Alemania

A Matter of Balance

Jesse Simon
George Enescu
George Enescu © DM
Berlin, sábado, 20 de junio de 2015.
Philharmonie. Brahms: Violin Concerto in D, op. 77. Debussy: Images pour orchestre. Enescu: Romanian Rhapsody No. 1. Christian Tetzlaff, violin. Berlin Philharmonic. Sir Simon Rattle, conductor
0,0001646

Brahms has certainly not been in short supply over the past few seasons, but it was nonetheless fitting that the Berlin Philharmonic’s season, which opened with a complete cycle of the symphonies, should end with two different concert programmes, each featuring one of the composer’s great concertos. Indeed, the first of these programmes, which also included Debussy’s Images pour orchestre and the first of Enescu’s Romanian Rhapsodies, may have contained the orchestra’s most satisfying Brahms performance this year, a refined account of the Violin Concerto propelled by Christian Tetzlaff’s assured reading of the solo part.

It may seem odd to apply ‘conservative’ as an adjective of praise, but the evening’s performance of the Violin Concerto achieved its own particular greatness largely though moderation. The tempi seemed neither frantic nor drawn out, the balance of the orchestra was close to perfect, and few if any passages were approached in a wilful or unconventional manner. It was, on the surface, a performance willing to take few interpretive risks. Yet the decision to play it straight resulted in no lack of passion and, in fact, was ideally suited to the noble tone and subtly emotive phrasing of Mr Tetzlaff.

During the course of the first movement, Mr Tetzlaff placed the full spectrum of his approach on display. His first appearance had an urgency that recalled the stormy first movement of the same composer’s D minor Piano Concerto, and the controlled attack he brought to the chordal passages was frequently thrilling. Yet the first of his extended accompanied passages was played with a pleasingly lyrical sweep and subtly-applied vibrato that flirted occasionally with sentimentality but invariably demurred.

Perhaps the most impressive aspect of Mr Tetzlaff’s performance, however, was his ability to allow long phrases, remarkably focussed but with an edge of rhapsodic longing, to emerge organically from his instrument. In the spellbinding cadenza – Mr Tetzlaff performed Joseph Joachim’s – fanciful excursions up and down the stave were held in check by a sense of internal rhythm that seemed almost inevitable. While one would not describe the performance as old-fashioned, it nonetheless belonged to a tradition in which refined judgment was valued over fanciful excursions.

The orchestra, under the direction of Sir Simon Rattle, seemed perfectly content to follow Mr Tetzlaff’s lead. During the Brahms symphony concerts at the beginning of the season, one was occasionally left with a sense that the music had been over-considered, or that lines had been moulded in a deliberate, almost counter-intuitive manner. That was not the case on this evening. There was little in Sir Simon’s reading that sounded anything less than perfectly judged.

The Berlin Philharmonic, for their part, sounded as majestic and richly detailed as ever; from the expressive solo oboe in the second movement to the dramatic, enveloping sound of the full ensemble in the Finale, the orchestra demonstrated why they have few serious rivals when it comes to the music of Brahms. While there is no question that a slower, faster, more inwardly searching or more extravagantly reckless performance would have yielded different insights onto this much performed concerto, Mr Tetzlaff and the orchestra made a convincing case for the rewards of moderation and balance.

If the opening half of the concert adhered to tradition, the second offered a decisive departure. A small piece of paper included in the programme booklet announced that the order of Debussy’s Images pour orchestre, would be altered so that Rondes de printemps would serve as the second movement, and the work would conclude with the tripartite Ibéria. The decision may have been defensible on musicological grounds, but it proved to be largely unsuccessful in practice, upsetting the arch-like structure of Debussy’s final great orchestral work. Although the boisterous conclusion of Ibéria made for an exciting finale, Rondes was robbed of some of its mysterious majesty by being placed so close to Gigues, with which it shares certain qualities of rhythm and mood.

Despite the odd sequencing, the performances themselves were generally strong. Gigues was able to conjure a suitably misty mood, but rhythmically seemed a touch on the heavy side, as though the orchestra hadn’t fully switched out of Brahms mode; however it lacked nothing in drama and featured some spectacularly detailed strings in the quiet final passage. Rondes featured a similar atmosphere, a somewhat lighter touch and superb playing from the first violins; the accumulation of momentum and sound toward the end the movement was handled with considerable skill.

Ibéria however was probably the finest of the three. In the opening section, the orchestra were able to highlight the brilliance of Debussy’s orchestration, allowing one to follow the various echoing phrases as they passed from instrument to instrument. The nocturnal second section was sultry, mysterious and beautiful, due in large part to the luxurious playing of the full orchestra; and if there was a tendency in the finale to wind up the pace and to draw out the exotic elements, it was at least matched with a rhythmic excitement that brought the piece to a stirring conclusion.

The evening, however, was not quite over. Enescu’s Romanian Rhapsody No. 1, with its shepherd’s pipe woodwinds, breakneck string passages and romanticised folk melodies is an unrepentant crowd-pleaser, and neither Sir Simon nor the orchestra tried to pretend otherwise: it was a high-octane performance, played for maximum sweep and dazzle, and in that regard it was completely successful. The flutes and clarinets were a marvel and the strings navigated their most furious passages with just the right amount of exotic abandon. It was the kind of piece that could have gone on forever or stopped abruptly at any moment, and when it finally did end, the audience let out an enormous cheer.

After a few curtain calls, Sir Simon returned to the stage with a microphone; the evening’s performance, he announced, had been principal flautist Andreas Blau’s final concert as a member of the Berlin Philharmonic. Mr Blau, who joined the orchestra in 1969, has been a crucial part of the orchestra’s unparalleled woodwind section for more than four decades and on this evening his long-standing devotion to the musical life of the city was honoured with flowers, heartfelt words of appreciation from Sir Simon and an extended standing ovation from the audience.

Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.