of Debussy, Ravel and Messiaen seemed to complement one another perfectly.

Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.