Alemania
Structures and Surfaces
Anyone hoping for a traditional Faust would have been very disappointed. Philipp Stölzl’s glossy new staging of Gounod’s much-loved opera – the Deutsche Oper’s final new production of the season – featured plenty of high-concept, lots of flashing lights, some bumper cars, and one of the creepiest choirs ever to appear on an opera-house stage. It was also, in its own peculiar way, quite affecting, and it certainly did no disservice to an evening which also featured a number of distinguished vocal performances, as well as some of the most luxurious playing to emerge from the pit of the Deutsche Oper in recent memory.
Gounod himself supervised several different versions of Faust in his lifetime and, during the past century and a half, the structure and content of the work has always remained somewhat in flux. The version performed on this evening was no exception: it was presented in four acts (the first was a composite of Acts One and Two, minus the second-act confrontation between Valentin and Méphistophélès), and the final act unsurprisingly skipped most of the ballet. The cuts, however, did not seem especially intrusive and, indeed, had the effect of both streamlining the narrative and shifting the focus emphatically in the direction of Marguerite; the opera, at least in Mr Stölzl’s interpretation, was very much her tragedy.
Even in his opera productions, Mr Stölzl – perhaps inevitably, given his background – tends to work within a recognisably cinematic vocabulary. His Faust was full of the stage equivalents of freeze-frames and long takes, while the action seemed to be governed by the idea that movement and interaction should remain, at some level, in the service of the image. Indeed the evening’s most successful moments often came from the dynamic accumulation of visual elements; by contrast, those scenes that relied too heavily on character interaction within a static setting – witness the long courtship duet of Marguerite and Faust – tended to suffer.
Fortunately, the production was given a near-constant sense of motion through its ingenious use of the revolving stage. The rear of the stage was hidden by a large curved structure resembling the base of a castle turret, which allowed elements to be added and removed from the setting without the visual intrusion of stage-hands. If the revolving stage can occasionally come across as a theatrical gimmick, here it proved to be an essential tool for the expression of Mr Stölzl’s long, continuously unfolding tableaux. The logistics must have been a nightmare, but the effect was seamless and natural.

Gounod's Faust. Conductor: Marco Armiliato. Regie: Philipp Stölzl, Premiere: 19.06.2015, Deutsche Oper Berlin © Matthias Baus, 2015
Of course the visual world of Mr Stölzl bore little resemblance to any kind of conventional setting. The scene by the city walls was transferred to a fairground, and Marguerite lived in a comedically undersized camper-trailer somewhere deep in the forest. The choir, when they appeared, all wore grotesque baby-face masks and pale-coloured, oddly-scaled clothing – the costume design, by Ursula Kudma, was brilliant throughout – and the Walpurgis Night of the final act was replaced with a scene in which Marguerite, in prison, has a vividly tacky dream of her wedding festivities. While these visual departures enraged some of the purists in the audience – there was some audible booing when Mr Stölzl and his team appeared on stage at the end of the evening – they rarely seemed excessively provocative.
However if Mr Stölzl’s visual concept had an engaging lightness of touch, his dramatic vision was almost deadeningly serious. Even those scenes which could have been played for comedic effect – notably the seduction of Marthe by Méphistophélès – had an awkward straightness to them. For Mr Stölzl, the tragedy belonged to Marguerite alone – the entire story was framed as an extensive flashback in which Marguerite, awaiting execution in her jail cell, recalls in details the events leading to her downfall – and from her reluctant surrender to Faust to her eventual execution by lethal injection (an uncomfortable scene, somewhat transformed by Gounod’s rapturous music), the production took a certain grim delight in the unjust magnitude of her suffering.
The tragic approach might easily have been unrelenting were it not for the music, and the evening featured no scarcity of excellent performances. Of the secondary roles, Markus Brück proved especially impressive as Marguerite’s brother Valentin. Although his opening scene, bidding farewell to his sister as he prepares to leave for war, was appealingly tender, it was his final appearance, lying in the snow and cursing Marguerite for the loss of his life, that provided the evening with some of its most captivating vocal drama.
All three of the principal roles were well sung, to the point where it would be difficult to choose a single performance that stood out above the others. Ildebrando D’Arcangelo, in his shirtless tux, was charismatic and stern as Méphistophélès, delivering his numbers with a voice that was frequently lusty but, much like the production itself, always completely serious. His charm came from his ringmaster’s sense of control over every situation, but his menace came from the lack of irony that accompanied it. The success of Mr D’Arcangelo’s performance was that he kept the cackling and vocal exaggerations to a minimum, singing instead with a directness that put his cold calculation on prominent display.
The robust, expressive tenor of Teodor Ilincăi was well suited to the role of Faust. At his most passionate, he had no trouble filling the hall in a way that seemed effortless and wholly free of strain, and his cavatina in the second act – delivered with melodious ardour and grand romantic phrasing – was an especial delight.

Gounod's Faust. Conductor: Marco Armiliato. Regie: Philipp Stölzl, Premiere: 19.06.2015, Deutsche Oper Berlin © Matthias Baus, 2015
As the object of Faust’s desire, Krassimira Stoyanova may have lacked the delicate meekness that one might associate with Marguerite; but as the central figure in a tragic drama she was wholly compelling. She had a number of fine moments in the evening’s first half – most notably her excited song of the jewels – but it was in the second half that she began to establish herself as the focus of the action. The third act in particular was bookended by two wonderful scenes – her lament at being abandoned, and her thwarted attempts to pray – distinguished by Ms Stoyanova’s dramatic phrasing and elegant dynamic control.
The orchestra of the Deutsche Oper is always reliable and often excellent, but on this evening they were in a class by themselves, breathing as a single entity and exuding a remarkable warmth of tone. Marco Armiliato, who generally favoured tempi that were spacious but never overly slow, devoted as much attention to coaxing a polished sound from the orchestra as to locating the emotional essence of the individual scFaustenes, and the results were often stunning. Although there was a certain burnished softness in evidence throughout – even the ominous opening chord of the prelude seemed smooth around the edges – the orchestra remained capable of considerable animation, as in the lilting chorus at the end of the first act, and in the score’s most climactic moments they swelled with a magnificence that was enveloping but never overpowering.
Gounod’s Faust is ultimately a work of brilliant surfaces; it has traded the universality of the myth for grand emotions and, in doing so, has achieved a certain popularity within the standard operatic repertoire. Mr Stölzl’s staging was similarly a creation of high artifice: while one may not have emerged from the auditorium with a profoundly changed sense of Gounod’s opera, the appeal of the production lay primarily in the memorable strangeness of its imagery and the impressive efficiency of its presentation. The Deutsche Oper’s new Faust may not have looked traditional, but the unconcealed gorgeousness of the music and the confident execution of the production satisfied and entertained in a remarkably traditional way.
Comentarios